Red Mosquito

doug rr wrote:

Norris wrote:Yeah no Joy Division and no Velvet Underground is a god damned travesty.

tournaments will tear us apart

it's a real disorder

st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

I put St Vincent higher than Talking Heads on my list despite knowing that Talking Heads are objectively better and historically more significant. I put a lot of weight into what would I simply rather listen to right now.

In similar fashion though, how is Phoebe Bridgers on this list but not Bright Eyes?

Norris wrote:Yeah no Joy Division and no Velvet Underground is a god damned travesty.

right? i mean, anyone that doesn't see that those two bands should definitely be mentioned in the same breath as the mynabirds . . .

Norris wrote:In similar fashion though, how is Phoebe Bridgers on this list but not Bright Eyes?

Probably because Phoebe Bridgers is good and Bright Eyes is bad.

Mickey wrote:

Norris wrote:In similar fashion though, how is Phoebe Bridgers on this list but not Bright Eyes?

Probably because Phoebe Bridgers is good and Bright Eyes is bad.

well that clears things up, thanks mick

But seriously, Punisher to me sounds like a Bright Eyes album in songwriting style and instrumentation.

Argo, post the votes for each band.

Mickey wrote:I think the Pearl Jam albums should be considered, on the grounds that after all, almost none of them are "good"

Hard disagree.

Strat wrote:st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

Strat, I swear to god

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

Strat, I swear to god

Look she's great! But i didnt even think there were enough fans on this board to boost her to 13!

Strat wrote:

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

Strat, I swear to god

Look she's great! But i didnt even think there were enough fans on this board to boost her to 13!

I'm shocked three people put her on their lists, tbh

Norris wrote:Yeah no Joy Division and no Velvet Underground is a god damned travesty.

Luv

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

Strat, I swear to god

Look she's great! But i didnt even think there were enough fans on this board to boost her to 13!

I'm shocked three people put her on their lists, tbh

singing those nirvana songs that one time really did the trick

tragabigzanda wrote:just give the people what they want, PhatJ: Do you regret supporting Trump and are you ready to grovel for our collective embrace?

Not even a little bit.

Kevin Davis wrote:

Jorge wrote:That's the point of the points. To quantify!

Just would've been a weirder and more interesting list is all. It's actually not a big deal

I'd be happy to make you a list of artists, based on nothing, if you'd just like to have one to look at.

Not based on nothing. That's no fun. Based on points! Points assigned by RMers!

spike wrote:

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:

epilogue wrote:

Strat wrote:st vincent is awfully high. I mean, she's great, but 13?

Strat, I swear to god

Look she's great! But i didnt even think there were enough fans on this board to boost her to 13!

I'm shocked three people put her on their lists, tbh

singing those nirvana songs that one time really did the trick

Fuck! I meant to put Post Malone on my list!

epilogue wrote:

Mickey wrote:I think the Pearl Jam albums should be considered, on the grounds that after all, almost none of them are "good"

Hard disagree.

First of all none of them pass the bechdel test

Mickey wrote:

epilogue wrote:

Mickey wrote:I think the Pearl Jam albums should be considered, on the grounds that after all, almost none of them are "good"

Hard disagree.

First of all none of them pass the bechdel test

What a weird thing to post