Re: Yield: Official Album Thread
Posted: Mon February 03, 2025 10:25 pm
Leatherman for me
Hypnos wrote:Which outtake is the only one worthy of being on the album?
- Whale Song
- Leatherman
- U
- Happy When Im Crying
Actually none of them for me. I am curious about Leatherman II (Eddie mentioned about it in an interview and can be seen the title in Lost Dogs booklet, too).. Also Falling Down (Fallen in Lost Dogs booklet?) could be a nice addition..
For me is Whale Song.
all those songs would lose their charms on the album. better as bsidestremornick wrote:Hypnos wrote:Which outtake is the only one worthy of being on the album?
- Whale Song
- Leatherman
- U
- Happy When Im Crying
Actually none of them for me. I am curious about Leatherman II (Eddie mentioned about it in an interview and can be seen the title in Lost Dogs booklet, too).. Also Falling Down (Fallen in Lost Dogs booklet?) could be a nice addition..
For me is Whale Song.
I agree. The band was clearly having fun experimenting around this era.stip wrote:all those songs would lose their charms on the album. better as bsidestremornick wrote:Hypnos wrote:Which outtake is the only one worthy of being on the album?
- Whale Song
- Leatherman
- U
- Happy When Im Crying
Actually none of them for me. I am curious about Leatherman II (Eddie mentioned about it in an interview and can be seen the title in Lost Dogs booklet, too).. Also Falling Down (Fallen in Lost Dogs booklet?) could be a nice addition..
For me is Whale Song.
McParadigm wrote:I can imagine a world where Happy When I’m Crying, Black Red Yellow, Dead Man, and Sunburn are on an album together.
Nah. Two of those are Ed's songs!dimejinky99 wrote:McParadigm wrote:I can imagine a world where Happy When I’m Crying, Black Red Yellow, Dead Man, and Sunburn are on an album together.
And they would be if it weren’t for the dictatorial lead singer.
Sloppy Dupree wrote:Yield is my #3 album, but my main knock against it is that All Those Yesterdays is a mid-level closers. I like the song okay, but I don’t think it fits tonally as a closer for the tracks that came before it.
If anything, it's the fault of the tracks that come before it for not fitting tonally with All Those Yesterdays, which is one of their very best closers. But I think tonally, it's all fits. Yield is a vibe.Sloppy Dupree wrote:Yield is my #3 album, but my main knock against it is that All Those Yesterdays is a mid-level closers. I like the song okay, but I don’t think it fits tonally as a closer for the tracks that came before it.
I know what you mean and agree completelydimejinky99 wrote:That leak is the worst fucking thing that ever happened to this board