Quarterfinals: Immortality vs. Black

[stip]

Vote

[stip]

These both scratch a different itch, and they're both maybe the best representative in the catalog for their respective type, but I think I like Immortality just a little bit more.

[stip]

really I don't care who wins this

[ABNorman]

really I don't care who wins this

But I voted Black.

[stip]

you're not wrong.


Though I voted for immortality

[Kaius]

"Black" for the superior, and one of Ed's very best, vocal performance.

[epilogue]

Adore them both. Two of my absolute favorites. I'm voting for Black. But I'll be happy with either one winning.

[Chris_H_2]

I used to love black. But then I grew tired of it. With a lot of songs of which I tire, after a time off, I usually find a way back to them. This hasn't happened with black; it's still a bore and a slog for me.

so Immortality all the way.

[E.H. Ruddock]

Immortality. Beautiful song.

[Self]

I used to love black. But then I grew tired of it.

Yeah. I can still get into Black every now and then, though. Usually after a few too many beers and stuff.

[Chris_H_2]

I used to love black. But then I grew tired of it.

Yeah. I can still get into Black every now and then, though. Usually after a few too many beers and stuff.

hypothetically, if people on this board actually hooked up with he opposite sex, how many do you think made out during black at one point in their lives?

[PHATJ]

Immortality. But seriously, these two are both all time favorites.

[darth_vedder]

I used to love black. But then I grew tired of it.

Yeah. I can still get into Black every now and then, though. Usually after a few too many beers and stuff.

hypothetically, if people on this board actually hooked up with he opposite sex, how many do you think made out during black at one point in their lives?

and timed it with the "her legs spread out before me" part

[Self]

I used to love black. But then I grew tired of it.

Yeah. I can still get into Black every now and then, though. Usually after a few too many beers and stuff.

hypothetically, if people on this board actually hooked up with he opposite sex, how many do you think made out during black at one point in their lives?

Well, there's darth_vedder for one. Maybe Stip. And I'm sure LV got around to it during one of his 8 hour sessions that his wife is so fond of.

[darth_vedder]

mine was a question, sorry, should have ended it with a question mark

[LetMeSleep]

Immortality although Black is a special song.

[Birds in Hell]

[evenslow]

I voted for Immortality but I'm not happy about it.

[LoathedVermin72]

Perfect.

[chewm]

Immortality.