All things Sherlock Holmes

[wease]

Wait til you see the third! (The lying detective)
It's so cool.

I thought that was the second. I'm only showing 2 eps so far: The Six Thatchers and The Lying Detective.

Oh right sorry.
It shows the zombie bride or whatever that was as my first of the season.

I was talking about the lying detective. Fuckin awesome episode.

Fuck yeah it was.

[epilogue]

Both episodes were.... off.

The second was MUCH better than the first. I can't believe they killed off Mary. What a fucking terrible start to the new year. Chist.

The second episode was better but still felt off to me. Loved certain elements. And I honesty didn't notice the girls. Which is sort of amazing. So, yeah, liked but not sure I loved S4E2.

[wease]

Both episodes were.... off.

The second was MUCH better than the first. I can't believe they killed off Mary. What a fucking terrible start to the new year. Chist.

The second episode was better but still felt off to me. Loved certain elements. And I honesty didn't notice the girls. Which is sort of amazing. So, yeah, liked but not sure I loved S4E2.

It was bound to happen. Watson's wife died in the original Doyle stories.

[dimejinky99]

Something I don't get

Spoiler: show

the latest episode was like a big reveal about Mary's secret life but they already did this in season 3 when she shoots him. In the blackmail episode. It's weird.

[stip]

Both episodes were.... off.

The second was MUCH better than the first. I can't believe they killed off Mary. What a fucking terrible start to the new year. Chist.

The second episode was better but still felt off to me. Loved certain elements. And I honesty didn't notice the girls. Which is sort of amazing. So, yeah, liked but not sure I loved S4E2.

i think tonally they are a bit blacker than is ideal. Holmes is such a dark character he needs lighter events to play off of. and watson should be Holmes' whipping boy, not lifes

[dimejinky99]

Season finale just started

[spike]

OMG!

[epilogue]

Both episodes were.... off.

The second was MUCH better than the first. I can't believe they killed off Mary. What a fucking terrible start to the new year. Chist.

The second episode was better but still felt off to me. Loved certain elements. And I honesty didn't notice the girls. Which is sort of amazing. So, yeah, liked but not sure I loved S4E2.

It was bound to happen. Watson's wife died in the original Doyle stories.

I know. But it's still a big fat bummer. Maybe I'd feel differently if I knew this was the final season. Since it isn't, I just wish she could have stayed around longer. She was awesome. One of my favorite parts of the show.

[epilogue]

Both episodes were.... off.

The second was MUCH better than the first. I can't believe they killed off Mary. What a fucking terrible start to the new year. Chist.

The second episode was better but still felt off to me. Loved certain elements. And I honesty didn't notice the girls. Which is sort of amazing. So, yeah, liked but not sure I loved S4E2.

i think tonally they are a bit blacker than is ideal. Holmes is such a dark character he needs lighter events to play off of. and watson should be Holmes' whipping boy, not lifes

Yeah, maybe that's exactly right.

[dimejinky99]

Ok. They've dropped the ball. This is total bollox. The worst episode they ever came up with.

It's utter crap.

[daft twat]

Ok. They've dropped the ball. This is total bollox. The worst episode they ever came up with.

It's utter crap.

Agreed. If it's the end, it's a shame. If it is instead an out from the lengthy arc they've been doing and a door opening to occasional one-off mysteries for the next decade, then I'll be thrilled.

[dimejinky99]

Ok. They've dropped the ball. This is total bollox. The worst episode they ever came up with.

It's utter crap.

Agreed. If it's the end, it's a shame. If it is instead an out from the lengthy arc they've been doing and a door opening to occasional one-off mysteries for the next decade, then I'll be thrilled.

I Ought it was gonna tie up everything we see in the previous one. It didn't at all. Huge jump in style too. That was like a bad action movie you'd see the rock starring in. Woeful.

[lowlight79]

I thought the finale was fantastic, there never gonna beat the 2nd season though IMO.

[dimejinky99]

I thought the finale was fantastic, there never gonna beat the 2nd season though IMO.

Yeah there's a lot of people loving it. Most divisive episode I can remember.

[Rangi Guy]

Watched The Lying Detective last night. Possibly watch The Final Problem tonight. Hope I don't feel the same way about it as Dime did

[swan]

That was certainly a fucking weird finale, but no more so than any of the zany shit they've done the last 2 seasons. I admit to kinda enjoying the happy ending. Would be totally fine if that were the end of the regular seasons.


Seasons 1 & 2 will be unfuckwithable forever. Don't know that I'll ever find myself needing to revisit 3 & 4.

[stip]

Man, season 3 might be my favorite. They're all great though. The last episode was pretty intense

[E.H. Ruddock]

Elementary is still a solid show, team.

[Rangi Guy]

Just finished this last night. No real complaints about the final other than that speech at the end which was totally unnecessary

[wease]

Elementary is still a solid show, team.

Yeah. It's still a mainstay for the Wease household.