Red Mosquito

harmless wrote:I *like* aspects of every song on this album except for Supersonic. The lyrics on that one ruin it, because they're not just bad in places, the entire concept and theme of the song is terrible. Every other song is passable and enjoyable, just hampered by various things. No song goes from good to great, because something lets it down. The only song I think they got nearly 100% right is Johnny Guitar.

The bridge in Supersonic is the only enjoyable thing on Backspacer......except maybe Got Some.

verb_to_trust wrote:

harmless wrote:I *like* aspects of every song on this album except for Supersonic. The lyrics on that one ruin it, because they're not just bad in places, the entire concept and theme of the song is terrible. Every other song is passable and enjoyable, just hampered by various things. No song goes from good to great, because something lets it down. The only song I think they got nearly 100% right is Johnny Guitar.

The bridge in Supersonic is the only enjoyable thing on Backspacer......except maybe Got Some.

While I won't take away from your dislike of Backspacer, that's heaping far too much praise on the Supersonic bridge. It's essentially a generic funk rock riff with a generic guitar solo over generic half-step drumming.

Rank....Song Name.......Letter Grade

01. Johnny Guitar...............B+
02. Amongst the Waves...........B
03. Force of Nature.............B
04. The End.....................C+
05. Speed of Sound..............C
06. Got Some....................C-
07. The Fixer...................C-
08. Unthought Known.............D+
09. Just Breathe................D
10. Supersonic..................D-
11. Gonna See My Friend.........F

by way of comparison, what are some other songs not on backspacer you would give those grades to?

PHATJ wrote:Rank....Song Name.......Letter Grade

01. Johnny Guitar...............B+
02. Amongst the Waves...........B
03. Force of Nature.............B
04. The End.....................C+
05. Speed of Sound..............C
06. Got Some....................C-
07. The Fixer...................C-
08. Unthought Known.............D+
09. Just Breathe................D
10. Supersonic..................D-
11. Gonna See My Friend.........F

For me it's :

Johnny Guitar...............D
Amongst the Waves...........F
Force of Nature.............B
The End.....................D
Speed of Sound..............D
Got Some...................B
The Fixer...................F
Unthought Known............B
Just Breathe................D
Supersonic..................F
Gonna See My Friend.........F

01. Johnny Guitar...............A
02. Amongst the Waves...........B
03. Force of Nature.............B
04. The End.....................B
05. Speed of Sound..............C+(demo B)
06. Got Some....................B
07. The Fixer...................C+
08. Unthought Known.............D+
09. Just Breathe................A-
10. Supersonic..................F
11. Gonna See My Friend.........C

01. Johnny Guitar...............B
02. Got Some....................C+
03. Just Breathe................C+
04. Gonna See My Friend.........C
05. The End.....................C
06. Force of Nature.............C-
07. Unthought Known.............D+
08. Supersonic..................D-
09. Speed of Sound..............F
10. Amongst the Waves...........F
11. The Fixer...................F

The first 4 tracks are very good, and new. They have this fresh and unique sound...PJ never had songs like those 4.
JB is good, ATW is ok, UK is ok...Supersonic is a b side. A very lazy one.
SOS...i just love that one...FON..its weird, its a good song that i dont need to hear it...and The End is good too.

supersonic is the only dud on this record for me. No song gets it all 100% right (Force of Nature comes closest) but only the presence of supersonic and the absence of any 5 star songs keeps this from dethroning vs. in the number 3 spot. Such an enjoyable listen from start to finish

Oh stip, it's so hard for me not to yell at you right now for having different tastes than me.

i was just equally dismissive to your rhapsody in blue comment as you were to my alive comment, so that may inspire you.

Your rate my professor page was right.

Force of nature is a great song. They should play it more often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to rest and dust off this beauty.

Force of Nature is a mediocre song. They should play it less often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to better use and have a funeral for this fart noise.

VinylGuy wrote:Force of nature is a great song. They should play it more often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to rest and dust off this beauty.

My 2nd and third favorites behind Force of Nature Johnny Guitar (oops). I think they all stink live.

Honestly, Amongst the Waves grabbed hold of me on first listen and has never let me go. I actually really dig that song. A lot. A lot lot.

durdencommatyler wrote:Force of Nature is a mediocre song. They should play it less often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to better use and have a funeral for this fart noise.

I like the melody, those guitars,,,the bass lines too. And Ed´s delivery is pretty good too.

PLAY FORCE OF NATURE YOU PUSSIES

VinylGuy wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:Force of Nature is a mediocre song. They should play it less often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to better use and have a funeral for this fart noise.

I like the melody, those guitars,,,the bass lines too. And Ed´s delivery is pretty good too.

PLAY FORCE OF NATURE YOU PUSSIES

It's never done much for me. It sounds like a Garth Brooks B-Side. Not that that's a terrible thing. I happen to like GB quite a bit. But there's nothing dynamic or particularly grabby about FoN to these old ears. But I'm fine no matter what they play live. If this is something folks are dying to hear, then I hope they play if more for those folks.

durdencommatyler wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:Force of Nature is a mediocre song. They should play it less often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to better use and have a funeral for this fart noise.

I like the melody, those guitars,,,the bass lines too. And Ed´s delivery is pretty good too.

PLAY FORCE OF NATURE YOU PUSSIES

It's never done much for me. It sounds like a Garth Brooks B-Side. Not that that's a terrible thing. I happen to like GB quite a bit. But there's nothing dynamic or particularly grabby about FoN to these old ears. But I'm fine no matter what they play live. If this is something folks are dying to hear, then I hope they play if more for those folks.

FON and SOS are two songs they should play often. And put to rest ATW and UK...and got some.

durdencommatyler wrote:

VinylGuy wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:Force of Nature is a mediocre song. They should play it less often...put Got Some or Amongst the waves to better use and have a funeral for this fart noise.

I like the melody, those guitars,,,the bass lines too. And Ed´s delivery is pretty good too.

PLAY FORCE OF NATURE YOU PUSSIES

It's never done much for me. It sounds like a Garth Brooks B-Side. Not that that's a terrible thing. I happen to like GB quite a bit. But there's nothing dynamic or particularly grabby about FoN to these old ears. But I'm fine no matter what they play live. If this is something folks are dying to hear, then I hope they play if more for those folks.

The music is on the mediocre side but i think the lyrics are outstanding.