Red Mosquito

I know I think Vs is a fair bit stronger than the last two, and Ten was a huge favorite of mine in the early 90s. So in that context the ratings for the last albums, are a bit high, even if they ended last.

Take the Gigaton scores with a pinch of salt. I need to fully digest that whole album on release, and even these two songs may be rated a little different.

Bammer wrote:BootsToAsses gave Johnny Guitar a 4.

DISQUALIFIED

Oh come on, Johnny Guitar is loads of fun. Goofy as hell but I have a soft spot for it.
It's not even close to being the most offensive thing in the record.

You rated it too low.

Here’s how I think the eras go...

Ten - Vs. - Vitalogy - No Code - Yield

Binaural - Riot Act

S/T - Backspacer - Lightning Bolt

blueviper wrote:Here’s how I think the eras go...

Ten - Vs. - Vitalogy - No Code - Yield

Binaural - Riot Act

S/T - Backspacer - Lightning Bolt

this is probably right.

You gotta keep the Jack Irons era separate.

Farmer John wrote:You gotta keep the Jack Irons era separate.

For shizzle

BootsToAsses wrote:

Bammer wrote:BootsToAsses gave Johnny Guitar a 4.

DISQUALIFIED

Oh come on, Johnny Guitar is loads of fun. Goofy as hell but I have a soft spot for it.
It's not even close to being the most offensive thing in the record.

The only redeeming quality about this song is I saw it live once and got my album trophy from the PJ Stat Tracker app.

The eras (broadly speaking):

Ten, Vs, Vitalogy

No Code, Yield, Binaural, Riot Act

Self Titled, Backspacer, Lighting Bolt

Maybe Gigaton will be the start of a new era.

burl jam wrote:The eras (broadly speaking):

Ten, Vs, Vitalogy

No Code, Yield, Binaural, Riot Act

Self Titled, Backspacer, Lighting Bolt

Maybe Gigaton will be the start of a new era.

If only for the fact that it is nearly a decade between albums

I don't think ST belongs with BS and LB, feels very different to me.

1. The Daves
2. Late Matt Cameron
3. Jack Irons
4. Early Matt Cameron

stip wrote:1. Jimmy Shoaf
2. The Daves
3. Late Matt Cameron
4. Jack Irons
5. Early Matt Cameron

FTFY

I assumed Jimmy Shoaf at number 1 is just an unspoken truth

1. Vitalogy: 4.15
2. Ten: 4.09
3. No Code: 3.84
4. Yield: 3.75
5. Vs: 3.54
6. Binaural: 3.5
7. Riot Act: 3.43
8. Self-Titled: 3.25
9. Backspacer: 3.14
10. Lightning Bolt: 3.04

5* : Black, Rearviewmirror, Elderly Woman, Indifference, Tremor Christ, Corduroy, Hail Hail, In My Tree, Present Tense, Do The Evolution

4.5* : Alive, Release, Nothingman, Better Man, Immortality, Off He Goes, Given to Fly, Insignificance, State of Love & Trust (non-album), Yellow Ledbetter (non-album), I Got Id (non-album)


Ten

Once: 3
Evenflow: 4
Alive: 4.5
Why Go: 3.5
Black: 5 - #1 in the clubhouse
Jeremy: 4
Oceans: 3.5
Porch: 4
Garden: 3
Deep: 3
Release: 4.5

Ten AVG : 4.09

Vs.

Go: 4
Animal: 4
Daughter: 3
Glorified G: 2.5
Dissident: 3
W.M.A.: 3
Blood: 3
Rearviewmirror: 5
Rats: 3
Elderly Woman: 5
Leash: 2
Indifference: 5

Vs. AVG: 3.54

Vitalogy

Last Exit: 4
Spin The Black Circle: 3
Not For You: 4
Tremor Christ: 5
Nothingman: 4.5
Whipping: 3.5
Pry, To: N/A
Corduroy: 5
Bugs: N/A
Satan’s Bed: 3.5
Better Man: 4.5
Aye Davanita: N/A
Immortality: 4.5
Stupid Mop: N/A

Vitalogy AVG: 4.15

No Code

Sometimes: 4
Hail Hail: 5
Who You Are: 3
In My Tree: 5
Smile: 4
Off He Goes: 4.5
Habit: 2.5
Red Mosquito: 4
Lukin: 3.5
Present Tense - 5
Mankind: 3.5
I’m Open: 3
Around The Bend: 3

No Code AVG: 3.84

Yield

Brain of J: 4
Faithful: 4
No Way: 4
Given to Fly: 4.5
Wishlist: 3.5
Pilate: 2.5
Do the Evolution: 5
Red Bar: N/A
MFC: 3
Low Light: 4
In Hiding: 3.5
Push Me, Pull Me: 3
All Those Yesterdays: 4

Yield AVG: 3.75

Binaural

Breakherfall: 3.5
God’s Dice: 3
Evacuation: 2.5
Light Years: 4
Nothing As It Seems: 3.5
Thin Air: 3.5
Insignificance: 4.5
Of the Girl: 3.5
Grievance: 4
Rival: 3.5
Sleight of Hand: 3.5
Soon Forget: 3.5
Parting Ways: 3.5

Binaural AVG: 3.5

Riot Act

Can’t Keep: 3.5
Save You: 4
Love Boat Captain: 4
Cropduster: 3.5
Ghost: 2.5
I Am Mine: 4
Thumbing My Way: 3
You Are: 4
Get Right: 3
Green Disease: 4
Help Help: 4
Bu$hleaguer: 3.5
1/2 Full: 2.5
Arc: 3
All or None: 3

Riot Act AVG: 3.43

Self-Titled:

Life Wasted: 4
World Wide Suicide: 2.5
Comatose: 3.5
Severed Hand: 3.5
Marker in the Sand: 3
Parachutes: 3.5
Unemployable: 2.5
Big Wave: 2.5
Gone: 3
Wasted Reprise: N/A
Army Reserve: 4
Comeback: 3.5
Inside Job: 3.5

Self Titled AVG: 3.25

Backspacer

Gonna See My Friend: 3.5
Got Some: 3
The Fixer: 2.5
Johnny Guitar: 3.5
Just Breathe: 4
Amongst the Waves: 3
Unthought Known: 4
Supersonic : 2
Speed of Sound: 1.5
Force of Nature: 3.5
The End: 4

Backspacer AVG: 3.14

Lightning Bolt

Getaway: 3.5
Mind Your Manners: 4
My Father’s Son: 3.5
Sirens: 4
Lightning Bolt: 3.5
Infallible: 3.5
Pendulum: 3
Swallowed Whole: 2.5
Let the Records Play: 2.5
Sleeping By Myself: 3
Yellow Moon: 2.5
Future Days: 1

Lightning Bolt AVG: 3.04

Gigaton

Superblood Wolfmoon: 3
Dance of the Clairvoyants: 4

stip wrote:I assumed Jimmy Shoaf at number 1 is just an unspoken truth

Who the hell is Jimmy Shoaf?

I'm not much of a ranker, but I'm spending too much goddamn time on this forum lately, so what the hell! Here's my hot take...

Yield
Vs
Binaural
Vitalogy
Riot Act
No Code
Pearl Jam
Backspacer
Ten
Lightning Bolt

Clem Halibut wrote:

stip wrote:I assumed Jimmy Shoaf at number 1 is just an unspoken truth

Who the hell is Jimmy Shoaf?

he got whipped by harrison ford at the beginning of satan's bed

EJ wrote:

Clem Halibut wrote:

stip wrote:I assumed Jimmy Shoaf at number 1 is just an unspoken truth

Who the hell is Jimmy Shoaf?

he got whipped by harrison ford at the beginning of satan's bed

This is a very good post.

dad wrote:

EJ wrote:

Clem Halibut wrote:

stip wrote:I assumed Jimmy Shoaf at number 1 is just an unspoken truth

Who the hell is Jimmy Shoaf?

he got whipped by harrison ford at the beginning of satan's bed

This is a very good post.

Wow. You learn something new everyday
Had no idea he was Harrison Ford's drum tech