2-149: Man on the Moon vs. The One I Love

[stip]

vote

[stip]

this is very close. Man on the Moon is the better song but I do love that slow version of The One I Love they sometimes do. It completely transforms the song, and I would take the new flexibility of The One I Love over Man on the Moon, I think

[Kevin Davis]

"Man on the Moon."

"The One I Love" is too repetitive without really gaining any momentum -- I like it but I wish it was about half the length.

[stip]

What do you think of the piano version?

[chewm]

I'm actually voting for The One I Love. I love it.
Man on the Moon probably deserves it anyways.

[Kevin Davis]

What do you think of the piano version?

Not sure I've heard it.

[stip]

the version from the second unplugged is best, but here's another