Page 8 of 17

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 9:36 pm
by bodysnatcher
Cold Confession

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 9:51 pm
by B
Simple Torture wrote:I find the backlash to the analysis of this phenomenon to be the most interesting thing of all. There have been lots of pieces floating around asking questions like, "How much awareness is actually being raised? What other messages are these videos saying? (About access, about disability, about peer pressure) How has this been distorted from the start?" And whenever I've read something like this, most comments are along the lines of what bodysnatcher described: "It raises money, why ask questions?" "Sounds like someone is afraid to do it!" "$1.5 million is great, so who cares what you think?" As someone who sort of, you know, trades in critical analysis, this resistance is fascinating and troubling.
in the end, who knows what the real benefit is, but the ice bucket challenge has little chance of causing harm (unless a trash bucket full of water lands on your head), so why not let it ride?

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 9:58 pm
by VinylGuy
the foo fighters one is the best one.

THE BEST, THE BEST, THE BEST

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 10:07 pm
by LetMeSleep
I kinda hope the douche that rangi posted at least hurt his hand punching that brick. If only he had copped that brick in the head.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:06 pm
by spike
B wrote:
Simple Torture wrote:I find the backlash to the analysis of this phenomenon to be the most interesting thing of all. There have been lots of pieces floating around asking questions like, "How much awareness is actually being raised? What other messages are these videos saying? (About access, about disability, about peer pressure) How has this been distorted from the start?" And whenever I've read something like this, most comments are along the lines of what bodysnatcher described: "It raises money, why ask questions?" "Sounds like someone is afraid to do it!" "$1.5 million is great, so who cares what you think?" As someone who sort of, you know, trades in critical analysis, this resistance is fascinating and troubling.
in the end, who knows what the real benefit is, but the ice bucket challenge has little chance of causing harm (unless a trash bucket full of water lands on your head), so why not let it ride?

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:10 pm
by Lament
Is that Peeps at 0:28?

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:16 pm
by Kaius
The dog bailing with wooden horse in tow was hilarious

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:40 pm
by Jorge
Kaius wrote:The dog bailing with wooden horse in tow was hilarious
Laughed pretty hard at that.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:42 pm
by Jorge
Also Lenny at the 2:00 mark.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:51 pm
by Sgt. Crackpot
B wrote:
Simple Torture wrote:I find the backlash to the analysis of this phenomenon to be the most interesting thing of all. There have been lots of pieces floating around asking questions like, "How much awareness is actually being raised? What other messages are these videos saying? (About access, about disability, about peer pressure) How has this been distorted from the start?" And whenever I've read something like this, most comments are along the lines of what bodysnatcher described: "It raises money, why ask questions?" "Sounds like someone is afraid to do it!" "$1.5 million is great, so who cares what you think?" As someone who sort of, you know, trades in critical analysis, this resistance is fascinating and troubling.
in the end, who knows what the real benefit is, but the ice bucket challenge has little chance of causing harm (unless a trash bucket full of water lands on your head), so why not let it ride?
I wish there was a simple gif to sum this up.

I don't mind seeing these kinds of things, they're usually entertaining in some way, and I completely understand that it's all for a good cause. However, I'll state clearly now (to save the trouble/waste of anyone nominating me) that I won't be taking part. I like charities that raise funds to help research and support sufferers of specific diseases, I'm not against any certain one, and it's both great and sad there are a shitload of them. For some of us though, certain charities have a bigger meaning that all the others. And for reasons some of you know, I dedicate a lot of time fundraising for, and donating to, the Breast Cancer Foundation and a few related Breast Cancer charities that support sufferers/families, all in the name of my sister.

I understand and appreciate what the Ice Bucket challenge is for, and this is certainly a 'novel' way of gaining awareness and funds, and I really feel for the sufferers and the families/friends of sufferers or ALS. While I won't take part, I will watch and laugh at the videos of those of you who do, and I will also respect you all greatly for doing it.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:55 pm
by Rangi Guy
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:
B wrote:
Simple Torture wrote:I find the backlash to the analysis of this phenomenon to be the most interesting thing of all. There have been lots of pieces floating around asking questions like, "How much awareness is actually being raised? What other messages are these videos saying? (About access, about disability, about peer pressure) How has this been distorted from the start?" And whenever I've read something like this, most comments are along the lines of what bodysnatcher described: "It raises money, why ask questions?" "Sounds like someone is afraid to do it!" "$1.5 million is great, so who cares what you think?" As someone who sort of, you know, trades in critical analysis, this resistance is fascinating and troubling.
in the end, who knows what the real benefit is, but the ice bucket challenge has little chance of causing harm (unless a trash bucket full of water lands on your head), so why not let it ride?
I wish there was a simple gif to sum this up.

I don't mind seeing these kinds of things, they're usually entertaining in some way, and I completely understand that it's all for a good cause. However, I'll state clearly now (to save the trouble/waste of anyone nominating me) that I won't be taking part. I like charities that raise funds to help research and support sufferers of specific diseases, I'm not against any certain one, and it's both great and sad there are a shitload of them. For some of us though, certain charities have a bigger meaning that all the others. And for reasons some of you know, I dedicate a lot of time fundraising for, and donating to, the Breast Cancer Foundation and a few related Breast Cancer charities that support sufferers/families, all in the name of my sister.

I understand and appreciate what the Ice Bucket challenge is for, and this is certainly a 'novel' way of gaining awareness and funds, and I really feel for the sufferers and the families/friends of sufferers or ALS. While I won't take part, I will watch and laugh at the videos of those of you who do, and I will also respect you all greatly for doing it.
You can chose which charity to give money too. Don't puss out Sarge

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:57 pm
by Jorge
Sarge why do you hate people with atrophied muscles

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:57 pm
by Jorge
Sarge answer me

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:58 pm
by Jorge
I see.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Tue August 19, 2014 11:58 pm
by Jorge
Your silence speaks volumes.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Wed August 20, 2014 12:00 am
by Sgt. Crackpot
Have you had too much sugar today, Jorge?

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Wed August 20, 2014 12:01 am
by Jorge
Yes... sugar

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Wed August 20, 2014 12:02 am
by Sgt. Crackpot
Image

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Wed August 20, 2014 12:12 am
by Kaius
Well done, chap.

Re: Vedder Ice Bucket Challenge ALS

Posted: Wed August 20, 2014 12:13 am
by B
spike wrote:
B wrote:
Simple Torture wrote:I find the backlash to the analysis of this phenomenon to be the most interesting thing of all. There have been lots of pieces floating around asking questions like, "How much awareness is actually being raised? What other messages are these videos saying? (About access, about disability, about peer pressure) How has this been distorted from the start?" And whenever I've read something like this, most comments are along the lines of what bodysnatcher described: "It raises money, why ask questions?" "Sounds like someone is afraid to do it!" "$1.5 million is great, so who cares what you think?" As someone who sort of, you know, trades in critical analysis, this resistance is fascinating and troubling.
in the end, who knows what the real benefit is, but the ice bucket challenge has little chance of causing harm (unless a trash bucket full of water lands on your head), so why not let it ride?
That first one's a win, baby! :lol: