Moonlander - Stone Gossard

[EJ]

There's nothing "Folk" about "I Need Something Different" or "Moonlander."

[warehouse]

its "Folk Rock", you idiots

It's not that either, jackass.

look dickhead, im not about to argue about an album i havent even heard. lets agree to call it "folk rock" and back to jew puns

Jewlander

[Jorge]

Shabbattle Cry

[Strat]

*reports*

[WtOB?]

its "Folk Rock", you idiots

It's not that either, jackass.

look dickhead, im not about to argue about an album i havent even heard. lets agree to call it "folk rock" and back to jew puns

Jewlander

Things are starting to heat up guys.

[Norah]

So help me Yahweh if this thread gets deleted...

[B]

There's nothing "Folk" about "I Need Something Different" or "Moonlander."

There's nothing "Rock" about "Both Live," "Your Flames," or "Battle Cry."

[Norah]

There's nothing "Folk" about "I Need Something Different" or "Moonlander."

There's nothing "Rock" about "Both Live," "Your Flames," or "Battle Cry."

Yes, yes there is.

[WtOB?]

C'mon. Let's stop this bullshit.

[WtOB?]

This is not the kind of heat I enjoy. This is genre-defining heat.

[Jorge]

This isn't heat, this is just B not knowing what the hell he's talking about.

[Norah]

This isn't heat, this is just B not knowing what the hell he's talking about.

Seriously.

[warehouse]

So help me Yahweh if this thread gets deleted...

this was great

first few times i heard "your flame" it kinda reminded me of a country song. although i think this was around the time stone was playing hank williams songs so maybe thats why it reminds me of a country song.

[B]

There's nothing "Folk" about "I Need Something Different" or "Moonlander."

There's nothing "Rock" about "Both Live," "Your Flames," or "Battle Cry."

Yes, yes there is.

Well, I crafted the post to look like EJ's post. There is something rock there, but those are not rock songs. And as it stands, they're the majority of songs released for this album.

I don't say it in a disparaging way, but so far, this is not a rock album. At the very least, it's a mix of several genres.

[Norah]

There's nothing "Folk" about "I Need Something Different" or "Moonlander."

There's nothing "Rock" about "Both Live," "Your Flames," or "Battle Cry."

Yes, yes there is.

Well, I crafted the post to look like EJ's post. There is something rock there, but those are not rock songs. And as it stands, they're the majority of songs released for this album.

I don't say it in a disparaging way, but so far, this is not a rock album. At the very least, it's a mix of several genres.

Go read the wikipedia article on rock music.

[B]

I'll take wikipedia's word on rock music the same day I take your word on the quality of Riot Act.

[Norah]

You're an idiot.

[Farmer John]

Doesn't the use of an oboe in Both Live automatically rule it out of being a rock song?

[B]

[Norah]

Yeah, because wind instruments have never been used in rock songs before.