Red Mosquito

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

Thisbitchleakyet?

It's got minor chords, and minor chords are cool. That helps it.

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Okay.

Lounge Lizard wrote:Thisbitchleakyet?

Most likely no

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Byzantine would have been a good word for you to use in the words tourney. You really overlooked some gems.

theplatypus wrote:

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Okay.

I just wanted to make sure that we were cool about thin air before we each went on with the rest of our day.

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

Lounge Lizard wrote:Thisbitchleakyet?

Most likely no

I found a link to it on Youtube posted like 1 day ago, but I didn't click the fucker.

harmless wrote:It's got minor chords, and minor chords are cool. That helps it.

I don't think it has a single minor chord

EJ wrote:

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Byzantine would have been a good word for you to use in the words tourney. You really overlooked some gems.

my only regret is arbor. The rest of those words were solid. And I don't really like byzantine as a word.

theplatypus wrote:

harmless wrote:It's got minor chords, and minor chords are cool. That helps it.

I don't think it has a single minor chord

Isn't the chord on 'baby' a minor, rather than the predictable happy chord it could've been. And isn't that same chord repeated on 'And I know...'? I'm just using the ear, it might be major despite the fact it doesn't sound happy. But that chord could've easily been replaced with a happy chord and they chose not to.

Future Days has a quality to it that brings the Eagles reunion tour to mind. More than that, it is exactly the kind of craft-without-impact filler that tends to come from an older artist who decides to write a song but feels no inherent drive. It is the epitome of safe and forgetful. It doesn't have enough personality to offend. It's like an homage to Paul McCartneys most tired solo efforts.

harmless wrote:

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

Lounge Lizard wrote:Thisbitchleakyet?

Most likely no

I found a link to it on Youtube posted like 1 day ago, but I didn't click the fucker.

Good man, stay strong

EJ wrote:

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Byzantine would have been a good word for you to use in the words tourney. You really overlooked some gems.

*rhinestones

McParadigm wrote:Future Days has a quality to it that brings the Eagles reunion tour to mind. More than that, it is exactly the kind of craft-without-impact filler that tends to come from an older artist who decides to write a song but feels no inherent drive. It is the epitome of safe and forgetful. It doesn't have enough personality to offend. It's like an homage to Paul McCartneys most tired solo efforts.

I'm not going to disagree with that, but I'll reserve the right to if the studio version changes my opinion of the song.


I've come to really like lightning bolt. It's just really a shame that it is has that clunky first set of lyrics.

harmless wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

harmless wrote:It's got minor chords, and minor chords are cool. That helps it.

I don't think it has a single minor chord

Isn't the chord on 'baby' a minor, rather than the predictable happy chord it could've been. And isn't that same chord repeated on 'And I know...'? I'm just using the ear, it might be major despite the fact it doesn't sound happy. But that chord could've easily been replaced with a happy chord and they chose not to.

I think the entire verse is just E and C. Maybe it sounds like a minor with Mike's slide accents, but I'd have to listen again to check.

McParadigm wrote:

EJ wrote:

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Byzantine would have been a good word for you to use in the words tourney. You really overlooked some gems.

*rhinestones

i thought about limiting myself to words in pearl jam songs, but if someone took waves early on I'd be fucked.

McParadigm wrote:Future Days has a quality to it that brings the Eagles reunion tour to mind. More than that, it is exactly the kind of craft-without-impact filler that tends to come from an older artist who decides to write a song but feels no inherent drive. It is the epitome of safe and forgetful. It doesn't have enough personality to offend. It's like an homage to Paul McCartneys most tired solo efforts.

I might be able to get behind this criticism, to be fair. It has more substance. But still, I don't know whether I'll feel like this when I've heard the album version on the album, and if I do, it definitely won't be the first time I've felt that way about a PJ song... by a long shot. The first thought I had after my first listen to Binaural was 'Man, they're getting old.' I felt embarrassed for my favourite band. But yet, it was a subjective feeling because obviously a lot of you didn't.

stip wrote:

McParadigm wrote:

EJ wrote:

stip wrote:

theplatypus wrote:

EJ wrote:

harmless wrote:So who actually thinks Thin Air is a go-to song, even when they're not listening to Binaural? I certainly don't. It's nice, but it's definitely a part of a whole and no more.

I do. Love it. Loved since they debuted it at Bridge School before Binaural was released. My opinion has not changed since.

Me too. I think it's great. Better than "Future Days" on just about every level.

the music on thin air is nice. Not crazy about the performance and don't like the lyrics.

Byzantine would have been a good word for you to use in the words tourney. You really overlooked some gems.

*rhinestones

i thought about limiting myself to words in pearl jam songs, but if someone took waves early on I'd be fucked.

If you'd only used words from bushleaguer you would have at least gotten out of the first round.