Star Wars: Rogue One

[Strat]

IS CHOPPER IN IT

[darth_vedder]

who's chopper?

[@SkitchP]

Petition to ban dime for not answering the chopper question

[Anders]

Still can't remember seeing Chopper at all. So the answer is almost certainly no.

[Strat]

ok so is rey in it

[Anders]

She wasn't born yet.

[Rangi Guy]

She wasn't born yet.

They could have done better in the lead up to this to let us know she wasn't going to be in it then

[dimejinky99]

To be honest I did think I saw chopper.

As for the ghost

Spoiler: show

pretty sure you don't hear them checking in their call sign in that scene but I could be wrong. I was listening for it tho.

[Anders]

Star Wars Timeline

If we have Episode 1 as year 0. Episode 2 was year 10. Episode 3 was year 13. Episode 4 was year 32. Episode 5 was year 35. Episode 6 was year 36. Episode 7 was year 66.

Rogue One has scenes from year 17, but mostly from year 32 just prior to Episode 4.

[wease]

I love episode 7 (best set of characters in any of the films), and would rank it next to A New Hope and Empire (each excels at something different). All star wars movies are imperfect, so I'm hoping I can rank this just as high for its own reasons.

Imperfect is being very kind. It has some really tedious scenes, others that are just illogical and the main plot is stolen straight from A New Hope. Not even close to A New Hope and Empire in quality.

Episodes 3 and 6 are solid efforts, but imperfect, episodes 1 and 2 are fun but deeply flawed.

Have to disagree. R1 was exactly what I thought it would be. A good war movie. Not a great Star Wars movie. It's saved by the ending and the only character you feel drawn to is the droid. No development or engaging characters.

And you can totally see that this was reshot and further, the trauma it had in editing. You can see they made the best they could of it. But still. It doesn't rank top 5 for me.

Out of eight movies, it doesn't rank in the top 5?

[Anders]

She wasn't born yet.

They could have done better in the lead up to this to let us know she wasn't going to be in it then

It's a prequel to the original Star Wars Movie: A New Hope (Episode 4). I thought that was clear.

[wease]

Do it as soon as you can.

I left the cinema about an hour ago and ran home. Put this straight in.

That's exactly what I'm going to do tomorrow night.

[Strat]

She wasn't born yet.

They could have done better in the lead up to this to let us know she wasn't going to be in it then

It's a prequel to the original Star Wars Movie: A New Hope (Episode 4). I thought that was clear.

so poe is also not in this? wtf

[wease]

She wasn't born yet.

They could have done better in the lead up to this to let us know she wasn't going to be in it then

It's a prequel to the original Star Wars Movie: A New Hope (Episode 4). I thought that was clear.

so poe is also not in this? wtf

I hope Fett is in it.

[Anders]

I love episode 7 (best set of characters in any of the films), and would rank it next to A New Hope and Empire (each excels at something different). All star wars movies are imperfect, so I'm hoping I can rank this just as high for its own reasons.

Imperfect is being very kind (to ep 7). It has some really tedious scenes, others that are just illogical and the main plot is stolen straight from A New Hope. Not even close to A New Hope and Empire in quality.

Episodes 3 and 6 are solid efforts, but imperfect, episodes 1 and 2 are fun but deeply flawed.

Have to disagree. R1 was exactly what I thought it would be. A good war movie. Not a great Star Wars movie. It's saved by the ending and the only character you feel drawn to is the droid. No development or engaging characters.

And you can totally see that this was reshot and further, the trauma it had in editing. You can see they made the best they could of it. But still. It doesn't rank top 5 for me.

Out of eight movies, it doesn't rank in the top 5?

I can see how some would say that. It's an easier story. Simpler than the big episodes. Not so epic. Personally I think Episode 3 is a really good movie. Not a huge fan of The Force Awakens, but I see that many are.

[dimejinky99]

Do it as soon as you can.

I left the cinema about an hour ago and ran home. Put this straight in.

That's exactly what I'm going to do tomorrow night.

You'll be so glad you did

[dimejinky99]

Cinema just down the street has three showings at midnight. All the 501 are there and everyone in costumes. I think I'll go again.

[Strat]

Cinema just down the street has three showings at midnight. All the 501 are there and everyone in costumes. I think I'll go again.

"tedious mess"

love it

[dimejinky99]

Cinema just down the street has three showings at midnight. All the 501 are there and everyone in costumes. I think I'll go again.

"tedious mess"

love it

You know I'll watch this however many times it takes until I love it.

Truth be told I just wanna see the final act again. It's beyond good. Somehow meshes exactly with a new hope while being totally new and thrilling.

[Strat]

Cinema just down the street has three showings at midnight. All the 501 are there and everyone in costumes. I think I'll go again.

"tedious mess"

love it

You know I'll watch this however many times it takes until I love it.

Truth be told I just wanna see the final act again. It's beyond good. Somehow meshes exactly with a new hope while being totally new and thrilling.

Love it. I can't wait. is it friday yet?