Player A or Player B

[PHATJ]

Name..........AB ......R.....H....2B....3B....HR...RBI....SB......BB....K....AVG...OB....SLG....OPS

Player A ..... 513....90...125...34.....4.....26....68...10/14...51...126. .244. .316. .478.. .794


Player B ..... 522....84...159...32 .....7 ....10 ...65 ....8/12 ..42....70.. .305.. .357.. .450. .807

Also, can you guess each players WAR?

[@SkitchP]

Albert Pujols 2.5 and 2007 Chauncey Billups 1.9.

[PHATJ]

Albert Pujols 2.5 and 2007 Chauncey Billups 1.9.

Your on the right track...

[philpritchard]

Name..........AB ......R.....H....2B....3B....HR...RBI....SB......BB....K....AVG...OB....SLG....OPS

Player A ..... 513....90...125...34.....4.....26....68...10/14...51...126. .244. .316. .478.. .794


Player B ..... 522....84...159...32 .....7 ....10 ...65 ....8/12 ..42....70.. .305.. .357.. .450. .807

Also, can you guess each players WAR?

You can't really guess a player's WAR if you don't know his position, defensive ability, year, and, to a lesser extent, home stadium.

[BigRedLedbetter]

Name..........AB ......R.....H....2B....3B....HR...RBI....SB......BB....K....AVG...OB....SLG....OPS

Player A ..... 513....90...125...34.....4.....26....68...10/14...51...126. .244. .316. .478.. .794


Player B ..... 522....84...159...32 .....7 ....10 ...65 ....8/12 ..42....70.. .305.. .357.. .450. .807

Also, can you guess each players WAR?

You can't really guess a player's WAR if you don't know his position, defensive ability, year, and, to a lesser extent, home stadium.

Chud told you to post that didn't he? Be honest.

[philpritchard]

Name..........AB ......R.....H....2B....3B....HR...RBI....SB......BB....K....AVG...OB....SLG....OPS

Player A ..... 513....90...125...34.....4.....26....68...10/14...51...126. .244. .316. .478.. .794


Player B ..... 522....84...159...32 .....7 ....10 ...65 ....8/12 ..42....70.. .305.. .357.. .450. .807

Also, can you guess each players WAR?

You can't really guess a player's WAR if you don't know his position, defensive ability, year, and, to a lesser extent, home stadium.

Chud told you to post that didn't he? Be honest.

HE CAN'T TELL ME WHAT TO DO! HE'S NOT MY DAD!

[BigRedLedbetter]

Name..........AB ......R.....H....2B....3B....HR...RBI....SB......BB....K....AVG...OB....SLG....OPS

Player A ..... 513....90...125...34.....4.....26....68...10/14...51...126. .244. .316. .478.. .794


Player B ..... 522....84...159...32 .....7 ....10 ...65 ....8/12 ..42....70.. .305.. .357.. .450. .807

Also, can you guess each players WAR?

You can't really guess a player's WAR if you don't know his position, defensive ability, year, and, to a lesser extent, home stadium.

Chud told you to post that didn't he? Be honest.

HE CAN'T TELL ME WHAT TO DO! HE'S NOT MY DAD!

Dude, your cap locks is on.

[numbers]

Pedroia and someone else.

(I feel like these things are always Pedroia and some other 2B)

[BigRedLedbetter]

Maybe Brandon Phillips for one?

[philpritchard]

If one's Pedroia it would have to be Player B considering the OBP. Player A is a low-OBP/high-power guy.

[BigRedLedbetter]

At first I thought A was Mark Reynolds but not near enough K's.

[PHATJ]

You guys are on the right track, but Pedroia isn't one of them. Brandon Phillips is a good guess too, but not correct.

That's true on guessing WAR. As soon as we guess the players I'd like to see what your guesses are on their WAR.

Who do you guys think is the better offensive player?

[@SkitchP]

You guys are on the right track, but Pedroia isn't one of them. Brandon Phillips is a good guess too, but not correct.

That's true on guessing WAR. As soon as we guess the players I'd like to see what your guesses are on their WAR.

Just name it damn it.

and as phil pointed out, you cant guess war without defense, park, etc.

[PHATJ]

You guys are on the right track, but Pedroia isn't one of them. Brandon Phillips is a good guess too, but not correct.

That's true on guessing WAR. As soon as we guess the players I'd like to see what your guesses are on their WAR.

Just name it damn it.

and as phil pointed out, you cant guess war without defense, park, etc.

They are both second basemen... Both A.L.

[@SkitchP]

Player B is altuve and Player A is whoever the 2B is for the Twins.

[Norah]

Player B is not Altuve.

[@SkitchP]

Player B is not Altuve.

The problem is, no one actually cares. This thread stinks.

[Norah]

Player B is not Altuve.

The problem is, no one actually cares. This thread stinks.

I agree.

[PHATJ]

Player A is Brian Dozier and Player B is Ian Kinsler. Who is the better player?

[Norah]

Kinsler