Page 2 of 2
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 4:57 am
by LetMeSleep
PHATJ wrote:Levee is the only song that is legitimately better than Stairway in the entire Zeppelin catalogue. Both are deserving of the short list of Best Rock Songs in History.
I also know that RM being what it is, Levee is the only song to possibly knock over Achilles and thus I'm reconsidering my vote.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 5:06 am
by PHATJ
LetMeSleep wrote:PHATJ wrote:Levee is the only song that is legitimately better than Stairway in the entire Zeppelin catalogue. Both are deserving of the short list of Best Rock Songs in History.
I also know that RM being what it is, Levee is the only song to possibly knock over Achilles and thus I'm reconsidering my vote.
YES!
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 5:20 am
by LoathedVermin72
I really don't get Stairway. It's not in the same universe as Levee.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 5:23 am
by PHATJ
I totally get Stairway, and I love it. But Levee is just better.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 1:22 pm
by stip
Open another day, which is good because I’ve been back and forth on my vote all day
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 1:48 pm
by @SkitchP
I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 2:01 pm
by wease
@SkitchP wrote:I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
But I voted Loving You and you’re punishing me with this vote.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 2:06 pm
by PHATJ
wease wrote:@SkitchP wrote:I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
But I voted Loving You and you’re punishing me with this vote.
And I lied about voting for Rain Song.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 2:28 pm
by LoathedVermin72
I voted for Since I've Been Loving You. Please vote for Levee.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 6:02 pm
by Birds in Hell
Hold your nerve, Skitch.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 7:10 pm
by @SkitchP
PHATJ wrote:wease wrote:@SkitchP wrote:I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
But I voted Loving You and you’re punishing me with this vote.
And I lied about voting for Rain Song.
Well now you need to be punished for a lack of integrity.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 7:40 pm
by Norah
RM was wrong on every match this round.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 7:47 pm
by Jammer XCI
Seriously needs some reevaluation at least.
I’m not a fan of this punitive style voting where one guy votes against a song because someone else is a fan, or someone solicits their vote in exchange for someone else’s vote or whatever. It’s cool that we can change our votes later, but then this sort of exchange emerges. What happened to voting for the song you like more?
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 9:40 pm
by wease
Jammer XCI wrote:Seriously needs some reevaluation at least.
I’m not a fan of this punitive style voting where one guy votes against a song because someone else is a fan, or someone solicits their vote in exchange for someone else’s vote or whatever. It’s cool that we can change our votes later, but then this sort of exchange emerges. What happened to voting for the song you like more?
Every vote I make is based on that.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 10:11 pm
by @SkitchP
Jesus christ you guys are so serious. I was voting Stairway either way. Sheesh.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 10:19 pm
by epilogue
It's like they've never participated in an RM tournament before.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sat November 18, 2017 10:33 pm
by evenslow
I'm really surprised that When the
- Spoiler: show
Breaks is gonna lose.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sun November 19, 2017 2:56 am
by PHATJ
@SkitchP wrote:PHATJ wrote:wease wrote:@SkitchP wrote:I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
But I voted Loving You and you’re punishing me with this vote.
And I lied about voting for Rain Song.
Well now you need to be punished for a lack of integrity.
I lied about lying.
Re: 70. Stairway to Heaven vs. When the Levee Breaks
Posted: Sun November 19, 2017 5:58 pm
by dpupenya
PHATJ wrote:@SkitchP wrote:PHATJ wrote:wease wrote:@SkitchP wrote:I just cast the 31st vote, breaking the 15-15 deadlock.
How did I make my pick?
The last person to have a post indicating they picked Rain Song over Since Ive Been Loving You was PhatJ
and I am 100% committed to finding a way to punish anyone that played a role in the elimination of Since Ive Been Loving You.
But I voted Loving You and you’re punishing me with this vote.
And I lied about voting for Rain Song.
Well now you need to be punished for a lack of integrity.
I lied about lying.
LIAR!