Re: The Official GIGATON Thread
Posted: Fri March 27, 2020 2:31 pm
Ms Harmless wrote:I've now bought this album in like 6 different formats

Ms Harmless wrote:I've now bought this album in like 6 different formats

You're putting in solid work here trying to convince people to not like the album!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
that's not true!!Strat wrote:You're putting in solid work here trying to convince people to not like the album!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
Im gonna have a bourbon county stout tonight while listening to this REALLY LOUDChris_H_2 wrote:that's not true!!Strat wrote:You're putting in solid work here trying to convince people to not like the album!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
If I recall correctly, there was a new thread created when the actual album came out.Strat wrote:I just perused through the Lightning Bolt thread.FlatSideofaDog wrote:Been meaning to do this, too.Bammer wrote:I am gonna go back and read everyone’s early impressions of Backspacer and Lightning Bolt now.
Kind of funny. It was 1,300 pages of anticipation and excitement but once the album was released around Mid October, there was little to no posting. Just dropped off.
RM died that day.
Strat wrote:Im gonna have a bourbon county stout tonight while listening to this REALLY LOUDChris_H_2 wrote:that's not true!!Strat wrote:You're putting in solid work here trying to convince people to not like the album!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
well saidHuell wrote:What is surprising to me is it’s like Eddie’s been AWOL since RA. He was over compensating with the Rawk. His performances were missing a lot of the authenticity and the things only he can do. That and there is room in the album.Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
Ed tried really hard on S/T to create a profound, contemporary rock album and he just fell short. Has been adrift since. Seems like he has it back now.EJ wrote:well saidHuell wrote:What is surprising to me is it’s like Eddie’s been AWOL since RA. He was over compensating with the Rawk. His performances were missing a lot of the authenticity and the things only he can do. That and there is room in the album.Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
I was cautiously optimistic for Lightning Bolt when a few of the songs leaked, but when the whole thing came out, I had a resigned feeling of "at least it's better than Backspacer, but it's not all that good on the whole." I wish I was more active when Backspacer came out because I thought it was awful, and apparently there was a lot of positive responses among this forum. Might have been fun to be one of the dissenting voices.FlatSideofaDog wrote:Been meaning to do this, too.Bammer wrote:I am gonna go back and read everyone’s early impressions of Backspacer and Lightning Bolt now.
oh my god, if you say that you'll also be wearing lululemon i won't be able to lastStrat wrote:Im gonna have a bourbon county stout tonight while listening to this REALLY LOUDChris_H_2 wrote:that's not true!!Strat wrote:You're putting in solid work here trying to convince people to not like the album!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
Yes, yes, this.stip wrote:I feel like half this record is made of bridges. that might be why its so good
well FINE, BE like that!!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
This fascinates me. I don't think I've seen a ranking that interests me as much as this one does.WtOB? wrote:5 stars -
dance
7 o’clock
never destination
retrograde
i also think they suffered from trying to pigeonhole every band member's contributions into the albums (they still kind of suffered from that with this album, but not to such a large extent). it made the albums really messy, with no coherent sound.Monkey_Driven wrote:Ed tried really hard on S/T to create a profound, contemporary rock album and he just fell short. Has been adrift since. Seems like he has it back now.EJ wrote:well saidHuell wrote:What is surprising to me is it’s like Eddie’s been AWOL since RA. He was over compensating with the Rawk. His performances were missing a lot of the authenticity and the things only he can do. That and there is room in the album.Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.
can i let you in on a little secret?Ms Harmless wrote:well FINE, BE like that!!Chris_H_2 wrote:I'm seeing a lot of "this is the best album since . . . " and it's mostly followed by either s/t or riot act. I like this new album a lot, but i attribute these statements less to the quality of this album and more to the abject failures of the last 2 albums.
put another way, these statements aren't saying anything at all.