Re: Star Wars: Rogue One
Posted: Wed June 01, 2016 4:30 pm
Strat wrote:Thats my kind of star wars for sure. Especially he porn and whiskey
Strat wrote:Thats my kind of star wars for sure. Especially he porn and whiskey
I think part of it is that SW fans are appropriating the franchise. They don't care about the artist who created it, they just care about their own misguided nostalgia. To the point where they actually say a new film the creator wasn't even involved with that is essentially trying to mimic the creator's earlier films is more "Star Wars" than the creator's own recent Star Wars films. They think they know the artist's art better than the artist.durdencommatyler wrote:LoathedVermin72 wrote:THAT'S NOT MY STAR WARSdurdencommatyler wrote:I want a really somber, old school, Italian-style silent film about the hardships of being a Jawa. I want to see a downtrodden Jawa come home from a long 18 hour day of backbreaking labor, sit alone at his small, slightly rusted, table and drink 5 fingers of bad whiskey cry as he masturbates to Gungan porn.![]()
Why do you think that sentiment is so bothersome to you coming from Star Wars fans but not Star Trek fans?
However, upon further reflection, one wonders what would have happened if Gene Roddenberry had done an about-face in his later years and altered the fabric of Trek's ideology himself. Then what would the fan outrage mean? And how would I feel about it? Hmm.LoathedVermin72 wrote:I think part of it is that SW fans are appropriating the franchise. They don't care about the artist who created it, they just care about their own misguided nostalgia. To the point where they actually say a new film the creator wasn't even involved with that is essentially trying to mimic the creator's earlier films is more "Star Wars" than the creator's own recent Star Wars films. They think they know the artist's art better than the artist.durdencommatyler wrote:LoathedVermin72 wrote:THAT'S NOT MY STAR WARSdurdencommatyler wrote:I want a really somber, old school, Italian-style silent film about the hardships of being a Jawa. I want to see a downtrodden Jawa come home from a long 18 hour day of backbreaking labor, sit alone at his small, slightly rusted, table and drink 5 fingers of bad whiskey cry as he masturbates to Gungan porn.![]()
Why do you think that sentiment is so bothersome to you coming from Star Wars fans but not Star Trek fans?
The objections to contemporary Trek, however, are largely couched in outrage over how the people handling it are the ones who appropriated it and turned it into something its creator never wanted it to be.
They both might be fan outrage over how their beloved properties are being handled, but they're coming from opposite places.
The first one is understandable to me. The second one, not as much. But what you're saying makes perfect sense and I never really (honestly) looked at it like that before. So thank you.LoathedVermin72 wrote:I think part of it is that SW fans are appropriating the franchise. They don't care about the artist who created it, they just care about their own misguided nostalgia. To the point where they actually say a new film the creator wasn't even involved with that is essentially trying to mimic the creator's earlier films is more "Star Wars" than the creator's own recent Star Wars films. They think they know the artist's art better than the artist.durdencommatyler wrote:LoathedVermin72 wrote:THAT'S NOT MY STAR WARSdurdencommatyler wrote:I want a really somber, old school, Italian-style silent film about the hardships of being a Jawa. I want to see a downtrodden Jawa come home from a long 18 hour day of backbreaking labor, sit alone at his small, slightly rusted, table and drink 5 fingers of bad whiskey cry as he masturbates to Gungan porn.![]()
Why do you think that sentiment is so bothersome to you coming from Star Wars fans but not Star Trek fans?
The objections to contemporary Trek, however, are largely couched in outrage over how the people handling it are the ones who appropriated it and turned it into something its creator never wanted it to be.
They both might be fan outrage over how their beloved properties are being handled, but they're coming from opposite places.
E.H. Ruddock wrote:more like Rogue Fun, amirite?
after these latest rumors, it's even more like rogue doneLoathedVermin72 wrote:more like rogue pun amirite
they left me rogue stunneddprival78 wrote:after these latest rumors, it's even more like rogue doneLoathedVermin72 wrote:more like rogue pun amirite
I believe you.Strat wrote:I LEGIT ENJOYED STAR WARS NOT JUST BECAUSE IT REMINDED ME OF BEING A KID YOU FUCKING ASS CLOWN FUCK.
The Fierce AwakensStrat wrote:I'm sorry for yelling.