Page 6 of 6
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Tue March 03, 2020 7:09 pm
by VinylGuy
I loooove Why Go live, but yeah i already saw it.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Tue March 03, 2020 9:07 pm
by DissidentRival4
The two at the top of my list are Spin the Black Circle and Whipping. I will keep going to any show I can and never complain if I didn't hear either of these live again.
I love Mike, but the running/circling the whole stage during spin just seems kind of cheesy to me. And whipping, I dunno, I can't explain it - just completely "meh" for me now....
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Tue March 03, 2020 9:35 pm
by Clem Halibut
DissidentRival4 wrote:The two at the top of my list are Spin the Black Circle and Whipping. I will keep going to any show I can and never complain if I didn't hear either of these live again.
I love Mike, but the running/circling the whole stage during spin just seems kind of cheesy to me. And whipping, I dunno, I can't explain it - just completely "meh" for me now....
I love classic Spin The Black Circle - the versions from 1994-1995 just rip
But Ed sounds like shit on that one now
Whipping hasn't aged well on record or live at all - Ed can't sing that one live anymore, and Jeff's backing vocals are horrendous - He sound like a sheep
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 2:44 am
by wease
Clem Halibut wrote:DissidentRival4 wrote:The two at the top of my list are Spin the Black Circle and Whipping. I will keep going to any show I can and never complain if I didn't hear either of these live again.
I love Mike, but the running/circling the whole stage during spin just seems kind of cheesy to me. And whipping, I dunno, I can't explain it - just completely "meh" for me now....
I love classic Spin The Black Circle - the versions from 1994-1995 just rip
But Ed sounds like shit on that one now
Whipping hasn't aged well on record or live at all - Ed can't sing that one live anymore, and Jeff's backing vocals are horrendous - He sound like a sheep
Whipping is played much too fast and I hate how Matt plays it. I can still listen to and love 93-94 versions of the tune.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 2:49 am
by EJ
this thread has inspired me to go listen to Vs right now
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 4:04 am
by Leatherhead
Whipping is great. Always.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 5:37 am
by guitar_davey
Leatherhead wrote:Whipping is great. Always.
Yeah, I'm not hearing it sounding bad these days. Count me in for Whipping any time.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 9:09 am
by igotworms
Garden is probably the song that has aged worst for me. Was one of my favourites on Ten when the album first came out. Now I just find it really bland and stodgy.
Particularly disappointing when you think of some of the other tracks recorded during those sessions that could have been on Ten instead.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 10:09 am
by Got Some
guitar_davey wrote:Leatherhead wrote:Whipping is great. Always.
Yeah, I'm not hearing it sounding bad these days. Count me in for Whipping any time.
X2 Whipping rules
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Wed March 04, 2020 8:54 pm
by scrub12
Evenflow is a good one to me. It's hard to say otherwise. Leash for sure, because of the subject matter.
I saw DTE mentioned earlier and I still think that song sounds fantastic.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Thu March 05, 2020 3:37 pm
by McParadigm
I am entertained by the number of people answering instead the question, “on which songs has the band not aged so well?”
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Thu March 05, 2020 4:01 pm
by VinylGuy
Clem Halibut wrote:DissidentRival4 wrote:The two at the top of my list are Spin the Black Circle and Whipping. I will keep going to any show I can and never complain if I didn't hear either of these live again.
I love Mike, but the running/circling the whole stage during spin just seems kind of cheesy to me. And whipping, I dunno, I can't explain it - just completely "meh" for me now....
I love classic Spin The Black Circle - the versions from 1994-1995 just rip
But Ed sounds like shit on that one now
Whipping hasn't aged well on record or live at all - Ed can't sing that one live anymore, and Jeff's backing vocals are horrendous - He sound like a sheep
STBC is a good example. They slow it down, and ed´s just not good there. Also Blood if they choose to play it on the second encore.
Re: Songs That Haven't Aged So Well
Posted: Thu March 05, 2020 6:39 pm
by Clem Halibut
VinylGuy wrote:Clem Halibut wrote:DissidentRival4 wrote:The two at the top of my list are Spin the Black Circle and Whipping. I will keep going to any show I can and never complain if I didn't hear either of these live again.
I love Mike, but the running/circling the whole stage during spin just seems kind of cheesy to me. And whipping, I dunno, I can't explain it - just completely "meh" for me now....
I love classic Spin The Black Circle - the versions from 1994-1995 just rip
But Ed sounds like shit on that one now
Whipping hasn't aged well on record or live at all - Ed can't sing that one live anymore, and Jeff's backing vocals are horrendous - He sound like a sheep
STBC is a good example. They slow it down, and ed´s just not good there. Also Blood if they choose to play it on the second encore.
Blood is an absolute mess now...Ed can't sing that one to save his life