Red Mosquito

This "Ultimate" list is now completely invalid. This all matters even less than it ever did. So... Who cares. Cropduster, I guess. But any of them are fine.

Rob wrote:

E.H. Ruddock wrote:If you guys leave Tremor Christ, the best Pearl jam song there is, off of this, then this thing really is a sham

I thought I saw someone say this is more about the fun of the process than the outcome.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:If you guys leave Tremor Christ, the best Pearl jam song there is, off of this, then this thing really is a sham

Dude, it's already a sham! Might as well own it at this point.

I mean, picking the wrong song off of one of their shitty albums is one thing, but leaving off arguably one of their best songs and the best off of a good album is something else and completely asinine

I went back and listened to some of these. I picked my first choice : Tremor christ. I find it unique in terms of mood and sound, kind of punk-noise. The bass is simply gorgeous, the guitars hypnotizing, the drum is groovy.

Come on, I want the result to be surprising and the process fun.

I like that we don't proceed in order. The final tracklist should be interesting !

E.H. Ruddock wrote:I mean, picking the wrong song off of one of their shitty albums is one thing, but leaving off arguably one of their best songs and the best off of a good album is something else and completely asinine

I see it the other way around. Vitalogy is arguably the best album and TC is a really good song on it, but to me there's 4-5 better songs on the album.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:I mean, picking the wrong song off of one of their shitty albums is one thing, but leaving off arguably one of their best songs and the best off of a good album is something else and completely asinine

We'll vote Corduroy on soon enough.

What’s the opposite of “ultimate’”?

Bammer wrote:What’s the opposite of “ultimate’”?

Antimate.

E.H. Ruddock wrote:I mean, picking the wrong song off of one of their shitty albums is one thing, but leaving off arguably one of their best songs and the best off of a good album is something else and completely asinine

completely agree with what you’re saying about sleight of hand here.

i’m not about to have some sgt.-crackpot-style meltdown about it though.

if garden is the ten song that makes it we royally fucked up

stip wrote:if garden is the ten song that makes it we royally fucked up

It'll be black. But Get Right might be on this thing.

WtOB? wrote:i’m not about to have some sgt.-crackpot-style meltdown about it though.

If you think that's a meltdown, then your life mustn't be very exciting at the moment.

durdencommatyler wrote:This "Ultimate" list is now completely invalid. This all matters even less than it ever did. So... Who cares. Cropduster, I guess. But any of them are fine.

Didn't you vote for Force of Nature?

Bammer wrote:What’s the opposite of “ultimate’”?

This

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

WtOB? wrote:i’m not about to have some sgt.-crackpot-style meltdown about it though.

If you think that's a meltdown, then your life mustn't be very exciting at the moment.

woah, dude. take it easy. that was aimed at ruddo.

WtOB? wrote:

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

WtOB? wrote:i’m not about to have some sgt.-crackpot-style meltdown about it though.

If you think that's a meltdown, then your life mustn't be very exciting at the moment.

woah, dude. take it easy. that was aimed at ruddo.

Storm in a teacup, bub.

Wait a minute. If this thing is only 12 songs long does that mean no Immortality!?! That blows

Guess I’ll go tremor Christ then

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

WtOB? wrote:

Sgt. Crackpot wrote:

WtOB? wrote:i’m not about to have some sgt.-crackpot-style meltdown about it though.

If you think that's a meltdown, then your life mustn't be very exciting at the moment.

woah, dude. take it easy. that was aimed at ruddo.

Storm in a teacup, bub.

aren’t you supposed to be a mod? you shouldn’t let your emotions cloud your posting. how can we trust you to make the big decisions?