Page 7 of 10
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Tue October 21, 2025 8:42 pm
by Simple Torture
Lorwyn Eclipsed looks like it’ll be right up your alley.
I like that since I don’t play paper Magic, I can avoid buying a UB set if I’m not into it collection-wise. I skipped Assassin’s Creed and Final Fantasy, and I’ll skip Avatar too. However, I do think it’s bogus that UB sets are going to outnumber in-universe sets next year.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Wed October 22, 2025 1:21 am
by washing machine
Simple Torture wrote:Lorwyn Eclipsed looks like it’ll be right up your alley.
Yeah buddy.
Also, check out this instagram.
https://www.instagram.com/oldschoolmtg? ... wzd3dhMWk2
These are the kind of cards I remember my older cousins bringing to Thanksgiving in the 90s.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Wed November 05, 2025 9:46 pm
by washing machine
Anyone else immediately concede anytime they see this stupid bastard?

Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Wed November 05, 2025 10:10 pm
by Simple Torture
I have a couple of cards that can remove those, so I’ll stick it out if I have a good position.

Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Wed November 05, 2025 11:04 pm
by washing machine
When you remove one, they just play another one!
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 06, 2025 12:03 am
by Simple Torture
I know. It’s rats all over again. Or Nazgûl (but at least there was a limit of 9 in those decks [and for transparency’s sake, I must disclose that I played a Nazgûl deck when it was legal in Standard]).
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 06, 2025 5:09 pm
by washing machine
You play a lot of red, right? Mowing cards down is kind of your thing. My poor greens can't deal with that kind of loop, but I'll give it a go with some of my red blue decks.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Fri November 07, 2025 5:43 pm
by washing machine
Okay, I did some crafting and I'm now ready for the hares.
I think the saga alone can work pretty well against a wide board, but I also have a new commander that can fish some other cool stuff out from the sea.
Doing reasonably well with this deck so far in brawl. I had a ton of wild cards to work with.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 20, 2025 3:38 pm
by washing machine
Honestly loving this Avatar set on Arena right now. I've crafted a formidable Earthbending (convert lands to creatures) deck that's got a decent winrate so far.
Surely my streak will hit a wall once I see more things like Day of the Black Sun.

Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 20, 2025 3:46 pm
by Mecca
Do I open or hold the 2 final fantasy play boosters I found in the store?
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 20, 2025 4:03 pm
by washing machine
Open them.
Do it now.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 20, 2025 4:05 pm
by washing machine
You know what's a cool card? Turtle-Duck.
As a one drop it blocks more than decently and I only need 3 mana a turn to get it stomping?

Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Thu November 20, 2025 4:10 pm
by tree_
nerd!
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Fri November 21, 2025 11:56 am
by blueviper
Plus, look how cute the turtle duck is! It lures you in with the “awwww” and bam!
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Fri November 21, 2025 5:01 pm
by Simple Torture
Those 0/4 creatures who aren't defenders can also be helpful in the early stages of a game if you have "If you attacked this turn..." triggers like Raid, since you can send them against opponents who have weak early creatures and they won't get destroyed, but you'll still get the trigger. Like just two examples:

Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Sat November 22, 2025 1:14 am
by washing machine
Mecca wrote:Do I open or hold the 2 final fantasy play boosters I found in the store?
Hope you opened them.
Anyway, I'm seeing restocks of FF boosters making their way onto shelves. Plenty to go around.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Sat November 22, 2025 1:18 am
by washing machine
On that note, I now own the Terra and the Cloud precon commander decks. Best Buy had them for $29 each.
You know what I did today? Played three solo rounds of brawl with myself across my kitchen table. Lame? Maybe. Before you judge, consider that people play Solitaire with regular playing cards all the time. I was getting a feel for paper magic and these deck mechanics because I'm never going to make it to a LGS for a real round of commander.
The Cloud deck won all three times. Terra takes a while to get online and Cloud auto-equips things like the 10/10 Colossus Hammer.
- Spoiler: show
- PRECON TERRA Deck https://share.google/WfdGTApy3HhTlTrCj
Supposed to excel at milling and graveyard recursion, but in three games I never could get a good graveyard going.
Cloud Precon // Commander (Cloud, Ex-SOLDIER) deck list mtg // Moxfield — MTG Deck Builder https://share.google/RkkEdoRW0mxKJsEOs
Excels at equipping artifacts.
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Sat November 22, 2025 1:30 am
by washing machine
ST, thanks for that tip. I'll try it out!
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Sat November 22, 2025 6:48 pm
by Mecca
washing machine wrote:Mecca wrote:Do I open or hold the 2 final fantasy play boosters I found in the store?
Hope you opened them.
Anyway, I'm seeing restocks of FF boosters making their way onto shelves. Plenty to go around.
I didn't get anything cool
Re: Me and Reid and Other Cool People Play Magic the Gatheri
Posted: Sat November 22, 2025 10:57 pm
by washing machine
Mecca wrote:I didn't get anything cool
I always smile when I see one of these little guys.
