Red Mosquito

Django Butterworth wrote:The only one I am not immediately sold on is Let The Records Play.

No idea why.

Cos as much as its an attempt to do something new it just isn't that good?

Easily the low point of what we have so far.

Sirens must not be the new sinlge if it's not on this...

stip wrote:

stupidmop wrote:Doesnt the post at the pit say Thursday? As in next week? Unless its still Thursday somewhere.

Getaway into cold confession works quite well.

If I like any of the new tracks as much as I like CC ill be happy.

I've pretty much discarded swallowed whole as just not my thing.

well I think CC is better than these songs. But these are good.

CC is better than 95 percent of their output

McParadigm wrote:I'm disappointed you all haven't talked yourselves into "best record since Vitalogy" yet.

Fairly sure I'll like it more than the last two. Everything could fail at Sirens, SBM or FD though.

McParadigm wrote:

Django Butterworth wrote:The only one I am not immediately sold on is Let The Records Play.

No idea why.

Cos as much as its an attempt to do something new it just isn't that good?

Easily the low point of what we have so far.

I can not support this at all.

Django Butterworth wrote:Sirens must not be the new sinlge if it's not on this...

I dunno. It's been pointed out that the audio files leaked today mention something about an MLB Promo. So theory is that this is a leaked promo CD containing the most upbeat songs on the album that will be used in some MLB promos/trailers/features/whatever.

Tj wrote:

McParadigm wrote:

Django Butterworth wrote:The only one I am not immediately sold on is Let The Records Play.

No idea why.

Cos as much as its an attempt to do something new it just isn't that good?

Easily the low point of what we have so far.

I can not support this at all.

In fact I don't know if the band has sounded this fresh since 1991

Getaway

But if you're gonna promote during the playoffs, wouldn't you want to include the single?

I would think so.

Tj wrote:

Tj wrote:

McParadigm wrote:

Django Butterworth wrote:The only one I am not immediately sold on is Let The Records Play.

No idea why.

Cos as much as its an attempt to do something new it just isn't that good?

Easily the low point of what we have so far.

I can not support this at all.

In fact I don't know if the band has sounded this fresh since 1991

Not that this is the best they have sound fresh is different than good.

stupidmop wrote:Doesnt the post at the pit say Thursday? As in next week? Unless its still Thursday somewhere.

Damn, I totally had myself convinced it was Thursday... ha ha...

Django Butterworth wrote:But if you're gonna promote during the playoffs, wouldn't you want to include the single?

I would think so.

Perhaps that was Track 4 that we didn't get.

Tj wrote:

stip wrote:

stupidmop wrote:Doesnt the post at the pit say Thursday? As in next week? Unless its still Thursday somewhere.

Getaway into cold confession works quite well.

If I like any of the new tracks as much as I like CC ill be happy.

I've pretty much discarded swallowed whole as just not my thing.

well I think CC is better than these songs. But these are good.

CC is better than 95 percent of their output

Im not too fond of CC, I liked LIR better and I like these songs better too...Different strokes I guess

Django Butterworth wrote:But if you're gonna promote during the playoffs, wouldn't you want to include the single?

I would think so.

Not necessarily, not if you're not ready to launch it yet. The single needs a huge promo push in itself, aside from the album. If anyone's heard it prior to its release, it could fall flat.

Django Butterworth wrote:But if you're gonna promote during the playoffs, wouldn't you want to include the single?

I would think so.

Yeah maybe, although the guy who leaked this said Mind Your Manners was also included in the leak, which is already a single...who knows.

Getaway starts off like Jessie's Girl ? Or I can hear Pat Benatar singing this.

Iowaska_Experience wrote:

Django Butterworth wrote:But if you're gonna promote during the playoffs, wouldn't you want to include the single?

I would think so.

Perhaps that was Track 4 that we didn't get.

That was probably Mind Your Manners. Original leaker on Phish forum said MYM was included.

harmless wrote:

McParadigm wrote:I'm disappointed you all haven't talked yourselves into "best record since Vitalogy" yet.

Fairly sure I'll like it more than the last two. Everything could fail at Sirens, SBM or FD though.

Assuming (!) that SBM and FD are as underwhelming as most of us seem to expect, and assuming (!) that My Father's Son/Infallible/Pendulum/Yellow Moon are as good/interesting as the reviews have led us to expect, these four songs are good enough that Sirens might be the song that pushes this album decidedly toward "really good" or "eh, it's okay."

"Every bone is naked in this town."

Great line.

Jaeti wrote:

harmless wrote:

McParadigm wrote:I'm disappointed you all haven't talked yourselves into "best record since Vitalogy" yet.

Fairly sure I'll like it more than the last two. Everything could fail at Sirens, SBM or FD though.

Assuming (!) that SBM and FD are as underwhelming as most of us seem to expect, and assuming (!) that My Father's Son/Infallible/Pendulum/Yellow Moon are as good/interesting as the reviews have led us to expect, these four songs are good enough that Sirens might be the song that pushes this album decidedly toward "really good" or "eh, it's okay."

Very much so. Sirens is relatively long, so if it's bad, it's bad for a relatively long time.