15. Garden (3:38-4:59) vs. Immortality (2:18-3:10)

[stip]

Garden (3:38-4:59) vs. Immortality (2:18-3:10)

Voting ends 5/11

[mikejasond]

The end of Garden is a really nice part in a not-very-memorable song. Ten has so many great sections. Its very nice, it just loses some prominence by Ten being FULL of awesome moments.

But that being said, the part in Immortality is a catalog highlight.

So Immortality it is.

Best part of Immortality = the switch to banging ride cymbals (I think). Whatever it is that solo builds into something amazing.

[stip]

pretty much everything MJD said, although the the end of Garden is an okay part in a not particularly memorable song, especially given what surrounds it.


There are basically no solos on Vitalogy, and the immortality solo is sooo good, and so unlike anything else he's really done, it makes you long for a larger presence on the other songs.

[evenslow]

There are basically no solos on Vitalogy

Something I never really think about. Ed Ved stripped every ounce of cock rock out of this band (even though it was exaggerated how much there was to begin with, but my point remains).

and the immortality solo is sooo good, and so unlike anything else he's really done

Yes. The denouement of Vitalogy. (with StupidMop being the oddball addendum)

it makes you long for a larger presence on the other songs.

No, not really.

[PHATJ]

There are basically no solos on Vitalogy

Something I never really think about. Ed Ved stripped every ounce of cock rock out of this band (even though it was exaggerated how much there was to begin with, but my point remains).

and the immortality solo is sooo good, and so unlike anything else he's really done

Yes. The denouement of Vitalogy. (with StupidMop being the oddball addendum)

it makes you long for a larger presence on the other songs.

No, not really.

[PHATJ]

Immortality is my number 3 PJ song. It's perfect.

[mray10]

There just aren't very many minutes of music I like better than that section of Immortality