Page 7 of 12

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 7:44 pm
by Anders
tommy wrote:Wishlist is such a snooze. This album needs more energy.
Won’t Tell is the answer, also ensures DTE and DOTC.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:22 pm
by epilogue
Anders wrote:Voting for Alright takes Dance off the album, which would be a shame.
I agree, except we only get one song per album. I still love No Way in the #3 spot (a song I like more than Dance, though I'd also love to see Dance on this thing).

It's all about choices. If we don't pick Alright, and Dance doesn't win out for the #3 slot... what do we have left from Gigaton? Nothing super exciting, in my mind. So, Alright is a great strategic pick even if I'd rather have Dance on the album than Alright.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:31 pm
by Anders
DTE, DOTC and Won't Tell vs No Way, Alright and Waiting For Stevie.

For me the first group is better in all three categories.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:33 pm
by Farmer John
Everybody listen to Anders!

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:33 pm
by epilogue
Anders wrote:DTE, DOTC and Won't Tell vs No Way, Alright and Waiting For Stevie.

For me the first group is better in all three categories.
I think the people agree with you!

Sadly, I do not.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:34 pm
by Monkey_Driven
epilogue wrote:
Anders wrote:Voting for Alright takes Dance off the album, which would be a shame.
I agree, except we only get one song per album. I still love No Way in the #3 spot (a song I like more than Dance, though I'd also love to see Dance on this thing).

It's all about choices. If we don't pick Alright, and Dance doesn't win out for the #3 slot... what do we have left from Gigaton? Nothing super exciting, in my mind. So, Alright is a great strategic pick even if I'd rather have Dance on the album than Alright.
I'd rank No Way as the 4th best option from the Track 3 options remaining.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:34 pm
by epilogue
Farmer John wrote:Everybody listen to Anders!
If you think for one second that anyone is gonna listen to me in this experiment, you haven't posted here before.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:34 pm
by epilogue
Monkey_Driven wrote:
epilogue wrote:
Anders wrote:Voting for Alright takes Dance off the album, which would be a shame.
I agree, except we only get one song per album. I still love No Way in the #3 spot (a song I like more than Dance, though I'd also love to see Dance on this thing).

It's all about choices. If we don't pick Alright, and Dance doesn't win out for the #3 slot... what do we have left from Gigaton? Nothing super exciting, in my mind. So, Alright is a great strategic pick even if I'd rather have Dance on the album than Alright.
I'd rank No Way as the 4th best option from the Track 3 options remaining.
I might rank No Way as Pearl Jam's 4th best song!

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:36 pm
by epilogue
Dance is the only one that comes close. So, if we're gonna commit to Dance AND DTE, then I'll definitely join that team. Because, though it isn't my personal preference, I do like it. But I don't trust the jokey-jokers around here to let that happen.

One of these ding-dongs with multiple accounts is gonna fuck it up!

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:37 pm
by Monkey_Driven
epilogue wrote:
Monkey_Driven wrote:
epilogue wrote:
Anders wrote:Voting for Alright takes Dance off the album, which would be a shame.
I agree, except we only get one song per album. I still love No Way in the #3 spot (a song I like more than Dance, though I'd also love to see Dance on this thing).

It's all about choices. If we don't pick Alright, and Dance doesn't win out for the #3 slot... what do we have left from Gigaton? Nothing super exciting, in my mind. So, Alright is a great strategic pick even if I'd rather have Dance on the album than Alright.
I'd rank No Way as the 4th best option from the Track 3 options remaining.
I might rank No Way as Pearl Jam's 4th best song!
You're a mad man!


I also really like No Way

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:37 pm
by tommy
Now that it looks like we're safe from Wishlist I'm going to switch to Won't Tell

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:40 pm
by Anders
epilogue wrote:Dance is the only one that comes close. So, if we're gonna commit to Dance AND DTE, then I'll definitely join that team. Because, though it isn't my personal preference, I do like it. But I don't trust the jokey-jokers around here to let that happen.

One of these ding-dongs with multiple accounts is gonna fuck it up!
We'll form a bond together to fight for Dance and DTE. 100%

Including voting for the Backspacer and LB songs for the other track numbers, if they come up first.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:40 pm
by Anders
tommy wrote:Now that it looks like we're safe from Wishlist I'm going to switch to Won't Tell
:thumbsup:

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:43 pm
by epilogue
Anders wrote:
epilogue wrote:Dance is the only one that comes close. So, if we're gonna commit to Dance AND DTE, then I'll definitely join that team. Because, though it isn't my personal preference, I do like it. But I don't trust the jokey-jokers around here to let that happen.

One of these ding-dongs with multiple accounts is gonna fuck it up!
We'll form a bond together to fight for Dance and DTE. 100%

Including voting for the Backspacer and LB songs for the other track numbers, if they come up first.
Okay... I'm gonna do it, I'm gonna change my vote to Won't Tell. But if this goes sideways, Anders, I swear to god...

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:47 pm
by Tj
I think this is a failure, now that everyone one understands the strategy it will be much better in the future. Maybe we should do another right away

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:47 pm
by Kevin Davis
“Wishlist” is my favorite of these songs, but I will vote for “Won’t Tell” to keep “Alright” off. Really not a fan of that one.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:48 pm
by liebzz
Jesus folks! To and fro, the pendulum throws.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:48 pm
by Monkey_Driven
Tj wrote:I think this is a failure, now that everyone one understands the strategy it will be much better in the future. Maybe we should do another right away
Other than Come Back I think this is going pretty well, honestly.

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:49 pm
by Jorge
Tj wrote:I think this is a failure, now that everyone one understands the strategy it will be much better in the future. Maybe we should do another right away
We've already done this twice before lol

Re: Let's make the Ultimate PJ Album: TRACK 5

Posted: Wed November 20, 2024 8:49 pm
by tommy
We're playing a real dangerous game with Lightning Bolt. What songs are left from that thing?