III-45: Hail Hail vs. Daughter

[LetMeSleep]

This is the toughest decision so far.

Irons is great, yet Daughter has the better drumming.

It's funny -- I always associate Abbruzzesse's drumming as being super cymbal happy, like he was on Vs. But then he totally changed his style for Vitalogy, really took a much more straight-forward approach on those songs. I don't give him enough credit for that.

Agreed. He seems like a different drummer on Vitalogy.

I love Abbruzzese, I love Daughter but I voted Hail Hail. It's that good.

[William Bloke]

Another ridiculously tough choice. Grabbed the good headphones and ran through both yet again.

I've gone back-and-forth over and over. In the end I had to stop thinking and just feel.

Hail Hail by a fly's foreskin.

[chewm]

Daughter, but its a really tough one.
I haven't voted for Hail Hail in any matchup this year which is crazy because I love the song.

[PHATJ]

Daughter, but its a really tough one.

[tommymtcom]

Hail, Hail should win it all

[digster]

Hail Hail, though this is certainly the hardest matchup for me this cycle. Another example of two songs that land on a similar plane for me in terms of how much I like them, but excel at very different things.