Sad vs. In the Moonlight vs. Olympic Platinum

[stip]

so completley?

[epilogue]

so completley?

Yes, I disbelieve this is random, completely.

[darth_vedder]

Sad, but I really In The Moonlight.

[evenslow]

This doesn't ever really happen but I voted Sad, then read the thread and consequently changed my vote to In the Moonlight. Nice work, team.

[PHATJ]

In the Moonlight is my pick, but it is really close.

[LetMeSleep]

Both are fantastic but Sad edged it for the bridge and instrumental break.

[Jorge]

I think Olympic Platinum is probably the most clever thing Pearl Jam has ever done.

Why

[stip]

I think Olympic Platinum is probably the most clever thing Pearl Jam has ever done.

Why

I probably need to walk that statement back a little bit, but not necessarily by much. At the time, other than Dirty Frank, they had no real songs that didn't take itself that seriously. There is a gentle playful mocking tone that was surprising at the time, has a few moments of genuine humor, and has a wry sardonic quality that I find appealing.

[PHATJ]

I think Olympic Platinum is probably the most clever thing Pearl Jam has ever done.

Why

I probably need to walk that statement back a little bit, but not necessarily by much. At the time, other than Dirty Frank, they had no real songs that didn't take itself that seriously. There is a gentle playful mocking tone that was surprising at the time, has a few moments of genuine humor, and has a wry sardonic quality that I find appealing.

I like it for what it is too, stip.

[Norah]

I like Olympic Platinum.

[PHATJ]

I like Olympic Platinum.

Sing like Whitney!

[chewm]

I like Olympic Platinum.

Same, too bad its against two great songs.