gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:36 pm
by Hypnos
The guitars and drums on BW are sexy.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:37 pm
by stip
gardenparty wrote:Comatose - 5*
Get Right - 4*
MYM - 5*
Johnny Guitar -3.5*
Big Wave -2*
Gonna See My Friend - 4*
SBWM. - 3.5*
Supersonic -2*
Hitchhiker - 1.5*
Ole -2 *
CDM. -.5*
some great songs and some real crap!
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:38 pm
by Hypnos
stip wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose - 5*
Get Right - 4*
MYM - 5*
Johnny Guitar -3.5*
Big Wave -2*
Gonna See My Friend - 4*
SBWM. - 3.5*
Supersonic -2*
Hitchhiker - 1.5*
Ole -2 *
CDM. -.5*
some great songs and some real crap!
CDM a 5? Come on!!!!
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:39 pm
by stip
.5
worst song in the catalog
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:40 pm
by Anders
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
They have a lot more than that.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:40 pm
by Hypnos
stip wrote:.5
worst song in the catalog
You scared me.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:40 pm
by DeeDee
stip wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose - 5*
Get Right - 4*
MYM - 5*
some great songs and some real crap!
I'm dying over here.
How many stars should Release, Corduroy, RVM or Immortality have if we compare 'em to these 3 songs? Twelve hundred?
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:41 pm
by DeeDee
stip wrote:.5
worst song in the catalog
Agreed.
But to me is a 0, just like Olé.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:41 pm
by tree_
Ed really loves water
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:43 pm
by Anders
stip wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose - 1.5*
Get Right - 3.5*
MYM - 2.5*
Johnny Guitar - 5*
Big Wave -2.5*
Gonna See My Friend - 2*
SBWM. - 4.5*
Supersonic -2*
Hitchhiker - 3*
Ole -1*
CDM. 1.5*
some great songs and some real crap!
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:43 pm
by DeeDee
Ed WaVedder.
Ok, I'm done.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 8:53 pm
by philpritchard
theplatypus wrote:
philpritchard wrote:He's not cramming too many words/syllables in, he's just forced to put emphasis on the wrong part of "away", which makes it sound awkward. You would have the same awkwardness with "I lost her too soon" because it doesn't fit properly. "She was taken too soon" fits in perfectly, but I don't know that it would actually sound any better. I don't mind the odd bit of awkwardness like this in a fun song.
Ed does that a lot; it's one of my lyrical pet peeves
He does. There are times where I don't mind it - this being one case - but there are plenty that stand out enough that they disrupt the flow of a song.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:03 pm
by Ms Harmless
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
top 75? I've NEVER been that specific about Pearl Jam; I swear some of you have filing systems for this shit
those 3 songs are solid songs in the catalogue, whether they're 75, 63, 49 or 12; the other songs in this list pale in comparison
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:18 pm
by 15showsandcounting
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
top 75? I've NEVER been that specific about Pearl Jam; I swear some of you have filing systems for this shit
those 3 songs are solid songs in the catalogue, whether they're 75, 63, 49 or 12; the other songs in this list pale in comparison
My point was those songs aren’t good, any of em, imo.
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:18 pm
by 15showsandcounting
Anders wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
They have a lot more than that.
125ish?
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:19 pm
by Ms Harmless
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:
gardenparty wrote:Comatose
Get Right
MYM
Johnny Guitar
Big Wave
Gonna See My Friend
SBWM
Supersonic
Hitchhiker
Ole
CDM
That's one long piss break for a concert.
I'm thrilled to say that Get Right, Hitchhiker and SBWM are the best songs on this list
Best of the worst, maybe. Not sure any of 'em deserve a place in their top 75, assuming they have about 100 or so originals.
top 75? I've NEVER been that specific about Pearl Jam; I swear some of you have filing systems for this shit
those 3 songs are solid songs in the catalogue, whether they're 75, 63, 49 or 12; the other songs in this list pale in comparison
My point was those songs aren’t good, any of em, imo.
I know
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:22 pm
by bodysnatcher
So what are we listing today?
Re: Superblood Wolfmoon
Posted: Thu February 20, 2020 9:23 pm
by 15showsandcounting
Ms Harmless wrote:
15showsandcounting wrote:My point was those songs aren’t good, any of em, imo.
