Red Mosquito

darth_vedder wrote:

bodysnatcher wrote:what's the overall consensus on "Hummus"?

Love it, and I wish they'd try it live one of these days.

Yeah I've always loved it. I like it when we get those peaks into them goofing around

bodysnatcher wrote:

darth_vedder wrote:

bodysnatcher wrote:what's the overall consensus on "Hummus"?

Love it, and I wish they'd try it live one of these days.

Yeah I've always loved it. I like it when we get those peaks into them goofing around

I think it's the epitome of what a "hidden track" should be. It's perfect. They really nailed it with that one and with Writer's Block on Binuaral. Both of those hidden codas are perfect for their respective albums.

i think pj should cover Disgusitpated for their next hidden track.

stip wrote:i think pj should cover Disgusitpated for their next hidden track.

What is that?

the hidden track (track 69, actually. Get it?!) on Tool's album, undertow. One of my favorite hidden tracks of all time.

Birds in Hell wrote:I think the transition between Wishlist and Pilate is really weak.

I agree but I would transition into Pilate 3:26 earlier. I enjoy Yield infinitely more without Wishlist.

Birds in Hell wrote:I'd have preferred something a bit louder to separate them (Happy When I'm Crying?) or, perhaps even more suitably, a non faded-out ending to Wishlist.

Maybe Happy would work but I don't think it's strong enough. I always want a little something extra after Push Me Pull Me but there was nothing from those sessions that would work. A burst of energy ala Leash or Lukin.

I'm always heartened to find others who think Wishlist is terrible.

Wishlist is one of the few PJ songs I actively dislike.

I sometimes, out of nowhere, get a strange affection for it and ill listen to it and enjoy it. The rest of the time I skip it. It's pretty awful with Matt Cam.

I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

As bad as Wishlist is, Unthought Known is certainly a lot worse.

Sigerson wrote:I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

Wishlist>Why Can't I Touch It at 7/11/03 was one of the highlights.

Sigerson wrote:I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

the good part about it live is the mirror ball, as simple as it is i always like the lights with the mirror ball and i cant remember any other songs they might use it for.

There's absolutely nothing wrong with Wishlist.

I absolutely adore studio version Wishlist.

Hatfield wrote:

Sigerson wrote:I adore the album version of Wishlist. Don't care for it much live. Sure, it's a simple track but doesn't keep me from enjoying it. It's beautiful and understated, unlike Unthought Known (a track which I do actively dislike).

Wishlist>Why Can't I Touch It at 7/11/03 was one of the highlights.

Eddie hacks that version, but the tag/ crowd are great.

Birds in Hell wrote:As bad as Wishlist is, Unthought Known is certainly a lot worse.

I love them both.

EJ wrote:There's absolutely nothing wrong with Wishlist.

Wishlist is an excellent song.

Unthought Known is not.

I can't hate "Wishlist" too much. It's a sweet song (where 'sweet' means tender, pleasant and heartfelt, not 'sweet' as in the modern parlance of 'awesome').

i love wishlist. I always have.