Red Mosquito

I would admit to being a Soundgarden fan without hesitation.

I just Kanye

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I just Kanye

I accidentally Kanye'd in my pants recently, when I thought it was just a fart.

I only Kanye

Will there a come a day when Pearl Jam are held in higher regard among music fans? There's precedent for this right? Bands and albums that are more appreciated long after the band has called it quits.

I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Leatherhead wrote:Will there a come a day when Pearl Jam are held in higher regard among music fans? There's precedent for this right? Bands and albums that are more appreciated long after the band has called it quits.

To an extent I think that's already happened. I feel like they're now mentioned by music critics in ways other than being the punchline of a joke and that wasn't the case before 2006 or so.

Unfortunately I think the increased attention has probably tended to cement the "big hits from the early 90s > boring middle period with boring records > great live band with bootlegs" narrative permanently in place, something the band also seem eager to buy into for whatever reason.

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

chewm wrote:

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

The insecurity inherent in making thousands of posts about the minutiae of Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam message board and then not even admitting you like the band is hilarious.

Birds in Hell wrote:

Leatherhead wrote:Will there a come a day when Pearl Jam are held in higher regard among music fans? There's precedent for this right? Bands and albums that are more appreciated long after the band has called it quits.

To an extent I think that's already happened. I feel like they're now mentioned by music critics in ways other than being the punchline of a joke and that wasn't the case before 2006 or so.

Unfortunately I think the increased attention has probably tended to cement the "big hits from the early 90s > boring middle period with boring records > great live band with bootlegs" narrative permanently in place, something the band also seem eager to buy into for whatever reason.

Yea. I guess I was referring more to the "boring middle period."

evenslow wrote:

chewm wrote:

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

The insecurity inherent in making thousands of posts about the minutiae of Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam message board and then not even admitting you like the band is hilarious.

It's comparable to having a serious fetish, I guess. It's something I get genuine enjoyment from and don't mind discussing in situations where I'm comfortable I won't be judged but I'm not about to bring it up with colleagues or strangers lest they think I'm some kind of deviant.

Birds in Hell wrote:

evenslow wrote:

chewm wrote:

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

The insecurity inherent in making thousands of posts about the minutiae of Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam message board and then not even admitting you like the band is hilarious.

It's comparable to having a serious fetish, I guess. It's something I get genuine enjoyment from and don't mind discussing in situations where I'm comfortable I won't be judged but I'm not about to bring it up with colleagues or strangers lest they think I'm some kind of deviant.

These days if PJ specifically came up, I'd say I love their middle albums and they are fun live, but I don't think I would mention them if someone asked me about my favorite bands. The middle era was such a long time ago.

evenslow wrote:

Birds in Hell wrote:

evenslow wrote:

chewm wrote:

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

The insecurity inherent in making thousands of posts about the minutiae of Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam message board and then not even admitting you like the band is hilarious.

It's comparable to having a serious fetish, I guess. It's something I get genuine enjoyment from and don't mind discussing in situations where I'm comfortable I won't be judged but I'm not about to bring it up with colleagues or strangers lest they think I'm some kind of deviant.

Is that Bartolo Colon?

I'm in no way embarrassed by my PJ fandom (or my fandom of any band for that matter).

evenslow wrote:

chewm wrote:

wease wrote:I have no problem telling people I like Pearl Jam or Soundgarden. I like what I like. Fuck other people if they have a problem with it.

Seriously, bunch of snobs.

The insecurity inherent in making thousands of posts about the minutiae of Pearl Jam on a Pearl Jam message board and then not even admitting you like the band is hilarious.

Embarrassed is probably not the right word. if I'm having an in depth music chat with a good friend I'll mention pearl jam and defend them if I have to, but if I'm in a casual conversation with a random, I feel like it's easier to not mention them at all. I think the relationship I have with pj is complicated haha.

I understand being tentative about expressing one's lower-minded music tastes among internet snobs, but among the general public? Probably 80% of the 135,000 people in my city own Luke Bryan t-shirts -- these are not people I worry about looking foolish in front of. Plus, historically, I end up establishing myself pretty early on in most groups as "the music guy," so people don't generally question my tastes. In the past, when people would take me to task for one of my lowbrow tastes, I would simply talk down to them using music jargon and make them feel like they were the ones who were wrong, not me. This doesn't work as well on the internet, but it really helped keep the rubes at bay when I was younger.

Now, I find that real-life opportunities to discuss music only arise once every 4-5 months, so I've mellowed a bit. I did recently tell a coworker that I hated Billy Joel though, and also went on a rant about the Avett Brothers.

I think it's time for everyone to come out of the Pearl Jam closet.

Admit that you vote on every Pearl Jam song ever created in a poll from 1-5 stars.

Admit that you Let's Actually Listened to an album to give your most updated, most current thoughts on an record that 98% of society wouldn't be able to pick out of a lineup.

Admit that you can recite each drummer's name within 5 seconds while also saying exactly why one of them is your favorite and the other ones suck.

Admit that you know the why's and wherefore's of the word "Rodlease."

Admit that three letters - BOB - conjure up a world of emotion in you that outweighs the birth of your first child.

Admit that you have an exact and wordy definition for the term, "middle period."

Admit that you're Stone's Bitch.

Admit that when it's dark and quiet and everyone's asleep you still pine for the post-Backspacer EP Mike McCready offhandedly mentioned in a random interview some years back.

Admit that you feel a chill go up your spine when you hear the phrase, "from the ashes of Mother Love Bone."

Admit that you could lead a 75 minute panel discussion about the tragedy of compression and faulty mastering in Pearl Jam's self titled album.

Admit that you have a definite opinion on the firing of Ricky Ramone.

Admit that you endlessly ponder such things as fadeouts and re-recorded vocals to old tracks.

Admit that you know the lyrics to something called Sweet Lew.

Admit that a person who calls himself "mikejasond" has really gotten under your skin. Yet, somewhere deep inside, you can't live without him.

I prefer Seven Mary Three, but I don't think they have a message board.