10th album rumors and speculation

[Sgt. Crackpot]

Victoria Secret 1000:1

[spike]

Victoria Secret 1000:1

[Dr. Van Nostrand]

I have as much interest hearing a song that ed has already done on a new album as I have interest in hearing a cover: 0%.

it's the hallmark of a band way past its prime and running on fumes.

EVERY ALBUM HAS CONTAINED SONGS EDDIE ALREADY DID

Yeah? I know of a good amount of them but not sure of them all. Which song from ten and vs?

I may be wrong but I thought Ten had stuff dating from Bad Radio. Either way, Ten and Vs. are just two albums.

I think most who have a problem with it is that it was released on an album not that long ago instead of just played live. But we don't know if there will be a uke song on it, or what it will sound like, so for me, i don't love the idea of reusing a song, but Im interested in seeing what they are able to do with it

[Self]

Angelfire is still around?

[Jorge]

Angelfire is still around?

They're sponsoring the new album.

[Self]

Angelfire is still around?

They're sponsoring the new album.

Can't believe they outbid GeoCities.

[stip]

I have as much interest hearing a song that ed has already done on a new album as I have interest in hearing a cover: 0%.

it's the hallmark of a band way past its prime and running on fumes.

EVERY ALBUM HAS CONTAINED SONGS EDDIE ALREADY DID

Yeah? I know of a good amount of them but not sure of them all. Which song from ten and vs?

I may be wrong but I thought Ten had stuff dating from Bad Radio. Either way, Ten and Vs. are just two albums.

Vitalogy was the first bad radio song (and only). It is entirely possible porch or release were things he wrote prior to those sessions.


Leash was written during the ten sessions (or shortly after) and played live with some regularity before vs.

[harmless]

I'm kind of thinking Citizen would've been a cool title for a PJ album. Ed seems to write pretty well when he's being patriotic, unlike most of the world.

[harmless]

I have as much interest hearing a song that ed has already done on a new album as I have interest in hearing a cover: 0%.

it's the hallmark of a band way past its prime and running on fumes.

EVERY ALBUM HAS CONTAINED SONGS EDDIE ALREADY DID

Yeah? I know of a good amount of them but not sure of them all. Which song from ten and vs?

I may be wrong but I thought Ten had stuff dating from Bad Radio. Either way, Ten and Vs. are just two albums.

I think most who have a problem with it is that it was released on an album not that long ago instead of just played live.

Yeah, thought of that. I get people feeling different about a song which has basically been officially released twice. I guess I'm looking forward to a reworking of a song that I don't think they can ruin...

[BurtReynolds]

I have as much interest hearing a song that ed has already done on a new album as I have interest in hearing a cover: 0%.

it's the hallmark of a band way past its prime and running on fumes.

EVERY ALBUM HAS CONTAINED SONGS EDDIE ALREADY DID

Yeah? I know of a good amount of them but not sure of them all. Which song from ten and vs?

I may be wrong but I thought Ten had stuff dating from Bad Radio. Either way, Ten and Vs. are just two albums.

I think most who have a problem with it is that it was released on an album not that long ago instead of just played live. But we don't know if there will be a uke song on it, or what it will sound like, so for me, i don't love the idea of reusing a song, but Im interested in seeing what they are able to do with it

no no I meant never played anytime by Eddie including on the day of the recording. any more than once is not fresh enough for me.

[Birds in Hell]

I really can't understand why the inclusion of Sleeping By Myself (if, in fact, it is on the album) has caused so much hand-wringing.

I'm pretty sure it:
a. won't feature the ukulele (at least, not prominently), and
b. won't sound anything like the previously released version

So what's the deal? It's one of the stronger songs from that record, I'd love to hear how the band could fill it out.

As I pointed out somewhere in this mammoth thread, the period in which the song was written overlaps with the time the band were working on this new album - it's possible the band version was recorded well before the release of Ed's 'Ukulele Songs'.

[spike]

probably because no one wants to hear anymore love songs from the pearl jam camp.

[BurtReynolds]

would just rather hear something new is all.

[E.H. Ruddock]

This is getting close.

[stip]

would just rather hear something new is all. plus, if history teaches us anything, the results are usually terrifying.

well technically the only previously recorded example of this is betterman. Can't Keep was clearly written as an eddie solo song before the band got to it. That's really all we have to go off of. And those were both smashing successes. Gone, Speed of Sound, The End, and Unthought Known were played by eddie (and two demoes were recorded/released) before the release of their respective albums, but those were also songs Eddie presumably wrote while the band was in new album mode, no?

[BurtReynolds]

yeah forget that last sentence.

[elliseamos]

would just rather hear something new is all. plus, if history teaches us anything, the results are usually terrifying.

well technically the only previously recorded example of this is betterman. Can't Keep was clearly written as an eddie solo song before the band got to it. That's really all we have to go off of. And those were both smashing successes. Gone, Speed of Sound, The End, and Unthought Known were played by eddie (and two demoes were recorded/released) before the release of their respective albums, but those were also songs Eddie presumably wrote while the band was in new album mode, no?

and then there's the other category of songs that are played live by Pearl Jam and are present during previous recording sessions that didn't make an album at inception (Brain of J and Of The Earth). are there others in this category? Navy Bean? Sirens?

[WaitingForBluey]

why does everyone always ignore veevee. dude is in the know. he says it's X.

it's X.

Hmm, so veevee is e v right?

[stip]

would just rather hear something new is all. plus, if history teaches us anything, the results are usually terrifying.

well technically the only previously recorded example of this is betterman. Can't Keep was clearly written as an eddie solo song before the band got to it. That's really all we have to go off of. And those were both smashing successes. Gone, Speed of Sound, The End, and Unthought Known were played by eddie (and two demoes were recorded/released) before the release of their respective albums, but those were also songs Eddie presumably wrote while the band was in new album mode, no?

and then there's the other category of songs that are played live by Pearl Jam and are present during previous recording sessions that didn't make an album at inception (Brain of J and Of The Earth). are there others in this category? Navy Bean? Sirens?

well those are the obvious choices

Habit, Lukin, and Red Mosquito may also fall in under that list. Same with I am Mine and Parting Ways

[elliseamos]

would just rather hear something new is all. plus, if history teaches us anything, the results are usually terrifying.

well technically the only previously recorded example of this is betterman. Can't Keep was clearly written as an eddie solo song before the band got to it. That's really all we have to go off of. And those were both smashing successes. Gone, Speed of Sound, The End, and Unthought Known were played by eddie (and two demoes were recorded/released) before the release of their respective albums, but those were also songs Eddie presumably wrote while the band was in new album mode, no?

and then there's the other category of songs that are played live by Pearl Jam and are present during previous recording sessions that didn't make an album at inception (Brain of J and Of The Earth). are there others in this category? Navy Bean? Sirens?

well those are the obvious choices

Habit, Lukin, and Red Mosquito may also fall in under that list. Same with I am Mine and Parting Ways

red mosquito was the other one i was trying to think of...