II-1: Wishlist v Cropduster

[stip]

Vote

[ABNorman]

Ok.

[stip]

Did you?

[stip]

Wishlist, easily, though Cropduster is a perfectly cromulent song. But Wishlist has that wonderful solo and is the rare love song that finds something interesting to say about relationships.

[chewm]

Wishlist is good but this is not even close.

[PHATJ]

Sorry Wishlist, Cropduster is just so nice.

[ABNorman]

Did you?

I did. Wishlist. Riot Act is the worst.

[Bammer]

Very hard choice here. Going with Cropduster because I had that song stuck in my head once for like an entire year.

[Kevin Davis]

I love "Wishlist" and I love the word "cromulent," but "Cropduster" has to take this one.

[darth_vedder]

spenno helped turn me around on cropduster. i still don't love it, but it has really climbed in my rankings, and it gets my vote this round.

[Kaius]

I love Cropduster, but I've really been digging Wishlist since this started.

[evenslow]

This is a real coin flip between two very different songs that I like for very different reasons.

I'll have to go with my sentimental favorite Wishlist, which is a song we don't talk much about on this board, but it's subtle and beautiful and just right.

Plus Ed was able to get to the e-bow on it.

[LoathedVermin72]

This is really close. Almost too close to call. But I went with "Wishlist".

[digster]

Two songs I like a lot, and both have very different aims. I think for the moment I'll go with Wishlist; there's something really disarming about the simplicity, and Mike's little solo is one of his best moments.

[seba88arg]

I like Wishlist but Cropduster is amazing

[darth_vedder]

I wish I could click with Cropduster and Evacuation the way RM has. Both songs have climbed their way out of the bottom and into mid tier levels for me though.

[WaitingForBluey]

Cropduster is a top 10 PJ song for me and perhaps Matt Cameron's greatest contribution to the band. Wishlist is a fine little ditty but it's not on par with Cropduster. #TeamRiotAct

[stip]

Two songs I like a lot, and both have very different aims. I think for the moment I'll go with Wishlist; there's something really disarming about the simplicity, and Mike's little solo is one of his best moments.

it's his second or third best, I think. It's a gem.

[Birds in Hell]

Cropduster is everything I wish modern-day Pearl Jam was more often.

[hlniv]

Cropduster. I'm always up for it.

And wishlist is even one of my go-to lullabies that I have sung / still sing to my kids.