Red Mosquito

MadBum's game should be considered a no-hitter

lennytheweedwhacker wrote:MadBum's game should be considered a no-hitter

I’m good with that, the Braves managed one hit in two games.

Wasnt there someone who took a no-hitter into the 10th and lost it there, and it didnt count as a no-hitter?

Official rule is you gotta pitch at least nine.

numbers wrote:Wasnt there someone who took a no-hitter into the 10th and lost it there, and it didnt count as a no-hitter?

Correct. It didn’t count.

numbers wrote:Wasnt there someone who took a no-hitter into the 10th and lost it there, and it didnt count as a no-hitter?

Pedro once brought a perfect game into the 10th and lost it. I also believe Rich Hill did something similar a few years ago.

We all know that Tigers pitcher (Gallaraga?) threw a no-no when the ump (Joyce?) fucked up the 27th out call at 1st base. That might have actually been a perfect game?

Not officially in the record books ... but we know.

Bammer wrote:We all know that Tigers pitcher (Gallaraga?) threw a no-no when the ump (Joyce?) fucked up the 27th out call at 1st base. That might have actually been a perfect game?

Not officially in the record books ... but we know.

Yes. It was a perfect game.

I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

spike wrote:Official rule is you gotta pitch at least nine.

it is, but i just take issue with the rule

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

numbers wrote:

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

i’m tempted to say that’s less worthy than a 7-inning no hitter...i just feel like the pitcher is being punished when the game length is shortened by rule

numbers wrote:

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

Is that even possible?

Bammer wrote:

numbers wrote:

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

Is that even possible?

If you're the home team, then yeah. You can pitch a 9-inning no hitter and give up any number of runs.

Simple Torture wrote:

Bammer wrote:

numbers wrote:

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

Is that even possible?

If you're the home team, then yeah. You can pitch a 9-inning no hitter and give up any number of runs.

In fact, it's happened once; here's the game log: https://www.baseball-reference.com/boxe ... 4230.shtml

they could walk or hit five batters in a row also

lennytheweedwhacker wrote:they could walk or hit five batters in a row also

how many times have you been hit by a fastball?

Simple Torture wrote:

Bammer wrote:

numbers wrote:

philpritchard wrote:I'm perfectly fine with an official no-hitter requiring both a complete game and at least nine innings.

Yeah. What if the pitcher does both but doesn't win the game? Thoughts?

Is that even possible?

If you're the home team, then yeah. You can pitch a 9-inning no hitter and give up any number of runs.

Sorry nevermind I was thinking perfect game not no-hitter

But maybe it could happen. 10-inning perfect game but in the 10th a runner starts on 2nd base. Maybe that guy steals two bases. Or scores on a sac fly.

doug rr wrote:

lennytheweedwhacker wrote:they could walk or hit five batters in a row also

how many times have you been hit by a fastball?

i can’t remember if i was ever hit in little league...the one year i pitched i did hit a few in one inning though

my god that team was awful...myself and the coach’s son were pretty much tied as the best players...thus we didn’t win a single game

go giants, btw