Re: Taylor Swift
Posted: Tue September 26, 2023 4:05 pm
Oh, he absolutely sucks. But his tunes were amazing. Emotional thinkers are missing this.
I can still see the humour in Cosby's material. This isn't that.Ello Sailor wrote:Oh, he absolutely sucks. But his tunes were amazing. Emotional thinkers are missing this.
How many Garth Brooks albums do you own?Chris_H_2 wrote:taylor swift = an opportunity for my daughter and me to talk music and go to her show together. i'll take that any day of the week.
what is she awesome at?VinylGuy wrote:i know she is awesome
there is a difference
Not being poortree_ wrote:what is she awesome at?VinylGuy wrote:i know she is awesome
there is a difference
She's got a knack for boiling complex, messy feelings down to their bare essences that I think is pretty rare, even among gifted songwriters. I remember first hearing Fearless -- which came out when she was 18 and I was 25, and is comprised mainly of songs about high school and teenage relationships -- and being really surprised at how much I found myself not only really enjoying the songs from a simple ear-candy standpoint (this was at the tail end of my Pitchfork phase, so even being open to this kind of music took some pride-swallowing), but how much I found myself actually identifying and connecting with certain parts of it. Her ability to zero in on the most tangible and relatable elements of certain experiences, and then articulate them back in ways that make me think, "Wow, I know exactly what she's talking about, and I've always kind of thought that, but I never would have thought to say it like that," is pretty whip-smart. I don't feel this way about everything she does, but it's not a stretch for me to imagine that there are people who do.tree_ wrote:Well, I mean, I don't see what's so special about her music and why she's so popular is what I mean and all
Well said. I haven't taken the time to really analyze, but quite a few of her songs (off the first 5 albums) give me a Pearl Jam vibe. Something about the melody and guitar solos. I'll try to figure out a couple of specific examples. My daughters will love playing that game.Kevin Davis wrote:She's got a knack for boiling complex, messy feelings down to their bare essences that I think is pretty rare, even among gifted songwriters. I remember first hearing Fearless -- which came out when she was 18 and I was 25, and is comprised mainly of songs about high school and teenage relationships -- and being really surprised at how much I found myself not only really enjoying the songs from a simple ear-candy standpoint (this was at the tail end of my Pitchfork phase, so even being open to this kind of music took some pride-swallowing), but how much I found myself actually identifying and connecting with certain parts of it. Her ability to zero in on the most tangible and relatable elements of certain experiences, and then articulate them back in ways that make me think, "Wow, I know exactly what she's talking about, and I've always kind of thought that, but I never would have thought to say it like that," is pretty whip-smart. I don't feel this way about everything she does, but it's not a stretch for me to imagine that there are people who do.tree_ wrote:Well, I mean, I don't see what's so special about her music and why she's so popular is what I mean and all
I think that's probably the quality in her music -- apart from the simple fact of the songs being well-written and catchy -- that has managed to connect with so many people on such a deep level, and it's amplified by the fact that she still does seem like a pretty gracious and compassionate person who genuinely cares, to the extent that it's reasonable and safe, about connecting with the people who've given her the life she has.