Vote for PJ in the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame nominations

[Norah]

Fuck this I'm voting for Jill Stein.

[LetMeSleep]

And the Modern Drummer article.

[EJ]

maybe we need them to not get voted in so they can write a nice angry album

[Birds in Hell]

This is monumentally dumb, but so is the RnR HoF.

Who is inducted seems arbitrary and it doesn't appear that bands themselves have much influence. Chad Channing was denied a spot with Nirvana which I gather was contrary to what the band wanted and Robert Smith wrote an angry diatribe when the Cure were nominated but long-serving drummer Jason Cooper (1994 to present) wasn't included. On the other hand, Chad Smith, Jack Irons and Cliff Martinez were all inducted with Red Hot Chili Peppers relatively recently, so who the hell knows.

[wease]

I even understand why Matt is getting in, but the snub to Dave A is bullshit.

[Norah]

Dave A, Jack Irons, and Matt Cameron all deserve inclusion.

[Birds in Hell]

Fingers crossed Pearl Jam lose out to Depeche Mode and Kraftwerk.

[wease]

So, how long has Ed had his speech written?

[bada]

I saw Chaka Khan last year. She was awesome.

[tragabigzanda]

pearl jam sucks now

[Norah]

I think you're downplaying Matt's contributions and worthiness here. He's the longest running drummer, and despite not being on the most memorable albums, is the guy everyone has seen perform live since they've really harnessed their reputation for live performance.

[Strat]

This is bullshit. Krusen and Abbruzesse absolutely deserve to be there. Irons shouldn't pull the same weight as far as the rules go, but the band is going to look like assholes to me if they don't try to find a way to include him. Chamberlain obviously doesn't deserve much credit. Cameron gets in on a couple technicalities: he's their current drummer, and he played on Last Kiss. But 100 years from now, no one is gonna remember Riot Act or Lightning Bolt. Their legend will rest firmly on Ten - Vitalogy. This whole thing is a joke.

The band already looks like assholes to you anyway. Lets be honest.

[Birds in Hell]

This is bullshit. Krusen and Abbruzesse absolutely deserve to be there. Irons shouldn't pull the same weight as far as the rules go, but the band is going to look like assholes to me if they don't try to find a way to include him. Chamberlain obviously doesn't deserve much credit. Cameron gets in on a couple technicalities: he's their current drummer, and he played on Last Kiss. But 100 years from now, no one is gonna remember Riot Act or Lightning Bolt. Their legend will rest firmly on Ten - Vitalogy. This whole thing is a joke.

I agree that even poor ol' Dave Krusen is significantly more important to the band's history than Matt Cameron but, as with those examples I gave upthread, I don't think the band has any say in these things.

[VinylGuy]

Dave K and Dave A should be there...the same for Jackie, and of course Matt. Its weird...they should let the band decide themselves.

[bodysnatcher]

http://pitchfork.com/thepitch/1329-a-ro ... n-decades/

[tragabigzanda]

pearl jam sucks now

[wease]

I've had handjobs that lasted longer than Chamberlain was in the band.

[Birds in Hell]

Chamberlain was arguably their best drummer, too bad it didn't work out.

[Rangi Guy]

Just hope we get a speech along the lines of

[wease]

Keep hoping RG. He's wanted this for waaaaaaaaaay too long.