Nothing as it Seems vs. Breakerfall vs. Of the Girl

[Strat]

i voted Of The Girl

NAIS has had it's day in the sun

experiencing them open with Of The Girl in 2000 is one of my fonder PJ live memories ... so pleasant ... unrushed ... just groovin along with the cosmos ... wish it were a vibe they had spent more time channeling in their later years ...

Of the girl is absolutely the best opener they've got. Ill give you that.

[digster]

Nothing As It Seems has consistently been climbing higher on the list of my favorite PJ songs. I mentioned it in the Low Light thread, but Jeff is incredibly talented of taking you by the shoulders and placing you in a really particular setting when listening to his songs.

[doone]

my initial vote was for Breakerfall but since it looks like it has no chance, I'm gonna throw behind Of the Girl. I truly can't stand NAiS.

[epilogue]

Love all three but I gotta give it to NAIS.

Yep.

Not really a close call, either. As good as the other two are, this really isn't difficult NAIS is a brilliant song.

[darth_vedder]

Love all three of these, and since NAIS is gonna win, I'm going with Of The Girl.

Breakerfall is really good too though. Most of the time I prefer studio versions over live, but some of those Breakerfalls from the 2000 tour are absolutely fantastic (Pittsburg and Lubbock come to mind).