bodysnatcher wrote:I have no doubt that there are probably 20 extra songs hanging out on the shelves from the last 3 albums... the question is how complete they are. Are they just basic song structures? Much like the demos of S/T that popped up with Ed just mumbling.
Question: If there were really basic song demos from Vs–Yield... would you rather hear those with possible Ed mumbling melodies on top? Or would you rather have them, as current PJ, flesh them out and finish them off as complete songs?
why not do both? kind of like a bob dylan bootleg series release
I'm not remotely interested in hearing Yield outtakes ruined by Ed's awful newish singing habits and the bumbling efforts of their current mastering house of choice.
and that's exactly why if they're going to do that they should also include the unadulterated takes
bodysnatcher wrote:I have no doubt that there are probably 20 extra songs hanging out on the shelves from the last 3 albums... the question is how complete they are. Are they just basic song structures? Much like the demos of S/T that popped up with Ed just mumbling.
Question: If there were really basic song demos from Vs–Yield... would you rather hear those with possible Ed mumbling melodies on top? Or would you rather have them, as current PJ, flesh them out and finish them off as complete songs?
why not do both? kind of like a bob dylan bootleg series release
I'm not remotely interested in hearing Yield outtakes ruined by Ed's awful newish singing habits and the bumbling efforts of their current mastering house of choice.
and that's exactly why if they're going to do that they should also include the unadulterated takes
bodysnatcher wrote:I have no doubt that there are probably 20 extra songs hanging out on the shelves from the last 3 albums... the question is how complete they are. Are they just basic song structures? Much like the demos of S/T that popped up with Ed just mumbling.
Question: If there were really basic song demos from Vs–Yield... would you rather hear those with possible Ed mumbling melodies on top? Or would you rather have them, as current PJ, flesh them out and finish them off as complete songs?
why not do both? kind of like a bob dylan bootleg series release
I'm not remotely interested in hearing Yield outtakes ruined by Ed's awful newish singing habits and the bumbling efforts of their current mastering house of choice.
and that's exactly why if they're going to do that they should also include the unadulterated takes
Is this entire discussion based in some rumor on the pit about them just being in atlanta? Did I read that right a few pages ago?
I think I did read that correctly, and this is all just wasted text. No way there is another rarities album chock full of magically unearthed material. Sorry guys, not going to happen.
I fully expect that they have made it to the studio for a few days once or twice in the last 18 months, and maybe recently in Atlanta, even. But that most certainly is at most one of 4-5 one week recording sessions that they will spread out over three years before they cobble together twelve tunes for an album.
I mean, have they surprised us with anything really in the last decade? Why start now.
hlniv wrote:Is this entire discussion based in some rumor on the pit about them just being in atlanta? Did I read that right a few pages ago?
I think I did read that correctly, and this is all just wasted text. No way there is another rarities album chock full of magically unearthed material. Sorry guys, not going to happen.
I fully expect that they have made it to the studio for a few days once or twice in the last 18 months, and maybe recently in Atlanta, even. But that most certainly is at most one of 4-5 one week recording sessions that they will spread out over three years before they cobble together twelve tunes for an album.
I mean, have they surprised us with anything really in the last decade? Why start now.
90% of the "covers" listed on the official site are fragments that were referenced in tags and whatnot. It does nothing but to the clutter up the list and confuse people.
