3-185: Man on the Moon vs. Maps and Legends

[stip]

vote

[stip]

Man on the Moon, easily. Amazing song that I take for granted

[Chris_H_2]

man, i really grew to dislike man on the moon over the years. i really liked the album version, but stipe's incessant yelling while singing it live really ruined it for me. now that's all i hear when i listen to it.

[stip]

yeah, that was really annoying.

[chewm]

Man on the Moon.

[AndySlash]

man, i really grew to dislike man on the moon over the years. i really liked the album version, but stipe's incessant yelling while singing it live really ruined it for me. now that's all i hear when i listen to it.

same exact feeling here. never was a fan of the transition away from iteotwawki to man on the moon as show closer, either. i was fine with dropping 'world', but would rather have had a number of other songs as the closer than 'moon'.

[stip]

when did man on the moon become the closer?

[Kaius]

Man on the Moon, easily. Amazing song that I take for granted

Yep

[AndySlash]

when did man on the moon become the closer?

around the time around the sun came out. i remember the 2003 show i saw had 'world' as the finale and then in 04 and later it was 'moon'. 'world' hardly got any play after that.

[stip]

prior to accelerate they started using I'm Gonna DJ. Maybe they were alternating?

[AndySlash]

looking at setlist.fm it seems dj was just for those dublin shows. in 04-05 it went dj>moon, to end. in 08 dj was midset with moon closing.

also, i didn't realize this until looking at sets just now, but iteotwawki did pop back up in 08 and was usually the penultimate song (with moon to close) or the main set closer.

[PHATJ]

man, i really grew to dislike man on the moon over the years. i really liked the album version, but stipe's incessant yelling while singing it live really ruined it for me. now that's all i hear when i listen to it.

I've never listened to live REM consistently enough to have MOTM permanently ruined by Stipe's idiotic yelling. Although I hated hearing it every time I have.