Red Mosquito

injuddstree wrote:

brisk wrote:

injuddstree wrote:Ed sounds really good on the Stern songs.

Why do people keep saying this, he clearly doesn't, he isn't hitting all of the notes/wrong notes and on fear he barely attempts the big 'woah', yes it's early and new but either way it objectively is not good for the new tunes.

I said it because it's my opinion based on his voice in recent years and based on what I was expecting. I think he sounds good.

brisk wrote:

injuddstree wrote:Ed sounds really good on the Stern songs.

Why do people keep saying this, he clearly doesn't, he isn't hitting all of the notes/wrong notes and on fear he barely attempts the big 'woah', yes it's early and new but either way it objectively is not good for the new tunes.

dprival78 wrote:i didn't think eddie sounded that great either. not terrible, but not great.

i sense much half-step de-tuning in the future

Noaheb wrote:

dprival78 wrote:i didn't think eddie sounded that great either. not terrible, but not great.

i sense much half-step de-tuning in the future

dimejinky99 wrote:

Noaheb wrote:

dprival78 wrote:i didn't think eddie sounded that great either. not terrible, but not great.

i sense much half-step de-tuning in the future

It’s bizarre to me they don’t factor that in when writing and recording

It will inevitably happen in the live setting. Why not just make that the case on the record?

Very strange.

Arthur Morgan wrote:I think Ed sounded good this morning. I feel he has lost some range, and that will continue to go away gradually with age. But his voice sounded strong and younger to me.

Knocking out two weeks in the studio when you are focusing on a couple of songs a day or one off media appearances are not as taxing on for his voice.


The biggest thing I worry about is his ability to sing over the course of an entire tour. You can hear it in his voice now more than ever(2022-2023) that he gets hoarse as the tour goes on. That leads to cancellations.


This is the biggest factor in me trying to just appreciate every moment. I feel our time with the band is limited. Hope I’m wrong and if I am then it’s all gravy.

Maybe they will go Beatles and just make studio records at some point

stip wrote:

Arthur Morgan wrote:I think Ed sounded good this morning. I feel he has lost some range, and that will continue to go away gradually with age. But his voice sounded strong and younger to me.

Knocking out two weeks in the studio when you are focusing on a couple of songs a day or one off media appearances are not as taxing on for his voice.


The biggest thing I worry about is his ability to sing over the course of an entire tour. You can hear it in his voice now more than ever(2022-2023) that he gets hoarse as the tour goes on. That leads to cancellations.


This is the biggest factor in me trying to just appreciate every moment. I feel our time with the band is limited. Hope I’m wrong and if I am then it’s all gravy.

Maybe they will go Beatles and just make studio records at some point

I wonder if they would approach the studio differently if they were writing WITHOUT the intent to tour.

digster wrote:I think their best move is to just write the songs as they should be, in whatever key or melody feels right for what they're chasing, and worry about the live show later. Ed's almost 60, and he's trying to sing songs from his youth every night that are extremely challenging. There's just no way it's not going to be an issue.

tree_ wrote:But the Beatles broke up before they were 30!

DDWJMUVW wrote:WTF are you still smoking for??

DDWJMUVW wrote:I also thought he sounded good considering. And that’s the key word. If you’re expecting him to sound like 91-94 Ed you’re batshit. If you’re expecting 98 tour you’re nuts. If you’re expecting 09/13 you’re asking a lot.

I think Watt kept him in his pocket vocally on this record and I like that. Don’t choose registers that don’t work for him at this point. He still has an amazing voice, and one of the most unique in rock history, but play to your strengths given your age.

If he can be selective with how he uses his voice night by night on the tour, it will serve him well in the long term. I was a little disappointed when he didn’t answer Howard’s question about maintaining his voice with: oh I do x/y/z and instead said he “just leans into it”. No dude - you need to be preserving with exercises and therapy. He admitted at St Paul N1 last summer to smoking in the shower in his hotel that morning. WTF are you still smoking for??