Page 8 of 11

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 12:49 pm
by stip
EJ wrote:Heard a first timer on the way out:
"Does he always talk that much between songs? All the politics..."
If I remember correctly there wasn't that many instances of talking, but the ones there were were particularly rambly.


Thank god we got hide your love away instead of No More

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 12:55 pm
by spike
stip wrote:Thank god we got hide your love away instead of No More
dodged that bullet

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:03 pm
by Bi_3
spike wrote:
stip wrote:Thank god we got hide your love away instead of No More
dodged that bullet
It's a little early in the morning for this level of dark humor, but I gotta give it to you on that post. 7/10.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:05 pm
by dprival78
love the breath > SOLAT combo. bit of a call back to the second msg show in 98.. "same record, different track"

and being at the last few shows reminded me that there's a lot more to a show than just a setlist. it's cliche to say, i know, but the energy in the building the last couple of nights was tremendous. had a great time.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:16 pm
by Captain Termite
spike wrote:is six cover songs the new record?
I think they did 7 covers in Boston in aught-four

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:34 pm
by spike
Bi_3 wrote:
spike wrote:
stip wrote:Thank god we got hide your love away instead of No More
dodged that bullet
It's a little early in the morning for this level of dark humor, but I gotta give it to you on that post. 7/10.
you're surprisingly alert for the morning after a PJ show :thumbsup:

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:36 pm
by stip
I'm at the point after 25 years that I don't really consider Last Kiss, Sonic Reducer, or Hide Your Love Away covers. Honestly I don't think I'd throw Baba or RITFW into that category either. They are staples that pearl jam happened not to write, but they feel just as organic as hearing Once or Nothingman or In hiding.

Surrender and Driven to Tears were covers in the sense I usually think of the word (at least in terms of the designation having significance in the context of the show)

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:37 pm
by EJ
stip wrote:
EJ wrote:Heard a first timer on the way out:
"Does he always talk that much between songs? All the politics..."
If I remember correctly there wasn't that many instances of talking, but the ones there were were particularly rambly.
Agreed. Too bad this first timer didn't see Ed in 2003.

Anyway, despite this not being my favorite set, the energy of the band and the audience made the show a really good time. They sounded so much better than 2013 as well.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:41 pm
by Moshimistic
MFC172 captured some of the MSG II magic in these clips:

"Surrender" (feat. Rick Nielsen and Tom Petersson of Cheap Trick)
[YouTube]nnoGOnmjNFg[/YouTube]

"Driven To Tears" (feat. Sting)
[YouTube]DUOk878_u20[/YouTube]

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:41 pm
by evenslow
stip wrote:I'm at the point after 25 years that I don't really consider Last Kiss, Sonic Reducer, or Hide Your Love Away covers. Honestly I don't think I'd throw Baba or RITFW into that category either. They are staples that pearl jam happened not to write, but they feel just as organic as hearing Once or Nothingman or In hiding.

Surrender and Driven to Tears were covers in the sense I usually think of the word (at least in terms of the designation having significance in the context of the show)
Agreed. All the cover talk is overblown. They've made most of those covers their own through the years.

But I'd certainly like them to come up with a few new cover "staples" to add to the mix. Maybe "Jesus is Just Alright With Me" is next.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:45 pm
by evenslow
Moshimistic wrote:MFC172 captured some of the MSG II magic in these clips:

"Surrender" (feat. Rick Nielsen and Tom Petersson of Cheap Trick)


"Driven To Tears" (feat. Sting)
FTFY

Nice clips - love that Sting just walked out unannounced.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:47 pm
by Captain Termite
Being a cover song and being a staple aren't mutually exclusive.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 1:49 pm
by Strat
I had an absolute blast. The band sounds great.

Too much ten for me over the past two shows. One thought I had was "if the hand doesn't respect their newer material, then why should I?"

The encores were fantastic. Really a couple of the better latter day shows I've seen. Being in the building is really special but I just wish they would play some of their better material. Surprised they relied so heavily on ten and vs over two nights in NYC.

Waved at Stip! He seemed to be enjoying himself.

They could have left after surrender and I would have felt satisfied. They really were on fire

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:05 pm
by spike

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:08 pm
by E.H. Ruddock
Seems like it took that person too long to recognize they were playing Breath. It is their 150th show, they should have known sooner.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:14 pm
by BDB
150th show? really?

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:16 pm
by Bi_3
BDB wrote:150th show? really?
You don't recognize that person from every single shot of the rail since GA started?

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:24 pm
by wease
evenslow wrote:
stip wrote:I'm at the point after 25 years that I don't really consider Last Kiss, Sonic Reducer, or Hide Your Love Away covers. Honestly I don't think I'd throw Baba or RITFW into that category either. They are staples that pearl jam happened not to write, but they feel just as organic as hearing Once or Nothingman or In hiding.

Surrender and Driven to Tears were covers in the sense I usually think of the word (at least in terms of the designation having significance in the context of the show)
Agreed. All the cover talk is overblown. They've made most of those covers their own through the years.

But I'd certainly like them to come up with a few new cover "staples" to add to the mix. Maybe "Jesus is Just Alright With Me" is next.
They could never pull off the harmonies required to make that one super-cool.

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:24 pm
by mikejasond
Crazy thing is Im reading the fanviews on the pearljam.com forums and people seem disappointed stating night 1 is better, while people here seem satisfied. Whats going on? O__O

Re: 2016-05-02: New York, New York

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 2:25 pm
by wease
I didn't realize Ed played guitar on Driven to Tears.