Song of the Moment: Let the Records Play

[Jorge]

and also, like, guts and stuff

[harmless]

The lyrics to this are bizarre. Ed actually paints a relatively evocative (and kind of dark) picture in the verses of the guy who may be avoiding the world with his whiskey bottle and turntable, but then turns around in the chorus and says, "hey, this guy's on the right track."

That's what I hear, 'just fuck it' maybe its a song about denial or maybe that how he really feels.

And swallowed whole is a dude putting off suicide another day cause the earth is coolz, what would have happened if the weather was shitty and a bird crapped on his head eh?

Eds happy lyrics almost always have something dark in them too, its a shame he keeps using vocal melodys that were shit out of the suns ass and landed directly on the set of bear in the big blue house.

To me, when it works, that contrast makes the songs more interesting.

I agree.

I also, after 20 years, just enjoy having pearl jam melodies it is fun to sing along to. It isn't all i want, but it is part of the story

I think the key of all this discussion is that is you want danceable or fun there's plenty of music out there that fits the bill, you can get any 90s eurodance compilation and that will do the trick. Maybe at some point some of us went to PJ because we found in this band something we couldn't find elsewhere, but if from now on it's just going to be Shania Twain or One Direction but with Ed singing there's no point.

I wouldn't say there's no point at all. Pearl Jam doing The Who was always better than The Who doing The Who. And it was the same with all of their influences, for me. I don't like a bunch of bands they love, but filtered through them, it's great. PJ don't write big gay dance anthems, so I have to go elsewhere for that. And I occasionally like a One Direction song, but they're not sung by Eddie Vedder and played by this band, so they lack something. These songs are more comparable to Counting Crows than One Direction anyway, and still, PJ doing Counting Crows still has those PJ touches that makes it different.

[Jorge]

PJ don't write big gay dance anthems

And isn't that a total shame?

[harmless]

and also, like, guts and stuff

And a skeleton.

[harmless]

PJ don't write big gay dance anthems

And isn't that a total shame?

It's what I have Jessie J, Misha B and David Guetta ft. Sia for.

[harmless]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

[Lounge Lizard]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

[harmless]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

Me neither. I like two songs by The Who -- Baba O'Riley and My Generation -- that's it. 'Who Are You?' is an absolute abomination.

[Lounge Lizard]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

Me neither. I like two songs by The Who -- Baba O'Riley and My Generation -- that's it. 'Who Are You?' is an absolute abomination.

and our guys' version of Love Rein O'er Me kicks the living shit out of the original.

[stip]

The lyrics to this are bizarre. Ed actually paints a relatively evocative (and kind of dark) picture in the verses of the guy who may be avoiding the world with his whiskey bottle and turntable, but then turns around in the chorus and says, "hey, this guy's on the right track."

That's what I hear, 'just fuck it' maybe its a song about denial or maybe that how he really feels.

And swallowed whole is a dude putting off suicide another day cause the earth is coolz, what would have happened if the weather was shitty and a bird crapped on his head eh?

Eds happy lyrics almost always have something dark in them too, its a shame he keeps using vocal melodys that were shit out of the suns ass and landed directly on the set of bear in the big blue house.

To me, when it works, that contrast makes the songs more interesting.

I agree.

I also, after 20 years, just enjoy having pearl jam melodies it is fun to sing along to. It isn't all i want, but it is part of the story

I think the key of all this discussion is that is you want danceable or fun there's plenty of music out there that fits the bill, you can get any 90s eurodance compilation and that will do the trick. Maybe at some point some of us went to PJ because we found in this band something we couldn't find elsewhere, but if from now on it's just going to be Shania Twain or One Direction but with Ed singing there's no point.

Sure, and then you won't care anymore. But I like (so far) the way this is filtered through pearl jam, as per that punk discussion when mym was released (play's why not just listen to a punk band arguement)

Also, when did these songs now become boy band/euro dance tracks?

[stip]

PJ don't write big gay dance anthems

And isn't that a total shame?

We haven't heard pendulum yet!

[Heathen]

The lyrics to this are bizarre. Ed actually paints a relatively evocative (and kind of dark) picture in the verses of the guy who may be avoiding the world with his whiskey bottle and turntable, but then turns around in the chorus and says, "hey, this guy's on the right track."

That's what I hear, 'just fuck it' maybe its a song about denial or maybe that how he really feels.

And swallowed whole is a dude putting off suicide another day cause the earth is coolz, what would have happened if the weather was shitty and a bird crapped on his head eh?

Eds happy lyrics almost always have something dark in them too, its a shame he keeps using vocal melodys that were shit out of the suns ass and landed directly on the set of bear in the big blue house.

To me, when it works, that contrast makes the songs more interesting.

I agree.

I also, after 20 years, just enjoy having pearl jam melodies it is fun to sing along to. It isn't all i want, but it is part of the story

I think the key of all this discussion is that is you want danceable or fun there's plenty of music out there that fits the bill, you can get any 90s eurodance compilation and that will do the trick. Maybe at some point some of us went to PJ because we found in this band something we couldn't find elsewhere, but if from now on it's just going to be Shania Twain or One Direction but with Ed singing there's no point.

Sure, and then you won't care anymore. But I like (so far) the way this is filtered through pearl jam, as per that punk discussion when mym was released (play's why not just listen to a punk band arguement)

Also, when did these songs now become boy band/euro dance tracks?

They're not boy band/eurodance but if danceable/fun has become the main point then there are plenty of that to be found in these genres.

[Heathen]

PJ don't write big gay dance anthems

And isn't that a total shame?

We haven't heard pendulum yet!

so it's an nod to this band?

[stip]

I don't think it is the main point, but it adds a nice element, and is playing off against other, darker moments and are being sung by my favorite singer

[harmless]

The lyrics to this are bizarre. Ed actually paints a relatively evocative (and kind of dark) picture in the verses of the guy who may be avoiding the world with his whiskey bottle and turntable, but then turns around in the chorus and says, "hey, this guy's on the right track."

That's what I hear, 'just fuck it' maybe its a song about denial or maybe that how he really feels.

And swallowed whole is a dude putting off suicide another day cause the earth is coolz, what would have happened if the weather was shitty and a bird crapped on his head eh?

Eds happy lyrics almost always have something dark in them too, its a shame he keeps using vocal melodys that were shit out of the suns ass and landed directly on the set of bear in the big blue house.

To me, when it works, that contrast makes the songs more interesting.

I agree.

I also, after 20 years, just enjoy having pearl jam melodies it is fun to sing along to. It isn't all i want, but it is part of the story

I think the key of all this discussion is that is you want danceable or fun there's plenty of music out there that fits the bill, you can get any 90s eurodance compilation and that will do the trick. Maybe at some point some of us went to PJ because we found in this band something we couldn't find elsewhere, but if from now on it's just going to be Shania Twain or One Direction but with Ed singing there's no point.

Sure, and then you won't care anymore. But I like (so far) the way this is filtered through pearl jam, as per that punk discussion when mym was released (play's why not just listen to a punk band arguement)

Also, when did these songs now become boy band/euro dance tracks?

They're not boy band/eurodance but if danceable/fun has become the main point then there are plenty of that to be found in these genres.

It's not the main point. The main point is that it sounds like Pearl Jam, and I really like the sound of Pearl Jam.

[harmless]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

Me neither. I like two songs by The Who -- Baba O'Riley and My Generation -- that's it. 'Who Are You?' is an absolute abomination.

and our guys' version of Love Rein O'er Me kicks the living shit out of the original.

Yes, as does their cover of Baba O'Riley.

[Jorge]

Hey guys




no.

[Lounge Lizard]

Yeees

[stip]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

Me neither. I like two songs by The Who -- Baba O'Riley and My Generation -- that's it. 'Who Are You?' is an absolute abomination.

and our guys' version of Love Rein O'er Me kicks the living shit out of the original.

Yes, as does their cover of Baba O'Riley.

Yup

[Birds in Hell]

PJ were always a filter for their influences. Ed is only writing music because he wants everyone to love The Who.

Out of all the influences they could have chosen, they picked The Who.

I don't mean to sound like a dick, but out of the famous British bunch The Who have never tickled my fancy.

It was Ed's choice, right?

Me neither. I like two songs by The Who -- Baba O'Riley and My Generation -- that's it. 'Who Are You?' is an absolute abomination.

and our guys' version of Love Rein O'er Me kicks the living shit out of the original.

Yes, as does their cover of Baba O'Riley.

Stop the internet, I want to get off.