HBO: Game of Thrones (Song of Ice and Fire)

[Ello Sailor]

“The Long Night” is an incredible piece of filmmaking.

It was pretty good. I think "incredible" is a bit of a stretch.

1. It's too damn dark. I know this was a deliberate choice, but I think they went overboard.

2. The Dothraki suiciding at the start was dumb as hell.

3. The plot armor on some of these characters was ridiculous. We saw how overwhelming the horde could be, but there's a stretch in the courtyard where Brianne and co. held the line for an absurdly long time. Why did the wights ease up once the walls were breached? They were surrounded but plot-armored their way through unscathed. Also, they weren't wearing helmets. Stupid.

I understand how spergy that last point sounds, but it's true.

[Monkey_Driven]

“The Long Night” is an incredible piece of filmmaking.

It was pretty good. I think "incredible" is a bit of a stretch.

1. It's too damn dark. I know this was a deliberate choice, but I think they went overboard.

2. The Dothraki suiciding at the start was dumb as hell.

3. The plot armor on some of these characters was ridiculous. We saw how overwhelming the horde could be, but there's a stretch in the courtyard where Brianne and co. held the line for an absurdly long time. Why did the wights ease up once the walls were breached? They were surrounded but plot-armored their way through unscathed. Also, they weren't wearing helmets. Stupid.

I understand how spergy that last point sounds, but it's true.

It makes no sense from a strategic standpoint, but it was beautiful to watch (if you have a decent TV with a quality streaming service).

[dimejinky99]

the shot(s) of all the dothraki torches going out..and all their battle cries silenced...that was inevitable. you knew they were all gonna die and quickly, but beautifully done too

[Simple Torture]

Never forget:

http://forums.theskyiscrape.com/viewtop ... 3#p1339023

Also, this one's for Joey: if they wanted to do the most "TV" ending to this conflict of all time, it'll be Arya who strikes the killing blow to the Night King, and when he looks her in the eye as he begins to crumble into ice chips, she'll whisper, "...not today."

Motherfuckers, I was CLOSE

[Ello Sailor]

[Mecca]

the shot(s) of all the dothraki torches going out..and all their battle cries silenced...that was inevitable. you knew they were all gonna die and quickly, but beautifully done too

Then they magically respawn in kings landing

[dimejinky99]

the shot(s) of all the dothraki torches going out..and all their battle cries silenced...that was inevitable. you knew they were all gonna die and quickly, but beautifully done too

Then they magically respawn in kings landing

this series is a perfect example of the books being in an another universe and the tv adaptation being crapr

[Ensign9]

I’m through episode 4. Among my major quibbles during the original airings was how little setup there seemed to be for Dany losing it. I gotta say, there are plenty of reasonable, logical breadcrumbs apparent upon a rewatch.

I’m very curious to see how I’ll react to the Bran election this time around. Perhaps I will let D&D out of media jail…


Another major quibble was Bran doing jackshit during the Battle of Winterfell. In actuality, he clearly states his role is as bait to lure the Night King in. Good job, Bran.

[Ensign9]

“The Long Night” is an incredible piece of filmmaking.

It was pretty good. I think "incredible" is a bit of a stretch.

1. It's too damn dark. I know this was a deliberate choice, but I think they went overboard.

2. The Dothraki suiciding at the start was dumb as hell.

3. The plot armor on some of these characters was ridiculous. We saw how overwhelming the horde could be, but there's a stretch in the courtyard where Brianne and co. held the line for an absurdly long time. Why did the wights ease up once the walls were breached? They were surrounded but plot-armored their way through unscathed. Also, they weren't wearing helmets. Stupid.

I understand how spergy that last point sounds, but it's true.

Watch it again on Max.

The cavalry approach had pretty great succcess smashing the Lannisters in season 7. They had no idea there’d be a 12-foot tall sea of surging wights greeting them at the tree line.

Tormund, Sam, Brienne and Pod absolutely should’ve died. (I’ll couch this by saying I wouldn’t want to have missed Tormund’s antics at the victory feast). Brienne giving her life for Jaime would have been a great choice.

[Ello Sailor]

Watch it again on Max.

Fair. I should do that.

Tormund, Sam, Brienne and Pod absolutely should’ve died. Brienne giving her life for Jaime would have been a great choice.

I was kind of expecting this to happen. The stakes didn't feel as high once I realized their whole crew was invulnerable.

[Chris_H_2]

the shot(s) of all the dothraki torches going out..and all their battle cries silenced...that was inevitable. you knew they were all gonna die and quickly, but beautifully done too

Then they magically respawn in kings landing

this series is a perfect example of the books being in an another universe and the tv adaptation being crapr

We missed you Chud

[Mecca]

As soon as they ran out of source material, the show focused a lot on doing things that theoretically are cool or shocking without any real motivation behind it. But, Dany’s heel turn was being told since her assassination attempt with the poison wine.

They really needed to come up with a better story than Bran has the best story; he’s a greenseer and a warg with a demeanor ruled by logic, the greater good, and a touch of autism.

[Ensign9]

Just finished. The election scene remains a piece of flaming doo-doo butter. Aside from that mess, the season was better upon this latest viewing. More than anything else, Dany’s descent into madness was improved upon this rewatch. It did not feel like it came out of nowhere.

A lot of things suffer due to the limited episode count, Cersei chief among them. She’s barely a character in the final season.

FINISH THE DAMN BOOKS, GEORGE

[Ensign9]

I couldn’t imagine watching this show in a bar with a bunch of people

My wife and I watched The Bells at a nerd bar on the outskirts of Las Vegas.

[Ensign9]

This thread should be deleted and all memory of this terrible series erased from our consciousness.

Disagree. This was a fun ride that gave us an ending. We might not have liked it, but it didn’t ruin the journey at all. I feel the exact opposite about Lost. That felt like a massive betrayal after season 3’s finale.

If a car you're in drives off a cliff and explodes in flames at the end of the journey, would you relive it all again?

I loved this show. What’s wrong with you.

I did, too. Then season 7 and 8 happened.

This Ensign guy needs to calm down and lighten up.

[dimejinky99]

I’m through episode 4. Among my major quibbles during the original airings was how little setup there seemed to be for Dany losing it. I gotta say, there are plenty of reasonable, logical breadcrumbs apparent upon a rewatch.

I’m very curious to see how I’ll react to the Bran election this time around. Perhaps I will let D&D out of media jail…


Another major quibble was Bran doing jackshit during the Battle of Winterfell. In actuality, he clearly states his role is as bait to lure the Night King in. Good job, Bran.

If you rewatch the whole series, it’s there all along. She was only ever gonna go that way.
But you’d have to be blind not to see it in the final two seasons

[dimejinky99]

the shot(s) of all the dothraki torches going out..and all their battle cries silenced...that was inevitable. you knew they were all gonna die and quickly, but beautifully done too

Then they magically respawn in kings landing

this series is a perfect example of the books being in an another universe and the tv adaptation being crapr

We missed you Chud

I miss chud. One of the best Rmers ever.

[Bi_3]

which of you clowns is this account? timing is too perfect.

[E.H. Ruddock]

[dimejinky99]

what was that ...there was a whole era of gloom in tv and cinema

Solo in the theatres..you couldnt see any of it..same with GOT