Red Mosquito

Lounge Lizard wrote:

harmless wrote:I'm just a tiny bit depressed that 'Sirens' will never be as good as Kings of Leon's 'Comeback Story'. I'm not sure anything will be now.

Don't be silly

gardenparty wrote:kind of a garbage review yet he makes me even more excited to hear Pendulum.

IlluminEddie wrote:

Release_Me wrote:

blueviper wrote:

IlluminEddie wrote:

evenslow wrote:First off, I think Ed is hot fire here. I like him when he sounds most engaged, and in that respect these songs recall his performances on Yield and Into the Wild. He obviously doesn't have the voice from '93 anymore, but his approach to these 4 songs is just right in my book. He doesn't get screamy either, which is a plus.

Do you honestly think Ed's vocal delivery is good in Swallowed Whole? Particularly, the chorus?

"Whisper songs inside the Wiiaaiianndd... Breathing in forgiiiaaaiiveneeeaass... Liaaiiaaaf's vibrationnnnss with no end... hear the planet hummaiaiaaianing"

It's not any worse then R&B singers doing atrocious runs in their songs.

and Christina Aguilera mutilating "This Christmas"

Ed's always taken liberty with his delivery and phrasing. Jeremy spoke in class today was made to sound something like 'Jeraamy spokane clahass t-dayyy'. Yellow Ledbetter needs no introduction either. He's always had a tendency to emphasise certain vowels or syllables or change words to fit the melodies. You may or may not like the way he pronounces words but to say this has crept in now is factually incorrect. This has been one of his unique attributes from day one.

You're right - he has. But, that's not what I'm saying. That sounded good. This does not. I'm not capable of actually typing out why what he does today is completely different from what he did in Jeremy or even Yellow Ledbetter. But, they are different.

VinylGuy wrote:i have the feeling everyone wants to pick a fight with IluminEddie.

cutuphalfdead wrote:Kings of Leon sucks.

Lounge Lizard wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Kings of Leon sucks.

Yep

cutuphalfdead wrote:Kings of Leon sucks. I can't wait for the new Arcade Fire.

jtr101 wrote:

Lounge Lizard wrote:

cutuphalfdead wrote:Kings of Leon sucks.

Yep

Nope.... this sucks....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jofNR_WkoCE

VinylGuy wrote:i have the feeling everyone wants to pick a fight with IluminEddie.

IlluminEddie wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:i have the feeling everyone wants to pick a fight with IluminEddie.

First rule of RM club: shun people who think critically and state their opinions. I'm OK with this. Provides a bit of life 'round these parts.

I just think Ed's often a hypocrite. Most fanboys don't. My viewpoint is a minority in a PJ fan club setting. And that's understandable.

harmless wrote:To be honest I fully admit that I might be missing what others are saying about these songs being average or bland, because rhythm section is what I'm most interested in, then lyrics, then everything else. Other people seem to leap on the guitars first. For most people I guess it's what goes on in the "middle" that makes a song. For me it's the bass/drums and then voice/lyrics.

McParadigm wrote:

harmless wrote:To be honest I fully admit that I might be missing what others are saying about these songs being average or bland, because rhythm section is what I'm most interested in, then lyrics, then everything else. Other people seem to leap on the guitars first. For most people I guess it's what goes on in the "middle" that makes a song. For me it's the bass/drums and then voice/lyrics.

You once made a comment in the Other Bands section about a record...something like "that piece of crap is the only album by a band I like that I have ever called a piece of crap."

Given the nature of most of your comments in that section I've been operating under the assumption that, once you've hitched your ride to a band, you tend to be all in. Very, very, very, very, very rarely do you express displeasure at a new release by an artist you already like.