mikejasond wrote:
The fact you guys think its so simple is just because it does what it does so dang WELL
Dude, you live in bizarro world. Reality is that YOU think daughter is amazing because it is SIMPLE done WELL. Not the other way around.
And like someone said before, I think it is the actual recording of the song that you are really most impressed with, you just don't realize it yet.
Also, this thread is maddening to read through. It's like everyone is just talking to a brick wall.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 1:22 am
by Birds in Hell
It's not just the recording, though; the things he's talking about are clearly related to the performance and arrangement of the song. There's a sense of space and dynamics missing from much of their later work.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 3:32 am
by digster
I'd actually agree that Daughter is deceptively complex in its' structure; it may be the most interesting way they crafted a piece of music on those first records, though other songs probably jump out to me more. I'm just surprised mike is latching onto the most conventional part of that song (we're going to start with an acoustic, then vocals, THEN DRUMS, then we'll pick it up for the chorus!) I also think the notion that this sort of songwriting inventiveness (although it may show up in other fashions) doesn't show up on the middle records is wrong.
But yeah, I'd say while I don't really agree mikejasond is correct in the least, Daughter is a more inventive song than it's often given credit for. He brought up Better Man for example; I love that song, it's a hell of a pop song, but Daughter takes quite a few more unexpected twists and turns, even if it doesn't draw attention to itself.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 2:59 pm
by mikejasond
There is just so much uniqueness in daughter you guys are overlooking.
Yes gradually adding instruments is standard. I still maintain it is done especially interestingly in daughter. even saying they 'just added instruments' is underselling it. The timing of it is unique and the effect is wonderful
And you're underselling the rest of the song too which is not standard in its structure in the WAY it's done. For example yes it goes to a chorus after the solo but the way it seamlessly transitions into a stripped down chorus without losing any momentum is not at all standard or obvious.
What I'm saying is they do it so flawlessly it sounds simple but it's actually very interesting. Just like the progression of the band under the song which falls very interestingly OUT of the standard structure
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 3:07 pm
by chewm
cutuphalfdead wrote:Mike isn't wrong about Daughter, he's just wrong about the songs he's comparing it to.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 3:15 pm
by Monkey_Driven
chewm wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:Mike isn't wrong about Daughter, he's just wrong about the songs he's comparing it to.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 6:45 pm
by Anders
mikejasond wrote:There is just so much uniqueness in daughter you guys are overlooking.
Yes gradually adding instruments is standard. I still maintain it is done especially interestingly in daughter. even saying they 'just added instruments' is underselling it. The timing of it is unique and the effect is wonderful
And you're underselling the rest of the song too which is not standard in its structure in the WAY it's done. For example yes it goes to a chorus after the solo but the way it seamlessly transitions into a stripped down chorus without losing any momentum is not at all standard or obvious.
What I'm saying is they do it so flawlessly it sounds simple but it's actually very interesting. Just like the progression of the band under the song which falls very interestingly OUT of the standard structure
Ive never said anything bad at Stone's songwriting and creative abilities, just his ability to perform live
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 6:53 pm
by Anders
mikejasond wrote:Ive never said anything bad at Stone's songwriting and creative abilities, just his ability to perform live
Never wrong with some love for the Bossman.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 7:47 pm
by bodysnatcher
jesus christ i just skipped from page 4 to page 7 and this is still happening
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:24 pm
by stip
cutuphalfdead wrote:So daughter is simple but used complexly, while soh is just simple?
It's more that SoH is just boring
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:25 pm
by stip
Strat wrote:Or the bridges in evacuation
the bridge in evacuation is helped immensely by the fact that the song surrounding it isn't very good. Like how I would look tall standing next to peter dinklage.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:26 pm
by stip
Strat wrote:or the change int he bridge of Light Years?
that's the part ripped from puzzles and games, right? That part is really good
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:26 pm
by stip
mikejasond wrote:i would compare it to the GRRM books, A Song of Ice and Fire.
The first albums are the first books of the series. Just an amazingly laid out and told story. Straight to the point, expert pacing.
Then the middle albums are feast for crows, and dance with dragons. Bloated, 'esoteric', rambling. So many songs on Binaural are twice as long as they need to be. Light Years and Nothing as it Seems the chief offenders, which get 5+ minutes out of barely any content. I dont feel the runtime of either song is earned.
you guys don't deserve mikejasond
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:28 pm
by Norah
mikejasond wrote:Ive never said anything bad at Stone's songwriting and creative abilities, just his ability to perform live
May I submit to you...
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 8:36 pm
by Strat
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Or the bridges in evacuation
the bridge in evacuation is helped immensely by the fact that the song surrounding it isn't very good. Like how I would look tall standing next to peter dinklage.
Goddammit stip.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 9:14 pm
by mikejasond
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Or the bridges in evacuation
the bridge in evacuation is helped immensely by the fact that the song surrounding it isn't very good. Like how I would look tall standing next to peter dinklage.
lol I love Stip
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 9:15 pm
by mikejasond
cutuphalfdead wrote:
mikejasond wrote:Ive never said anything bad at Stone's songwriting and creative abilities, just his ability to perform live
May I submit to you...
Yes that's probably his best song, and do the evolution (and maybe daughter?). Then he makes a mess of Black almost every time.
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 15, 2017 11:24 pm
by bodysnatcher
mikejasond wrote:
stip wrote:
Strat wrote:Or the bridges in evacuation
the bridge in evacuation is helped immensely by the fact that the song surrounding it isn't very good. Like how I would look tall standing next to peter dinklage.
lol I love Stip
mikejason is stip. stip is mikejason? STIP IS A MAN???
Re: Song of the Moment: Daughter
Posted: Fri September 07, 2018 8:52 pm
by dimejinky99
FInd myself listening to this one more and more lately. There’s a weird huge heart in this song separate to it’s lyrics maybe.
