Red Mosquito

stip wrote:The fact that S/T is now finally beginning its reassessment and people are discovering it's actually a solid record that they like is what complicates this. We only use PRAMG pejoratively. But when that phrase first came into existence it was clearly intended to include S/T.

There's definitely an element of this.

I've tried and failed twice now to make this list. Either I don't love these songs much, or I'm too embarrassed to admit the ones I like.

Anyhow, I want a 10 Billion Years official release.

I've made my top choices into a playlist:

1. Gonna See My Friend
2. Got Some
3. My Father's Son
4. Johnny Guitar
5. Life Wasted
6. Infallible
7. Unemployable
8. Swallowed Whole
9. Parachutes
10. Army Reserve
11. Yellow Moon
12. Amongst the Waves
13. Cold Confession

numbers wrote:

Strat wrote:

durdencommatyler wrote:But there's no surf song on Riot Act.

Fuck Riot Act is a depressing album but good gosh darn if i dont absolutely love it

Riot Act is my favorite album.

Severed Hand
Parachutes
Army Reserve
Marker in the Sand
Let it Ride
Force of Nature
Johnny Guitar
Getaway
Sirens
Yellow Moon

Okay... let's take a look at this again...

Here's my S/T ranking:

Spoiler: show

1. Marker
2. Unemployable
3. Parachutes
4. Big Wave
5. Severed Hand
6. Come Back
7. Gone
8. Army Reserve
9. World Wide Suicide
10. Wasted (Reprise)
11. Life Wasted
12. Inside Job
13. Comatose

Here's Backspacer

Spoiler: show

1. Just Breathe
2. Amongst the Waves
3. Speed of Sound
4. Got Some
5. The End
6. Johnny Guitar
7. The Fixer
8. Gonna See My Friend
9. Unthought Known
10. Force of Nature
11. Supesonic

Here's those two albums combined:

Spoiler: show

1. Marker
2. Unemployable
3. Parachutes
4. Big Wave
5. Just Breathe
6. Severed Hand
7. Amongst the Waves
8. Come Back
9. Gone
10. Speed of Sound
11. Army Reserve
12. Got Some
13. World Wide Suicide
14. The End
15. Johnny Guitar
16. The Fixer
17. Gonna See My Friend
18. Wasted (Reprise)
19. Life Wasted
20. Inside Job
21. Unthought Known
22. Force of Nature
23. Supersonic
24. Comatose

Here's Lightning Bolt:

Spoiler: show

1. Infallible
2. Yellow Moon
3. Pendulum
4. Mind Your Manners
5. Sirens
6. My Father's Son
7. Future Days
8. Sleeping By Myself
9. Getaway
10. Let the Records Play
11. Lightning Bolt
12. Swallowed Whole

All together now!

Spoiler: show

1. Infallible
2. Marker
3. Unemployable
4. Parachutes
5. Big Wave
6. Yellow Moon
7. Just Breathe
8. Severed Hand
9. Amongst the Waves
10. Pendulum
11. Mind Your Manners
12. Come Back
13. Gone
14. Speed of Sound
15. Sirens
16. Army Reserve
17. Got Some
18. World Wide Suicide
19. The End
20. My Father's Son
21. Johnny Guitar
22. The Fixer
23. Future Days
24. Sleeping By Myself
25. Gonna See My Friend
26. Wasted (Reprise)
27. Life Wasted
28. Inside Job
29. Getaway
30. Let the Records Play
31. Unthought Known
32. Lightning Bolt
33. Force of Nature
34. Supersonic
35. Swallowed Whole
36. Comatose

So, my top ten without any non-album tracks is:

Spoiler: show

1. Infallible
2. Marker
3. Unemployable
4. Parachutes
5. Big Wave
6. Yellow Moon
7. Just Breathe
8. Severed Hand
9. Amongst the Waves
10. Pendulum

But 10 Billion Years and Ole belong on the list because they are two of my favorite tracks in this time frame. I'm going to leave off Man of the Hour, we'll call that Riot Act era for the sake of argument. So the "final" list looks like:

1. Infallible
2. Marker
3. Unemployable
4. 10 Billion Years
5. Parachutes
6. Big Wave
7. Ole
8. Yellow Moon
9. Just Breathe
10. Severed Hand

joey, your disdain for comatose makes my heart break

I'm sorry friend. I just really do not like it.

I run the marathon to the very last mile!

tragabigzanda wrote:This thread is exhausting.

Welcome to PJ Chat

S/T ranking:

1. Marker In The Sand
2. Unemployable
3. Army Reserve
4. Come Back
5. Parachutes
6. Gone
7. Severed Hand
8. Big Wave
9. Life Wasted
10. Wasted Reprise
11. Comatose
12. Inside Job
13. World Wide Suicide


Backspacer:

1. Amongst the Waves
2. Johnny Guitar
3. Speed of Sound
4. Force of Nature
5. The End
6. Got Some
7. The Fixer
8. Supersonic
9. Unthought Known
10. Just Breathe
11. Gonna See My Friend


Here's those two albums combined:

1. Marker in the Sand
2. Unemployable
3. Amongst the Waves
4. Army Reserve
5. Come Back
6. Parachutes
7. Johnny Guitar
8. Gone
9. Speed of Sound
10. Severed Hand
11. Force of Nature
12. Big Wave
13. Life Wasted
14. The End
15. Got Some
16. The Fixer
17. Wasted Reprise
18. Supersonic
19. Comatose
20. Unthought Known
21. Inside Job
22. Just Breathe
23. World Wide Suicide
24. Gonna See My Friend


Lightning Bolt:

1. Lightning Bolt
2. Pendulum
3. Yellow Moon
4. Infallible
5. Mind Your Manners
6. Sirens
7. My Father's Son
8. Getaway
9. Future Days
10. Let the Records Play
11. Swallowed Whole
12. Sleeping By Myself


All three:

1. Lightning Bolt
2. Pendulum
3. Marker in the Sand
4. Unemployable
5. Amongst The Waves
6. Army Reserve
7. Yellow Moon
8. Infallible
9. Come Back
10. Parachutes
11. Johnny Guitar
12. Gone
13. Speed of Sound
14. Severed Hand
15. Force of Nature
16. Big Wave
17. Life Wasted
18. Mind Your Manners
19. Sirens
20. My Father's Son
----------------------------------------
I like all the songs above this line and would be happy to hear any of them.
I almost always hit skip if any of the following songs come on.
-----------------------------------------
21. Getaway
22. The End
23. Got Some
24. The Fixer
25. Future Days
26. Wasted Reprise
27. Supersonic
28. Comatose
29. Unthought Known
30. Let the Records Play
31. Inside Job
32. Just Breathe
33. Swallowed Whole
34. Sleeping By Myself
35. World Wide Suicide
36. Gonna See My Friend

This has gotten entirely out of hand.

@SkitchP wrote:This has gotten entirely out of hand.

Just Breathe, man.

@SkitchP wrote:This has gotten entirely out of hand.

You're just four post short of 10k.

@SkitchP wrote:This has gotten entirely out of hand.

Yeah this thread is a real shit show.

It's tied for the worst thread with that LB or Backspacwr thread.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:

@SkitchP wrote:This has gotten entirely out of hand.

Yeah this thread is a real shit show.

Just getting you guys ready for the U.S. Tour.

Wikipedia:

In June 2003, Pearl Jam announced it was officially leaving Epic Records following the end of its contract with the label. The band stated it had "no interest" in signing with another label. The band's first release without a label was the single for "Man of the Hour", in partnership with Amazon.com.

Note:

http://www.businesswire.com/news/home/2 ... ogram-Sell

SEATTLE (BUSINESS WIRE) Dec. 17, 2003

"Amazon.com (Nasdaq:AMZN) and Pearl Jam today announced the band's enrollment in Amazon.com's Advantage for Music program. The arrangement enables Pearl Jam to sell their new CD single, "Man of the Hour," directly to Amazon.com's millions of customers worldwide."

I think, MOTH is the milestone of PRAMG

Yeah, hard to argue that a song released after Riot Act, and written for a movie released in partnership with Amazon should not be included in the PRAMG category.