Red Mosquito

durden
phil

Man this is gona be an interesting final matchup

and with that, voting is closed. ill have the final count up in a minute then we will start the next round

durdencommatyler - 14
darth vedder - 7

philpritchard - 14
farmer john - 7

Voting will end on Friday at around 10am

Finals

durdencommatyler

1. Nothing As It Seems
2. No Way
3. Red Mosquito
4. Cropduster
5. Evacuation
6. Amongst the Waves
7. Sunburn
8. Army Reserve
9. Immortality
10. Around the Bend

vs

philpritchard

1. Long Road
2. You Are
3. Marker In The Sand
4. Undone
5. Johnny Guitar
6. I Got Shit
7. Got Some
8. Lukin
9. Crazy Mary
10. Oceans

joey

Tough match up and congrats to the finalist!

Both teams have songs I love and songs I'm not so wild about.

d,t has 4 songs I'm not crazy about, which are: Cropduster, Evacuation, Sunburn, and ATW.

philpritchard has Lukin and Crazy Mary, both songs I tend to skip / not listen to.

d,t, has NAIS, No Way, Immortality, RM, and Around The Bend, all personal favorites of mine.

phil has Long Road, Marker, I Got Shit, Got Some, and Oceans, all songs I really love as well.

Shit, I have no idea who to vote for right now...phil to me has a more rounded team, but the highs on d,t's team are some of my favorites, and songs I like better than the highs on phil's team.

Oddly enough, I've never been as high on d,t's team as everyone else seems to be. There are no weak teams in this thing, but I didn't think his team stood out as being that much better than the average. He doesn't have what I would consider any weak spots, though, and Immortality is the best song on either of our lists.

I pick PhilPritchard. That guy picked a hell of a team.

D,T

Good matchup.

I really dislike ATW. But, there's just too many heavy hitters surrounding it to let that be the downfall of the set. D,T by a hair.

philpritchard.

philpritchard

although if DcT wins I can console myself by saying that I would have beaten every other team and lost in the 1st round to the champion

Time for me to go back on re-listen one more time... just too close to call at this point

My pick goes to Durden!

philpritchard

close, but i'm going with durdencommatyler

D,T
Not very close.

I'm actually gonna listen to these ones before I vote.

D,T

I can convince myself I tied for second...

d,t

I probably could have gone either way on this. Both mixes are loaded with personal faves (No Way, Cropduster, Evacuation, Army Reserve, You Are, Undone, Johnny Guitar). But in the end, although Phil's 1 thru 7 is just killer stuff, the Lukin-Crazy Mary sequence just derails it for me. D,t's mix ends much stronger... and that makes enough of a difference. durdencommatyler by a hair...