Red Mosquito

Since this isn't ranking I need to weigh in on this. Waaaay too many songs on most lists. This is five stars team, not every pearl jam song.

Alive
Black
Porch
Go
RVM
Tremor Christ
Corduroy
Immortality
Present Tense
No Way
GTF
DTE
NAIS
Parting Ways
Pendulum
Cold Confession
Sad
HTI
Breath
Man of the Hour
Strangest Tribe
Wash

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Waaaay too many songs on most lists.

No shit.

I feel like I went way overboard by picking 15 or 16.

Birds in Hell wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Waaaay too many songs on most lists.

No shit.

I feel like I went way overboard by picking 15 or 16.

Yeah there are 3 or 4 on my list that I consider "4.5" star songs. But for the sake of the list I rounded up.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Waaaay too many songs on most lists.

No shit.

I feel like I went way overboard by picking 15 or 16.

Yeah there are 3 or 4 on my list that I consider "4.5" star songs. But for the sake of the list I rounded up.

I wasn't sure what the rules were.

harmless wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:Waaaay too many songs on most lists.

No shit.

I feel like I went way overboard by picking 15 or 16.

Yeah there are 3 or 4 on my list that I consider "4.5" star songs. But for the sake of the list I rounded up.

I wasn't sure what the rules were.

Parting Ways, Breath, and Wash are 4.5 stars for me.

OK, but seriously, these are my untouchable songs:

Black
State of Love and Trust
Daughter
Elderly Woman
Indifference
Corduroy
Immortality
In My Tree
Off He Goes
Given to Fly
Do the Evolution

Adding songs that straddle the 4.5/5 boundary rounds out the list a lot:

Alive
Jeremy
Last Exit
Tremor Christ
Nothingman
Better Man
Hail Hail
Who You Are
Smile
Red Mosquito
Present Tense
Faithfull
Wishlist
In Hiding
Fatal
Parting Ways
All or None
Sirens
Yellow Ledbetter
Man of the Hour

Only in (a kind of) chronological order.

Black
Porch
Yellow Ledbetter
SOLAT
Breath
Small Town
Indifference
Corduroy
Off he Goes
Red Mosquito
Brain of J
Do the Evolution
Thin Air
Sad
Down
Love Boat Captain
Man of the Hour
Parachutes
Unthought Known
Getaway
Mind your Manners
Pendulum

Sleight of Hand
Red Mosquito
In Hiding
Yellow Ledbetter
Release
Off He Goes

It's nice to see Man Of The Hour on peoples lists.

Black
Release
Animal
Dissident
Rearviewmirror
Last Exit
Corduroy
Immortality
Hail Hail
Given to Fly
Sleight of Hand
Force of Nature
Yellow Ledbetter
Breath
I Got Shit

The 4 star list would be embarassingly long. Probably 80% of the first 6 albums as well as a dozen post-Binaural tracks.

This is a fluid list but most have been here since their release. If I had to think about it I cut it from my list. There's a bunch of 4/4.5's but here's my top shelf songs:

Alive
State of Love & Trust
Nothingman
Immortality
In My Tree
Long Road
Given to Fly
Lowlight
Light Years
Parting Ways
Sad
The End

Second Team:
Once, Jeremy, Why Go, Porch, Yellow Ledbetter, Breath, Go, Elderly Woman, Corduroy, Betterman, Hail Hail, Off He Goes, I Got Shit, Wishlist, All Those Yesterdays, Faithful, Grievance, I am Mine, All or None, Worldwide Suicide, Severed Hand, Parachutes, Man of the Hour, Got Some, Speed of Sound (demo), Lightning Bolt, Mind Your Manners, Pendulum, Education, Hard to Imagine.

I have a lot. Here they are by album:

Ten:
Alive
Black
Jeremy
Oceans
Release

Vs.:
Go
Animal
Daughter
Glorified G
Dissident
Leash

Vitalogy:
Last Exit
Not For You
Tremor Christ
Nothingman
Corduroy
Better Man
Immortality

No Code:
Hail, Hail
Who You Are
In My Tree
Red Mosquito
Present Tense

Yield:
Brain Of J.
Faithful
No Way
Given To Fly
Do The Evolution

Binaural:
Nothing As It Seems
Of The Girl
Sleight of Hand

Riot Act:
Cropduster
I Am Mine
You Are

Pearl Jam:
Severed Hand
Unemployable
Army Reserve

Backspacer:
Amongst the Waves

Lightning Bolt:
Getaway
Lightning Bolt
Pendulum
Yellow Moon

Miscellaneous:
Yellow Ledbetter
Hard To Imagine
Wash
I Got Shit
Long Road
Sad
In The Moonlight
Education
Strangest Tribe
Man of the Hour

Had to go back to my PJ ranker list...

Ten: Jeremy, Release, Alive, Breath (same era), Yellow Ledbetter (same era), Wash (same era)
Vs: Go, Daughter, Rearviewmirror, Leash
Vitalogy: Corduroy, Not For You, Better Man, Spin The Black Circle, Last Exit, Immortality
Merkin Ball: I Got Id
No Code: In My Tree, Hail Hail
Yield: Faithfull, Given To Fly, In Hiding, Do The Evolution
Binaural: Education (same era)
Riot Act: ...
Pearl Jam: ...
Backspacer: ...
Lightning Bolt: Pendulum

OK. Everyone is correct. Way too many songs on my list. I will cut it down. It was 36 songs.

hlniv wrote:I was just thinking about this question. I will take a shot-

Black
Porch
Release
Go
Footsteps
Rearviewmirror
Indifference
Hard to Imagine
Corduroy
Immortality
I Got Shit
Hail Hail
In My Tree
Off He Goes
Red Mosquito
Present Tense
Faithfull
Given to Fly
Grievance
Sad

20 total

In the spirit of short lists:

Black
Release
Indifference
Immortality
Present Tense
Long Road
Faithfull
Parting Ways
Hard to Imagine

*Edit: +Nothingman

For me, it's an even 20:
-----------------------
Oceans
Alive
Release
Go
Blood
Rearviewmirror
Hard to Imagine
Not For You
Corduroy
Immortality
Who You Are
In My Tree
Brain of J
Given to Fly
Do the Evolution
Sad
Breakerfall
Nothing As It Seems
Insignificance
Parting Ways

my top 5 star pearl jam songs don't ecveb exist. but also in my tree and present tense

theplatypus wrote:my top 5 star pearl jam songs don't ecveb exist. but also in my tree and present tense

Going by my own criteria of "songs which do what they do as well as I could imagine wanting," my list would almost certainly be the longest one posted yet--I'd probably give the nod to 80-85% of the mid-period stuff, with more than a few stragglers from the early and later days. I imagine that would be the case for most of my favorite artists, really--I mean, they earn the title for a reason.

LikeLukin wrote:In the spirit of short lists:

Black
Release
Indifference
Immortality
Present Tense
Long Road
Faithfull
Parting Ways
Hard to Imagine

*Edit: +Nothingman

this guy gets it!