III-46: Animal vs. All Those Yesterdays

[William Bloke]

I fully expected to vote ATY here but after a side-by-side listen I can't go past Animal. Just a great fun blast of rock that hits right in the good-bit feelies.

[LetMeSleep]

I fully expected to vote ATY here but after a side-by-side listen I can't go past Animal. Just a great fun blast of rock that hits right in the good-bit feelies.

Good on ya, bloke.

[Mike]

Stop putting No Way over great songs like GTF, DTE or Low Light in your rankings.

Animal, by the way.

[stip]

five for me

Behind...

Do the Evolution
Given to Fly
Wishlist
Brain of J

???

yup. 4 great songs - among their very best. ATY is a solid good

then probably
mfc
push me/pull me
pilate
no way
(all decent)

lowlight
faithful
in hiding
(songs i always skip)

yield has aged worse than any other pearl jam record for me

[chewm]

Both songs are tremendous but Animal it is.

[LoathedVermin72]

Brain of J.
No Way
Wishlist
Do the Evolution
Faithfull
Push Me, Pull Me
In Hiding
All Those Yesterdays
Given to Fly
MFC
Pilate
Low Light
Red Dot

[chewm]

In Hiding
Faithfull
Low Light
No Way
Given to Fly
MFC
Brain of J
Do the Evolution
Pilate
All Those Yesterdays
Wishlist
Push Me, Pull Me
Red Dot

They're all fucking great, best album, easily.

[ABNorman]

Woohoo! More ranking!

Given to Fly
Do the Evolution
Faithfull
Brain of J
In Hiding
Wishlist
All Those Yesterdays
Low Light
No Way
Pilate
MFC
Push Me Pull Me
Red Dot

[PHATJ]

Animal by a wide margin.

[stip]

[digster]

All Those Yesterdays. Not a choice I'm happy to make, as I love Animal, but not a hard one. If Yesterdays had been up against Go (and I always associate Go and Animal almost like one song in my mind), it would've fallen.

As for YIELD: THE RANKING...

Do The Evolution
Given to Fly
Brain of J
All Those Yesterdays
Faithfull
In Hiding
Low Light
No Way
Wishlist
Push Me, Pull Me
Pilate
MFC
Red Dot

That's an awesome collection of songs.

[stip]

when the hell did ATY pull ahead of animal?

[stip]

[LetMeSleep]

How can anyone see Animal through this Yield forest?

[LoathedVermin72]

Go
Rearviewmirror
Animal
Daughter
Blood
Indifference
Elderly Woman
W.M.A.
Rats
Dissident
Leash
Glorified G

[LoathedVermin72]

Every single one of those is a monster.

[LetMeSleep]

Go
Rearviewmirror
Animal
Daughter
Indifference
Rats
Blood
Glorified G
Elderly Woman
W.M.A.
Leash
Dissident

[Jorge]

Top-tier stuff:
RVM
Go

I like these a lot!:
Animal
Elderly Woman
W.M.A.

these are OK:
Daughter
Dissident
Blood

stay away from me:
Indifference
Rats
Leash
Glorified G

[LetMeSleep]

The album so good that Hard To Imagine and Whipping and Betterman lay on the floor.

[stip]

vs please