Red Mosquito

stip wrote:

Release_Me wrote:CC is a solid 4.5 star song for me. That's heading into Black/Nothingman/Immortality territory as far as PJ's slower songs/ballads are concerned. The only thing needed to make it a 5 star song is for Ed to redo the vocals. Not differently, just better. I love his approach and I don't want him to sing lower or in a different tone as some have suggested. I just think there is never a good enough reason for a studio song to have unintentional voice breaks like this one does. That's probably because this is a demo and Ed did only one take. If the vocals could be redone, this song would be the best slow one they made since Vitalogy. It's that good.

LIR is sitting somewhere close to 4 stars for me. The first half of the song I'm just waiting to get over with so I can listen to the eargasm that is the second half. Again, could do with a slightly better vocal but very good song nonetheless.

MYM is also sitting at 4.5 stars at the moment. I think it's the best song they've made with this kind of blueprint. I prefer it to STBC because it is more melodic.

I'm liking LB at least as much as LIR at the moment. It's more engaging from the get-go and Ed's vocals just soar. LIR has that amazing second half though so hard to split the two.

FD is easily the song I like the least from the five which have surfaced. 3 stars at this point. I put it in the same boat as most PJ ballads post Vitalogy; Around The Bend, All Those Yesterdays, Thin Air, Parting Ways, etc. Pretty, but not essential PJ. I do relate to the sentiment because I'm married and our first one is on the way.

Congrats and good luck! We have a parents thread in general discussion. It will help

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

EJ wrote:Just think buried in the vault, there exists recorded versions of Thin Air, Of The Girl, and Parting Ways with Jack Irons.

That would give us all yet another way of retracking Binaural.

Strat wrote:

Thejambi wrote:

WtOB? wrote:

Lounge Lizard wrote:

Release_Me wrote:Well, to me it's the 'breathiness' of the vocals which give the song it's character. I don't think the voice breaking adds anything to it.

I agree. It's actually taking away from the song. Let's admit it - bad singing has never done any good to a song, and this singing was plain bad.

No, this is bad singing:


What he's doing on CC is an artistic choice, not bad singing. I happen to think it's really good singing. Vulnerable doesn't mean bad.

Same can be said for The End.

Aw man, I like the fixer.

Also, I can't help it. I love the mans voice and ill take his "bad" singing any day

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

Good luck

Release_Me wrote:

Strat wrote:

Thejambi wrote:

WtOB? wrote:

Lounge Lizard wrote:

Release_Me wrote:Well, to me it's the 'breathiness' of the vocals which give the song it's character. I don't think the voice breaking adds anything to it.

I agree. It's actually taking away from the song. Let's admit it - bad singing has never done any good to a song, and this singing was plain bad.

No, this is bad singing:


What he's doing on CC is an artistic choice, not bad singing. I happen to think it's really good singing. Vulnerable doesn't mean bad.

Same can be said for The End.

Aw man, I like the fixer.

Also, I can't help it. I love the mans voice and ill take his "bad" singing any day

I guess I have a different appreciation of vocals than you guys and what I'm finding as a fault is fine with you. I don't mind Ed sounding vulnerable. I don't equate that with bad. I equate not being able to hold a note as bad and voice cracking unintentionally as bad. I am not against screaming Ed either as most seem to be here. I like Ed's singing on the Fixer. I also like it on The End, Inside Job and Immortality. Those three songs are bringing vulnerability without sacrificing on the technical aspects of singing. That's my only qualm about CC which I still love as it is. I'm a bit of a vocal snob so you're never going to be able to convince me that voice cracks and unintentional notes are good in anyway.

southp wrote:

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

well technically they're not b-sides right? They're unmastered demos.
Hopefully the fact that you clued him into the rarity of them, won't deter him from give them all up.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

Good luck

Dude, shouldn't you be at the beach with your wife or something?

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

EJ wrote:Just think buried in the vault, there exists recorded versions of Thin Air, Of The Girl, and Parting Ways with Jack Irons.

That would give us all yet another way of retracking Binaural.

I can understand parting ways, but were thin air and of the girl supposedly written around the same time as parting ways?

EJ wrote:

Dr. Van Nostrand wrote:

EJ wrote:Just think buried in the vault, there exists recorded versions of Thin Air, Of The Girl, and Parting Ways with Jack Irons.

That would give us all yet another way of retracking Binaural.

I can understand parting ways, but were thin air and of the girl supposedly written around the same time as parting ways?

Febbraio/Giugno 1997 - Studio Litho - Seattle, WA; Agosto/Settembre 1997 - Studio Litho and Studio X - Seattle, WA and Southern Tracks Recording - Atlanta, GA
Ed Vedder - vocals, guitar, background vocals; Stone Gossard - guitar, background vocals, bass on 'Do The Evolution' and 'No Way'; Mike McCready - guitar; Jeff Ament - bass, background vocals; Jack Irons - drum kit, percussion, vocals on 'The Whale Song'; Brendan O'Brien - organ, piano

All Those Yesterdays
Bayleaf
Brain Of J.
Bulldozer
Color Red, The (a.k.a. Red Dot)
Do The Evolution
Faithfull
Fallen (a.k.a. Falling Down)
Given To Fly
Happy When I'm Crying
Hummus
In Hiding
Leatherman
Leatherman II
Low Light
MFC (a.k.a. Mini Fast Car)
No Way
Of The Girl
Parting Ways
Pilate
Push Me, Pull Me
Thin Air
Whale Song, The (a.k.a. Whales)
Wishlist
U

KurtLeon wrote:Talked to my contact yesterday, he did not even know that these songs were B-Sides!
He is going to try to get HIS contact to send more.

Now, lets hope and wait.

southp wrote:ooohh.. Leatherman II??.... if only we could hear that one!