PoP-pUnK ToUrNaMeNt!!!: Come Out and Play WINS.

[PHATJ]

Goodbye Teenage Dirtbag, you deserved better.

[Jorge]

It lost by just one vote, so that's nice.

[tragabigzanda]

[Jorge]

I think it is likely that we get a "Come Out and Play" vs. "The Middle" final, with "Come Out and Play" winning

[The Argonaut]

Come Out and Play vs When I Come Around, though I'm not sure who wins. I'll be voting Smash, as promised

[tragabigzanda]

[wease]

Come Out and Play isn’t making it out of this round.

[Jorge]

Advancing:
The Offspring- "Come Out and Play"
Jimmy Eat World- "The Middle"
Green Day- "When I Come Around"
No Doubt- "Spiderwebs"

Eliminated:
Green Day- "Basket Case"
The Offspring- "Gone Away"
Jimmy Eat World- "Sweetness"
The Offspring- "Self Esteem"

- Wease doesn't know anything
- I am pleasantly surprised by "Spiderwebs"' success in this tourney. I would not have expected it to do so well.

We are down to the semifinals. Go make your voices heard

[The Argonaut]

COAP v BC quarterfinal yo-yoed back and forth a lot

[LoathedVermin72]

The two best songs are gone

[tragabigzanda]

Top 10 maybe?
Hello Morning
Close Captioned
The Kill
Place/Position
Do You Like Me?
Latest Disgrace
Recap Modotti
Nightshop
Break
Life & Limb

I'd maybe bump Life & Limb for Epic Problem

[PHATJ]

Basket Case should have won. No Doubt is awful. RM is retarded.

[evenslow]

Hi I didn't participate in this until the last round. Please disregard my thoughts. But my ego is itching and this is message board after all.

1. You guys should not have voted for the Offspring so much. They are bad.

2. Did I miss (I'm sure I did) Third Eye Blind somehow not making it to the finals with any number of awesome pop-punk songs that are way fucking better than the Offspring?

3. You all should have gotten more into the spirit of this thing and voted way more heavily for 311 and/or Sublime.

4. Vote for Spiderwebs.

I'm done now.

[LoathedVermin72]

Third Eye Blind is not pop punk.

There were no 311 songs included.

[evenslow]

Third Eye Blind is not pop punk.

There were no 311 songs included.

What?

What?

[LoathedVermin72]

[evenslow]

In the real world, Third Eye Blind is not pop-punk, but by my cursory view of this message board's definition of the pop-punk tourney, they could have easily sidled in to competition.

Same thing goes (even moreso) for 311. If you include Sublime, 311 follows.

Let's do this whole thing over again.

New Finals: Semi-Charmed Life vs. All Mixed Up (90s songs that make you like you're on a lazy river and also have the extreme benefit of not being the Offspring).

[chewm]

The two best songs are gone

Yes the Letters to Cleo cover of "I Want You to Want Me" and "That's What You Get" left a while ago.

[Jorge]

I really don't think of Third Eye Blind or 311 as anything resembling ska or pop punk, but I only know 2 or 3 songs by each of those bands

[evenslow]

I’m just being the annoying after the fact guy. I would have made a Gregory Peck case if we could turn back time.