Red Mosquito

tree_ wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

Strat wrote:

RockPusher wrote:tree, if you were actually listening to me, you'd understand that I am not asking for an echo chamber at all.

Nobody has said "how can you like this"

That seems to be how you interpret someone else not liking it and discussing why they dont like it.

this is just patently false Strat, over and over again we've been told we must have impaired hearing and mental capacity for enjoying these songs

If this is in fact so, why do you give it any weight? Why not just say "I disagree" or ignore them?

VinylGuy wrote:Well, im warming a lot with this song. It has a lot of energy and its catchy too, specially the bridge.

yeah, the bridge is awesome. Tight as hell. I still think the solo its meh, specially the guitar tone but its followed by that insanely heavy ending so im liking it more with each listen

bodysnatcher wrote:I’ve been listening to quiet ambient music all morning, and feel like if I jump straight into Running I might get whiplash. Gonna need a good middle ground song or two to make that transition. Maybe I’ll queue up some Crash Test Dummies

Strat wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

Strat wrote:

RockPusher wrote:tree, if you were actually listening to me, you'd understand that I am not asking for an echo chamber at all.

Nobody has said "how can you like this"

That seems to be how you interpret someone else not liking it and discussing why they dont like it.

this is just patently false Strat, over and over again we've been told we must have impaired hearing and mental capacity for enjoying these songs

Again. Wrong. Nobody has said you can't like this song. We talk production. Trag comments that for you to comment on production while listening to your phone speakers isn't fair, he never said you can't like or enjoy this song.

Strat wrote:

tree_ wrote:

Ms Harmless wrote:

Strat wrote:

RockPusher wrote:tree, if you were actually listening to me, you'd understand that I am not asking for an echo chamber at all.

Nobody has said "how can you like this"

That seems to be how you interpret someone else not liking it and discussing why they dont like it.

this is just patently false Strat, over and over again we've been told we must have impaired hearing and mental capacity for enjoying these songs

If this is in fact so, why do you give it any weight? Why not just say "I disagree" or ignore them?

Because she requires people make her feel better and put her in the right all the time.

tree_ wrote:KD for president

i don't know if RM has its own style of humour though. I think we tend to think too much of our "tribe" that way sometimes. We're just like everyone else

Strat wrote:But anyone that disagrees with you, harmless, is bullying. So, done chatting about this stuff with you.

Ms Harmless wrote:did my pointing out Trag's laughter get deleted? cool, cool

RockPusher wrote:I think part of the problem is that there are a lot of people here who don't like modern Pearl Jam, and who view this as a place to vent about why, because they see this as a forum *about* Pearl Jam. On the other hand, there are a lot of people here, myself included, who see this as a forum for *fans of* Pearl Jam. We definitely want there to be space to be critical of the music and the band, but the massive amount of shaming taking place for earnestly liking stuff seems way out of place to us. "HOW CAN YOU LIKE THIS WHEN IT SOUNDS LIKE SHIT" is a form of bullying for a place like this, from our perspective. "I'M SO EMBARRASSED BY THIS MUSIC" is a similar type of vibe that adds nothing to the discussion. Layering it in snark and then trying to guilt people for being bothered by it doesn't help.