Red Mosquito

simple schoolboy wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote: clear language exactly what is happening at these centers to young people in desperate need of help.

No it doesn't. It's a vague overgeneralization.

There are literally screenshots of emails between the clinic and parents. What more do you want?

Ah fair, I see there's more than you posted. Definitely, this field is failing at communicating the risks and benefits of treatment. We need to improve that process.

But you can improve that process without taking away treatment options.

Treatment options absolutely should be taken away if informed consent is not possible. It's not clear that informed consent is a priority for these providers.

Not possible and not being done are too different things. This may have been in the article, I admit to not reading it all, but if the above clinic won't do it, you're right, they shouldn't give the treatment. But they should just do it. Teaching people about their risks and benefits and verifying that they understand isn't hard.

B wrote:

simple schoolboy wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote: clear language exactly what is happening at these centers to young people in desperate need of help.

No it doesn't. It's a vague overgeneralization.

There are literally screenshots of emails between the clinic and parents. What more do you want?

Ah fair, I see there's more than you posted. Definitely, this field is failing at communicating the risks and benefits of treatment. We need to improve that process.

But you can improve that process without taking away treatment options.

Treatment options absolutely should be taken away if informed consent is not possible. It's not clear that informed consent is a priority for these providers.

Not possible and not being done are too different things. This may have been in the article, I admit to not reading it all, but if the above clinic won't do it, you're right, they shouldn't give the treatment. But they should just do it. Teaching people about their risks and benefits and verifying that they understand isn't hard.

Just like with the COVID vaccine.

Snark aside, we are talking about the minds of children. They are designed by evolutionary forces to rapidly shift and adapt during adolescence. All mammals have this in common. Even the most thorough and accurate diagnosis could become inaccurate in a month through no wrongdoing on anyone's part. The children could literally just change. That's what kids do. And that's the core problem here and why it's so dangerous to medically treat kids versus psychiatrists and focused mental health support.

Bi_3 wrote:

B wrote:

simple schoolboy wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote: clear language exactly what is happening at these centers to young people in desperate need of help.

No it doesn't. It's a vague overgeneralization.

There are literally screenshots of emails between the clinic and parents. What more do you want?

Ah fair, I see there's more than you posted. Definitely, this field is failing at communicating the risks and benefits of treatment. We need to improve that process.

But you can improve that process without taking away treatment options.

Treatment options absolutely should be taken away if informed consent is not possible. It's not clear that informed consent is a priority for these providers.

Not possible and not being done are too different things. This may have been in the article, I admit to not reading it all, but if the above clinic won't do it, you're right, they shouldn't give the treatment. But they should just do it. Teaching people about their risks and benefits and verifying that they understand isn't hard.

Just like with the COVID vaccine.

Did you not sign giant EUA fact sheets with every dose? Those were required by law.

Bi_3 wrote:Snark aside, we are talking about the minds of children. They are designed by evolutionary forces to rapidly shift and adapt during adolescence. All mammals have this in common. Even the most thorough and accurate diagnosis could become inaccurate in a month through no wrongdoing on anyone's part. The children could literally just change. That's what kids do. And that's the core problem here and why it's so dangerous to medically treat kids versus psychiatrists and focused mental health support.

This is a pretty big oversimplified stereotype of kids. How many trans kids have you even met?

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:Snark aside, we are talking about the minds of children. They are designed by evolutionary forces to rapidly shift and adapt during adolescence. All mammals have this in common. Even the most thorough and accurate diagnosis could become inaccurate in a month through no wrongdoing on anyone's part. The children could literally just change. That's what kids do. And that's the core problem here and why it's so dangerous to medically treat kids versus psychiatrists and focused mental health support.

This is a pretty big oversimplified stereotype of kids. How many trans kids have you even met?

One day my kids loved Elsa/Frozen more than anything. Movies, songs, board games, puzzles, dolls, stuffies … anything and everything Frozen.

Then one day they fucking hate it. All of it. I can’t even play the Panic! or Weezer covers of the songs. Pure hate.

and here comes bammer

knee tunes wrote:and here comes bammer

I didn't even bother opening the thread until someone else commented.

B wrote:

Bi_3 wrote:Snark aside, we are talking about the minds of children. They are designed by evolutionary forces to rapidly shift and adapt during adolescence. All mammals have this in common. Even the most thorough and accurate diagnosis could become inaccurate in a month through no wrongdoing on anyone's part. The children could literally just change. That's what kids do. And that's the core problem here and why it's so dangerous to medically treat kids versus psychiatrists and focused mental health support.

This is a pretty big oversimplified stereotype of kids. How many trans kids have you even met?

Rapid changes in physical self, mental development, and self-identity are common in adolescence amoung nearly all mammals. It's a key part of how evolution powers changes in population level groups. Human adolescents have it even harder as they have thousands of competing socially and culturally constructed roles to choose from. It is and has always been perfectly natural for adolescents to move between them, with some being simple like peer groups (e.g. a school club) and some being more complex like sexuality. You might even say that sense of self is 'fluid'. The human mind and the body have evolved to demand this process so they can grow and reach their steady-state. Interrupting this carries incredible risk and those who support it will have to reconcile that they are going to cause irreversible damage to a large number of children who were lost in the middle of this maze in order to help those who would benefit... and they are going to have to accept they have no way of knowing which is which until it's too late.


And that's before we get into what for-profit medicine is going to do here

Bi_3 wrote:They are designed by evolutionary forces

Bi_3 wrote:All mammals have this in common

Bi_3 on children and aardvarks

Yeah, that second quote was all the farther I got.

Understandable. Many adults feel threatened by middle school biology

I'm going to hijack my own thread for discussions about anti-drag legislation. Fuck these people.

Glad I’m not in Tennessee. Still not really sure why the fuck anyone cares about this. Not to say I haven’t had my interactions with asshole people. Had a girl at my work rambling something about pedophiles after using the bathroom one day…and I normally blend in as a girl too. Shit’s bananas fam.

What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

Bammer wrote:What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

Bammer I’m curious, what do you see the other side (dems etc) doing that you feel is comparable to what the governor in the video B posted is doing? I take your post to mean you think this kind of stuff is just the usual politics and both sides are doing it.

Bammer wrote:What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

What if I told you that that majority of people, even in Tennessee give no fucks if a drag queen reads a picture book at the library?

B wrote:

Bammer wrote:What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

What if I told you that that majority of people, even in Tennessee give no fucks if a drag queen reads a picture book at the library?

What’s the typical voter turnout % there?

True most people don’t care. Also most people don’t vote so … fire up the ones that vote.

bart wrote:

Bammer wrote:What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

Bammer I’m curious, what do you see the other side (dems etc) doing that you feel is comparable to what the governor in the video B posted is doing? I take your post to mean you think this kind of stuff is just the usual politics and both sides are doing it.

Ever been to Seattle?

Bammer wrote:

bart wrote:

Bammer wrote:What if I told you that politicians push policy catering to their majority base in the sole interest of being re-elected?

Bammer I’m curious, what do you see the other side (dems etc) doing that you feel is comparable to what the governor in the video B posted is doing? I take your post to mean you think this kind of stuff is just the usual politics and both sides are doing it.

Ever been to Seattle?

Ever been to a drag show?