Page 6 of 21
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 3:47 am
by Dr. Van Nostrand
Backspacer
Force of nature
The end
Johnny guitar
The fixer
Gonna see my friend
Got some
Just breathe
Unthought known
Amongst the waves
Speed of sound
Supersonic
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 3:52 am
by stip
since I know you'll care, DcT
Overlap in our top 30
Black
Immortality
Small Town
Do The Evolution
Release
Tremor Christ
I Am Mine
Even Flow
Animal
RVM
Yellow Ledbetter
Last Exit
Corduroy
Porch
Alive
Better Man
Also, two of your bottom 5 are in my top 20
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:00 am
by epilogue
Man, Stip, you really don't like Hitchhiker.
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:01 am
by epilogue
Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:First, Ruddo is going to be pissed. Second, what the hell do you have against Gods' Dice, Joey?
I've just never liked it. The whole thing rubs me the wrong way. Don't like the feel of it. Don't like the lyrics. Don't like the way Ed sings it. Don't like the melody.
How are you feeling about your over all list after most of the day? You thinking you will tweak it at all? i feel like when Im done with mine ill want to move a bit around here and there
Right now I'm feeling pretty good. I want to see what a good night's sleep does. Tomorrow I'll reevalute and see if anything's changed.
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:06 am
by Dr. Van Nostrand
durdencommatyler wrote:Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:durdencommatyler wrote:cutuphalfdead wrote:First, Ruddo is going to be pissed. Second, what the hell do you have against Gods' Dice, Joey?
I've just never liked it. The whole thing rubs me the wrong way. Don't like the feel of it. Don't like the lyrics. Don't like the way Ed sings it. Don't like the melody.
How are you feeling about your over all list after most of the day? You thinking you will tweak it at all? i feel like when Im done with mine ill want to move a bit around here and there
Right now I'm feeling pretty good. I want to see what a good night's sleep does. Tomorrow I'll reevalute and see if anything's changed.
I don't think i can get done with this tonight, so ill think on what I've finished, but still won't know about any changes till Im done with it all.
Thanks for the idea for this, its been fun, I've never tried to do anymore then to make a top 10
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:13 am
by stip
I may take a look and move some things around. These were spur of the moment calls that may not sit right in the morning.
It may also depend on how i want to balance long term loyalty to a song vs. current enjoyment, or how 'good' I think a song is vs. how much I like it (I think Sleight of Hand is better than my ranking, for instance)
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:17 am
by epilogue
stip wrote: 'good' I think a song is vs. how much I like it (I think Sleight of Hand is better than my ranking, for instance)
This is one of the big things I keep struggling with.
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:25 am
by Birds in Hell
Okay, bearing in mind my reservations about how representative this will be of what I enjoy about the band, I admit I'm curious in seeing how different (or similar) my list ends up being to Joey's, stip's, Doc's, etc.
So, fine, I'm in.
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:27 am
by Dr. Van Nostrand
Birds in Hell wrote:Okay, bearing in mind my reservations about how representative this will be of what I enjoy about the band, I admit I'm curious in seeing how different (or similar) my list ends up being to Joey's, stip's, Doc's, etc.
So, fine, I'm in.
Nice
looking forward to seeing how it all turns out
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:29 am
by Birds in Hell
Vs:
Rearviewmirror
Animal
Daughter
Indifference
Go
Blood
Rats
Glorified G
Dissident
W.M.A.
Leash
Small Town
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:34 am
by Birds in Hell
Vitalogy:
Last Exit
Tremor Christ
Corduroy
Not for You
Spin the Black Circle
Immortality
Satan's Bed
Whipping
Better Man
Bugs
Pry, To
Nothingman
Aye Davanita
Stupid Mop
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:40 am
by Birds in Hell
First three combined:
Rearviewmirror
Last Exit
Tremor Christ
Oceans
Animal
Daughter
Jeremy
Corduroy
Indifference
Once
Not for You
Even Flow
Go
Spin the Black Circle
Blood
Immortality
Deep
Rats
Satan's Bed
Garden
Glorified G
Porch
Dissident
Release
W.M.A.
Why Go
Whipping
Black
Alive
Better Man
Bugs
Leash
Pry, To
Small Town
Nothingman
Aye Davanita
Stupid Mop
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:49 am
by Birds in Hell
No Code:
Hail, Hail
In My Tree
Red Mosquito
Smile
Habit
Off He Goes
Present Tense
Sometimes
Who You Are
Lukin
Mankind
Around the Bend
I'm Open
Yield:
Faithfull
Brain of J.
Do the Evolution
No Way
All Those Yesterdays
Push Me, Pull Me
In Hiding
MFC
Pilate
Given to Fly
Wishlist
Low Light
Red Dot
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 4:52 am
by Jorge
You guys!
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 6:12 am
by Birds in Hell
Rearviewmirror
Last Exit
Faithfull
Tremor Christ
Oceans
Animal
Daughter
Hail, Hail
Brain of J.
Do the Evolution
Jeremy
Corduroy
In My Tree
Indifference
Red Mosquito
Smile
No Way
All Those Yesterdays
Habit
Once
Not for You
Push Me, Pull Me
Even Flow
Go
Spin the Black Circle
In Hiding
Off He Goes
Present Tense
Blood
Immortality
Sometimes
Deep
Rats
Satan's Bed
Garden
Glorified G
Who You Are
Porch
Lukin
Dissident
Release
MFC
W.M.A.
Mankind
Around the Bend
Pilate
Given to Fly
Why Go
Whipping
Black
Alive
Better Man
Leash
Wishlist
Small Town
Nothingman
Low Light
Pry, To
I'm Open
Bugs
Red Dot
Aye Davanita
Stupid Mop
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 6:13 am
by Norah
theplatypus wrote:You guys!
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 6:15 am
by Birds in Hell
How are we handling the other assorted songs like State of Love and Trust, I Got Shit, etc.?
Binaural:
Sleight of Hand
Evacuation
Insignificance
Of the Girl
Nothing as it Seems
Gods' Dice
Grievance
Thin Air
Rival
Breakerfall
Light Years
Parting Ways
Soon Forget
Riot Act:
Cropduster
All or None
Can't Keep
Help Help
Love Boat Captain
Half Full
Ghost
Get Right
I Am Mine
Thumbing My Way
Green Disease
Save You
You Are
Bushleaguer
Arc
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 6:43 am
by Birds in Hell
Rearviewmirror
Last Exit
Faithfull
Tremor Christ
Oceans
Animal
Daughter
Hail, Hail
Brain of J.
Do the Evolution
Sleight of Hand
Evacuation
Jeremy
Corduroy
Insignificance
In My Tree
Indifference
Red Mosquito
Smile
Cropduster
Of the Girl
No Way
All Those Yesterdays
Nothing as it Seems
Habit
Once
Not for You
All or None
Push Me, Pull Me
Even Flow
Go
Spin the Black Circle
Gods' Dice
Can't Keep
In Hiding
Off He Goes
Present Tense
Blood
Immortality
Grievance
Sometimes
Deep
Rats
Satan's Bed
Garden
Glorified G
Help Help
Who You Are
Porch
Lukin
Dissident
Release
Love Boat Captain
Half Full
Thin Air
Rival
Ghost
MFC
W.M.A.
Mankind
Get Right
Around the Bend
Pilate
Given to Fly
Why Go
Whipping
Black
Alive
Better Man
I Am Mine
Thumbing My Way
Leash
Green Disease
Breakerfall
Wishlist
Small Town
Light Years
Save You
You Are
Nothingman
Low Light
Parting Ways
Pry, To
I'm Open
Bugs
Bushleaguer
Arc
Soon Forget
Red Dot
Aye Davanita
Stupid Mop
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 6:57 am
by Birds in Hell
Why did I start doing this? This was a terrible idea. It's hard for me to see the Matt Cameron years of the band on the same continuum as the earlier records, I think I'd find it easier to rank them separately. But oh well.
S/T:
Unemployable
Parachutes
Comatose
Big Wave
Army Reserve
Life Wasted
Severed Hand
Marker in the Sand
Gone
Inside Job
World Wide Suicide
Wasted Reprise
Come Back
Backspacer:
Gonna See My Friend
Speed of Sound
Johnny Guitar
Amongst the Waves
Just Breathe
The End
The Fixer
Got Some
Supersonic
Force of Nature
Unthought Known
Lost Dogs 1:
In the Moonlight
All Night
Alone
Education
Sad
U
Hitchhiker
Don't Gimme No Lip
Leavin' Here
Down
Undone
Whale Song
Black Red Yellow
Hold On
Gremmie Out of Control
Yellow Ledbetter
Lost Dogs 2:
Strangest Tribe
Fatal
Hard to Imagine
Wash
Dead Man
Sweet Lew
Dirty Frank
Footsteps
Last Kiss
Other Side
Brother
Bee Girl
Let Me Sleep
4/20/02
Driftin'
Re: Rank The Pearl Jam Catalog
Posted: Sun January 20, 2013 11:38 am
by Birds in Hell
Rearviewmirror
Last Exit
Faithfull
Tremor Christ
Oceans
Animal
Daughter
Hail, Hail
Brain of J.
Do the Evolution
Sleight of Hand
Evacuation
Jeremy
Corduroy
Insignificance
In My Tree
Indifference
Red Mosquito
Smile
In the Moonlight
All Night
Cropduster
Of the Girl
Alone
No Way
All Those Yesterdays
Nothing as it Seems
Habit
Education
Once
Not for You
All or None
Push Me, Pull Me
Even Flow
Go
Strangest Tribe
Sad
Spin the Black Circle
Gods' Dice
Can't Keep
In Hiding
Fatal
Off He Goes
Present Tense
Blood
Immortality
Grievance
Hard to Imagine
Wash
Sometimes
Deep
Rats
Satan's Bed
Garden
Glorified G
Unemployable
Help Help
Parachutes
Dead Man
Who You Are
Porch
Lukin
Comatose
Big Wave
Dissident
Release
Around the Bend
Love Boat Captain
Half Full
Thin Air
Rival
U
Army Reserve
Ghost
MFC
W.M.A.
Mankind
Hitchhiker
Don't Gimme No Lip
Gonna See My Friend
Get Right
Sweet Lew
Leavin' Here
Pilate
Given to Fly
Speed of Sound
Johnny Guitar
Down
Why Go
Whipping
Dirty Frank
Black
Alive
Better Man
I Am Mine
Undone
Thumbing My Way
Leash
Whale Song
Life Wasted
Severed Hand
Black Red Yellow
Green Disease
Breakerfall
Wishlist
Small Town
Marker in the Sand
Light Years
Footsteps
Gone
Save You
Last Kiss
Inside Job
You Are
World Wide Suicide
Nothingman
Low Light
Other Side
Brother
Parting Ways
Pry, To
Wasted Reprise
I'm Open
Bugs
Bee Girl
Hold On
Let Me Sleep
4/20/02
Driftin'
Amongst the Waves
Just Breathe
The End
Bushleaguer
The Fixer
Gremmie Out of Control
Yellow Ledbetter
Got Some
Come Back
Arc
Soon Forget
Red Dot
Aye Davanita
Supersonic
Force of Nature
Unthought Known
Stupid Mop