Red Mosquito

dimejinky99 wrote:I can't figure this out.

Why release this new edition with JJs commentary, only on 3D blu ray?

I mean that's beyond niche. They'd make far more money making it a regular DVD blue Ray release surely?

Welcome to star wars, dime. Take a seat. Get comfortable.

dimejinky99 wrote:I can't figure this out.

Why release this new edition with JJs commentary, only on 3D blu ray?

I mean that's beyond niche. They'd make far more money making it a regular DVD blue Ray release surely?

This is the edition I've been waiting to buy

Rangi Guy wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:I can't figure this out.

Why release this new edition with JJs commentary, only on 3D blu ray?

I mean that's beyond niche. They'd make far more money making it a regular DVD blue Ray release surely?

This is the edition I've been waiting to buy

Wanna Dropbox me the audio commentary?

I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

It's not apparently.

dimejinky99 wrote:

Rangi Guy wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:I can't figure this out.

Why release this new edition with JJs commentary, only on 3D blu ray?

I mean that's beyond niche. They'd make far more money making it a regular DVD blue Ray release surely?

This is the edition I've been waiting to buy

Wanna Dropbox me the audio commentary?

If I knew how to do this - I would in an instant

dimejinky99 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

It's not apparently.

Source? I find that extremely unlikely. Like, that would be unprecedented.

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

It's not apparently.

Source? I find that extremely unlikely. Like, that would be unprecedented.

Yeah, I'm gonna go ahead and say this isn't true. The only way that would make sense is if they were being cheap and just throwing in the exact same 2D Blu-ray from the previous release. But I found pictures of the 2D discs and they have different images on them, so that's not the case. I would bet money the commentary is on the 2D disc as well as the 3D disc.

Spoiler: show

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

It's not apparently.

Source? I find that extremely unlikely. Like, that would be unprecedented.

Yeah, I'm gonna go ahead and say this isn't true. The only way that would make sense is if they were being cheap and just throwing in the exact same 2D Blu-ray from the previous release. But I found pictures of the 2D discs and they have different images on them, so that's not the case. I would bet money the commentary is on the 2D disc as well as the 3D disc.

Spoiler: show

If you'd read the blurb attached with those images you'd see. The commentary is only on the 3D blu ray

dimejinky99 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

dimejinky99 wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:I'm sure the commentary is on the 2D Blu-ray that's included in the set, no?

It's not apparently.

Source? I find that extremely unlikely. Like, that would be unprecedented.

Yeah, I'm gonna go ahead and say this isn't true. The only way that would make sense is if they were being cheap and just throwing in the exact same 2D Blu-ray from the previous release. But I found pictures of the 2D discs and they have different images on them, so that's not the case. I would bet money the commentary is on the 2D disc as well as the 3D disc.

Spoiler: show

If you'd read the blurb attached with those images you'd see. The commentary is only on the 3D blu ray

Where? I read them. Show me where it says that.

Do you mean this?

Digital bonus offerings may vary by retailer. New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only.

Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc; it is saying they are only available in the physical package and may not be available digitally.

LoathedVermin72 wrote:Do you mean this?

Digital bonus offerings may vary by retailer. New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only.

Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc; it is saying they are only available in the physical package and may not be available digitally.

Those look like 2 separate statements to me and that the new bonus content is only available in the 3d Collectors edition.

Strat wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:Do you mean this?

Digital bonus offerings may vary by retailer. New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only.

Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc; it is saying they are only available in the physical package and may not be available digitally.

Those look like 2 separate statements to me and that the new bonus content is only available in the 3d Collectors edition.

Uhh...that's what I said?

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

Strat wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:Do you mean this?

Digital bonus offerings may vary by retailer. New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only.

Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc; it is saying they are only available in the physical package and may not be available digitally.

Those look like 2 separate statements to me and that the new bonus content is only available in the 3d Collectors edition.

Uhh...that's what I said?

"Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc"

I think that is exactly what it is saying

"New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only"

Strat wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:

Strat wrote:

LoathedVermin72 wrote:Do you mean this?

Digital bonus offerings may vary by retailer. New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only.

Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc; it is saying they are only available in the physical package and may not be available digitally.

Those look like 2 separate statements to me and that the new bonus content is only available in the 3d Collectors edition.

Uhh...that's what I said?

"Because that is not saying the new features are only on the 3D disc"

I think that is exactly what it is saying

"New bonus content is available in the 3D Collector’s Edition package only"

"3D Collector's Edition Package" does not mean "only on the 3D disc." A 2D disc is included in that package.

I own like 2000 Blu-rays/DVDs. I am familiar with the terminology.

Ok well all the podcasts I listen to are all failing about it and it's very clear in the blurb the commentary is only on the 3D bluray. We have a trump already LV. Don't be another. Surplus to requirement.

dimejinky99 wrote:Ok well all the podcasts I listen to are all failing about it and it's very clear in the blurb the commentary is only on the 3D bluray. We have a trump already LV. Don't be another. Surplus to requirement.

It is not "very clear" at all. Nothing in that announcement states that. As I said, I am very familiar with Blu-ray terminology and press releases. Again, I'd love for you to tell me exactly where it says that.

I guess we'll find out for sure once this thing actually comes out.

LV. Find me the announcement about a DVD blurayrelease of the special edition of force awakens with audio commentary by director JJ Abrams

dimejinky99 wrote:LV. Find me the announcement about a DVD blurayrelease of the special edition of force awakens with audio commentary by director JJ Abrams

What? That is the announcement. It is a 3D Collector's Edition. And like most/all 3D Collector's Editions, it also includes a 2D disc. Nothing in that announcement states the commentary is only on the 3D disc; just that it is exclusive to this Collector's Edition.

Funny you don't see me mirroring your shit in the rogue one thread